Forgotten Realms:Homeland Review

Truth Seeker

Adventurer
Just got it today...barely, there was one copy left on the shelf. (I took two before the last). I will be viewing it later. Can't say much now, at work and it is busy.

First things first...I am not a fan, or truly familiar in depth with any of R.A. Salvatore's works *reading wise, but have heard enough*, nor am I not a chest-deep player of the Forgotten Realms Lore and it's materials. So, whatever is said here, is from a comic book collector's POV, nothing more, and nothing less.

Comic collecting has been in my blood since the pre-teens days for me. Still remember X-Men #109, and the very first appearance of Captain Britian, in my mind's eye. But anyway, enough of the ole' flashbacks. To the subject at hand.

Review:Well, with miminal fanfare, the first of several mini-series titles from Forgotten Realms trademark has been revisited for a third time. Not going to rehash the history on the former two titles that came out before.

Art:Nothing to sneeze or cry foul over. The illustrations are simple, so simple, that a young child with a good reading comprehension can understand what is going. Pencils by Tim Seely, & Inks by Andrew Pepoy. 48 pages(no ads) of Drow life, has been capture with all the near familiarity, that can put in these pages. For those who know the Drow ways of life. Nothing was left out. Hairstyle, clothing, surroundings and such.

Colors:Capturing the feel on how the Drow will look, is without a doubt, very important. And BLOND*must be a outside sourcing unit* bring life to the pages, with the same premise as the pencils and inks, nothing too grand or too little. Everything is clean and crisp and seeable. The panels are simple also, nothing too jarring.

And now for the Story:Translating anything from a novel to a comic book, is never a 100% correct, but when you have the original author, that is a different story. Like I said before, I never read any of his books and don't plan to. So, for me, it is going to be fun to watch the nickpickers go over this revise work, that has been put into this format. And since the story was done before the revise Wotc stat rules on the Drow, like the ability levitate is not there anymore. You will get to see it in action, in the book.

Conclusion:As a collector of the comic fad and a player in the D&D genre, seeing the mixture of both hobbies woven together, does bring out that careful and nickpick eye to find major faults in this book series. And if it was design to bring a younger crowd to the readership and playing fields of Dungeon & Dragons...the premise could be smothered by one thing, the price...at $4.95.

Everyone who has visited a comic book shop these days...knows that 'kids' don't loiter around there, expect for the older adult 'kids'...like me. As a collector and player, I will get it for the information, illustrations on the Drow's surroundings. As for the story, I know almost everyone knows of Drizzt. So no need for me to nickpick there. I am just going to read and see how it turns out.

Well, no major faults to scream on, and nothing to rave in the glorious light.

My original rating would have been 3 out of 5, but it will get a 4, for NO ADS...just the way I like to read my books. And sorry, no MAJOR spoilers, you just have to buy it and see for yourself.:p
 
Last edited:

log in or register to remove this ad

I picked it up myself, and well... I was unimpressed. The story of Drizzt's upbringing is glossed over entirely too quickly- even moreso than in the book, Homeland. The dialogue falls flat in a lot of places- with characters providing exposition that is obviously intended to inform readers about how Drow society works, but that comes across as unbelievable from the characters themselves (who are drow, and don't need to have their own culture explained to them by others).

The artwork is not terribly impressive- passable, but it has some failings. The children's heads are too inflated and cherubic, though that's a minor nitpick. Chiefly, there are some key story elements that could have benefited very well from a visual depiction (as opposed to simply a textual one)- notable among these is the famed cross-sword parry that Zaknafein uses on Drizzt in the novels; here is is barely identifiable and is shown at a strange angle and in shadow. When it happens again, later, and Drizzt finally counters it, it will probably come across as a "huh?" moment. Another scene that would have greatly benefited from the visual format is when Masoj Hun'ett scars Alton Devir with acid- rather than simply having him say "I'm going to get the acid" (as happens here), it would have been far more effective (and character defining) IMO to show it happening.

Anyway, I was hoping for a lot more. Devil's Due's "Legend of Huma" and "Hedge Knight" renditions were very impressive efforts (and I didn't like the LoH novel, so that's pretty darn impressive to me), but this was just a disappointment. I won't be picking up the rest of the series.
 

Looks like no one else bought the book, but it was nearly gone but the time I got it. Oh well.:\ One in-between review and one against. Erm...not pleasant.
 

Where do these exist?

I've never heard of them.

Where can I get them?

I'm a big fan of the FR & still pick up the novels as they come out.

I fully the WotC schedule pretty closely & never saw these.

Can someone give a link to where I can pcik these up?

Thanks.
 

Vraille Darkfang said:
Can someone give a link to where I can pcik these up?

The first issue (of three) just came out this past Wednesday. You should be able to find it in most comic book stores near you. Alternatively, you can can order the book directly from Devil's Due via their Web Store.
 

Vraille Darkfang said:
Where do these exist?

I've never heard of them.

Where can I get them?

I'm a big fan of the FR & still pick up the novels as they come out.

I fully the WotC schedule pretty closely & never saw these.

Can someone give a link to where I can pcik these up?

Thanks.
A bigger question, where the blazes have you been?:lol:
 


RangerWickett said:
I hadn't heard anything about them either. Never saw them advertised or even mentioned until now.

There was a blurb on the front page some time ago about Devil's Due picking up licensing rights for D&D comics, though I don't remember when. I actually remembered it more from an article on Newsarama.

Devil's Due did a graphic adaptation of Legend of Huma several months (a year or so?) back, and it was pretty good, though I didn't get all of it, due to financial considerations at the time. In the interim is when they got the licensing rights to Forgotten Realms properties, which they are leading off with the Drizzt adaptation. Don't recall if they have other properties in the D&D line licensed (though I think they do), and so far, the only thing they've announced is the Dark Elf adaptation.
 

Cthulhudrew said:
There was a blurb on the front page some time ago about Devil's Due picking up licensing rights for D&D comics, though I don't remember when. I actually remembered it more from an article on Newsarama.

Devil's Due did a graphic adaptation of Legend of Huma several months (a year or so?) back, and it was pretty good, though I didn't get all of it, due to financial considerations at the time. In the interim is when they got the licensing rights to Forgotten Realms properties, which they are leading off with the Drizzt adaptation. Don't recall if they have other properties in the D&D line licensed (though I think they do), and so far, the only thing they've announced is the Dark Elf adaptation.

Almost forgot to add this, the only way I found out the release date, I had to go digging literally into DD forums for info. And someone was kind enough to put a preview page and the release date (which posted on 6.29.05 SCI FI page *comics* section). Some parts of DD are NOT updated on a daily basis.

Comic News 4.08.05 This is what was last posted.
Comic News 4.01.05 This was a follow up to Krug's report
First posted by Krug:News at Wotc; 3.30.05
 
Last edited:

Here's a link to a Newsarama article on the D&D license. Devil's Due to Acquire D&D License. As TruthSeeker notes, it doesn't mention the release date anywhere in there, just that it starts in June.

The Legend of Huma is supposed to have come out as a trade paperback last month, though I don't recall seeing it in stores at all. It may not be out yet. You'd probably have to check the Devil's Due website for more. (As TS also notes, that website doesn't seem to be regularly updated. Wonder if they need a webmaster... hmm.)
 

Remove ads

Top