Favorite campaign that you NEVER played/ran.

Reynard · May 17, 2026

We all have campaigns we have intended to run, or really wanted to play in, that either fizzled out or never materialized in the first place.

What is the campaign that you really wished you got to play or run? What went wrong? Is there a chance to do it yet, or has that ship sailed?

Thomas Shey · May 17, 2026

Probably the sequal campaign to my Claves post-apocalypse/cyberpunk/anime-ish mecha campaign using a mix of Mekton and Cyberpunk applied to a Fuzion chassis. Did pretty much all the work for it, then realized both groups I was running for had no-go players for it. Taught me not to do campaign prep before I had buy-in.

Whisper-Kitten · May 17, 2026

The one where I brought back players into an old gladiator game that I ran in the past.

Agamon · May 17, 2026

I bought the Lot5R Second City boxed set 10 years ago, and traded it away last year unplayed. Looked interesting, but never got around it.

FitzTheRuke · May 17, 2026

Wow. I can't remember missing any. Can I really have never misses out? I suppose that I have a handful that didn't finish, but none that I never got to run or play for at least a good while.

payn · May 18, 2026

I played in a short lived War for the Crown AP in PF1. Started out promising but the GM took a lot of liberties and I'm not sure we were even playing it anymore after about 3rd level.

Id love to run this someday but im not likley to ever find a group. There was a local PF con here about a year ago and the silent auction had all 6 chapters in softback. I tried to bid but lost. Id pick up the PDFs but again im not sure it would ever hit the table

aco175 · May 18, 2026

Over the years I wanted to always play Temple of Elemental Evil (ToEE) and never had the chance. Even the updated version of 2e and 3e looked cool and fun. We did play the 5e Elemental Evil book Prices of the Apocalypse (PotA) and that was ok to fine. I think now I am ok with not playing the original.

We tried playing Tomb of Horrors (ToH) a few times but kept dying before long and gave up on it.

Never played the Bloodstone Lands series as well and heard it was good.

sevenbastard · May 18, 2026

The Enemy Within is my dream. I bought it but refuse to read it in hopes someone will run it for me.

zarionofarabel · May 18, 2026

A full length Great Pendragon Campaign.

Autumnal · May 18, 2026

A Dark Ages: Vampire chronicle where the PCs were very recent childer of a cabal of ancient 5th generation vampires planning an end run around conventional vampire politics. Chargen was great, and then I had one of my extended physical and mental slumps.