General star wars talk/discussion/complaining

[Zardnaar]

That would cause a bunch of crybabies would start crying as soon as they announce a non-white actress playing Dr. Aphra

Which means they should definitely do it

Whats her ethnicity in the comics? Whatever it is cast someone who can pass for it.

Disclaimer haven't read a Vader comic or any Disney book or comic.

 

[Reynard]

Whats her ethnicity in the comics? Whatever it is cast someone who can pass for it.

Disclaimer haven't read a Vader comic or any Disney book or comic.

"Vader Down" is worth the price of admission.

 

[Zardnaar]

"Vader Down" is worth the price of admission.

Burn me once though.. ..

Vader would be a problem for a feature film beyond a cameo.

You can really only portray him as a monster. Anything thats not a Jefi master or equivalent should get chopped to pieces. Even they need to run imho.

Paint, corner.

 

[Reynard]

Burn me once though.. ..

Vader would be a problem for a feature film beyond a cameo.

You can really only portray him as a monster. Anything thats not a Jefi master or equivalent should get chopped to pieces. Even they need to run imho.

Paint, corner.

Have you read Vader Down?

 

[Zardnaar]

Have you read Vader Down?

Nope.

I dont read Disney books/comics. Ive heard the Vader co.ics, lost stars and Thrawn stuff is good.

 

[Reynard]

Nope.

I dont read Disney books/comics. Ive heard the Vader co.ics, lost stars and Thrawn stuff is good.

I get that. But Vader proves he could do more than a cameo. And still be the monster.

 

[Zardnaar]

I get that. But Vader proves he could do more than a cameo. And still be the monster.

No idea. What works in a comic or videogame though may not work live action or animated.

Not impossible but its basically hard to defeat Vader. Even if a story shows that it doesnt really matter because you cant kill him off. (Thats convenient effect).

Arguably undermines Luke's achievement as well. Didn't work so well in Force Unleashed game where you could outright kill him.

Theres not much you can do with him imho. Rogue One and Shadow Lord arguably he's used right.

See reception in Obi Wan. Doesn't contradict the movies subject to 10 years being a long time.

Vader seems to be less is more.

 

[gnarlygninja]

No one (well, almost no one) beats Vader in a straight up fight in those comics. He gets outmaneuvered, and sometimes the other person "winning" just means they didn't die. A bigger problem (for me) is I'm not excited to hear dead actors speak new lines.

 

[Reynard]

No one (well, almost no one) beats Vader in a straight up fight in those comics. He gets outmaneuvered, and sometimes the other person "winning" just means they didn't die. A bigger problem (for me) is I'm not excited to hear dead actors speak new lines.

That ship has sailed and JEJ made that deal knowingly.

 

[chuckdee]

Doubtful. They would absolutely want to go with an actress of East Asian descent. Someone with comedy chops, too

Cue Awkwafina