D&D 5.5E (2024) Grappling does not prevent spellcasting in 5e?!

There does seem to be a large contingent of players who have a phobia for house rules or homebrew for various reasons. Oftentimes these are not good reasons. For example, duplicating a feat or spell is a really bad reason. It assumes there should be only one way to do something, and that all feats and spells are well-crafted. Both are definitely not true.

I'm stricter than average as a DM, but I like making house rules and homebrew. With one important condition, they should be declared and vetted ahead of time, then made official for that table. If rules are changing in the middle of the game, it's not a fair game. It's fundamental to games that you plot the best strategy given the rules known to you.

I agree 100% on house rules. I don't have a phobia of house rules, however I play in a lot of games with a lot of different groups and using rules as written as a baseline provides a common framework for everyone to start from if they have not been playing with each other for years.

In this respect when I am looking for a new game I want the DM to say what houserules exist in their game in session 0 before we start playing. Ideally they have a list of houserules ahead of time. Also as far as things unexpected go I would expect a DM to stick with that agreement unless it is really, really bad. As an example from the first 2024 game I played - the DM said we are in a high magic town and we have the ability to purchase any magic item from the DMG at the price listed. That resulted in most of the party purchasing a ring of resistance for every damage type and then purchasing one or more vicious weapons due to changes in the 2024 rules. It was miserable for the DM, but he stuck it out through level 20. At the begining of the next campaign he restricted players to one ring per hand and only specific magic items were available for purchase.

Houserules is different from rulings though. Using the sand example, that is a ruling but it is only a houserule if the DM has an established rule that are the mechanics for throwing something in someone's eye to blind them. Further making that ruling on the spot does not necessarily tie them to it in the future. If the player did this on the beach yesterday it does not mean they will be able to do it with the same mechanics on a dirt road in town tomorrow.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Houserules is different from rulings though. Using the sand example, that is a ruling but it is only a houserule if the DM has an established rule that are the mechanics for throwing something in someone's eye to blind them. Further making that ruling on the spot does not necessarily tie them to it in the future. If the player did this on the beach yesterday it does not mean they will be able to do it with the same mechanics on a dirt road in town tomorrow.

True, but it's not a good experience if "how things work" keeps changing. If you allow something to happen with beach sand, and on later reflection decide that it shouldn't set a precedent for the remainder of the campaign, you should probably make that explicitly clear before the next session (or, anyway, before they start planning for a situation where they may rely on replicating that action) rather than surprising them just as they next attempt it. Otherwise, there might be a contentious discussion regarding how they only did X because they thought that you'd allow them to do Y, etc, and some eventual rolling-back of time.
 

True, but it's not a good experience if "how things work" keeps changing.

I think this captures the difference between a rule and a ruling. A rule is how things work, is generally appliable. A ruling is specific to a situation.

You could argue the "rule of cool" even comes into play here if you consider that as a rule that applies when a PC tries something memorable or creative, but the rule of cool does not apply if they are now doing it every single encounter.

If you allow something to happen with beach sand, and on later reflection decide that it shouldn't set a precedent for the remainder of the campaign, you should probably make that explicitly clear before the next session (or, anyway, before they start planning for a situation where they may rely on replicating that action) rather than surprising them just as they next attempt it.

I would agree, but in the scenario presented they were not setting a precedent it was a specific thing they were doing at a specific time and place. This is fundamentally different than asking for mechanics for throwing sand in someone's face generally.
 

I think this captures the difference between a rule and a ruling. A rule is how things work, is generally appliable. A ruling is specific to a situation.

You could argue the "rule of cool" even comes into play here if you consider that as a rule that applies when a PC tries something memorable or creative, but the rule of cool does not apply if they are now doing it every single encounter.
Is 'throwing sand' really memorable or creative? One of the things I've never really liked about 'rule of cool' discussion online is that a lot of examples people use are really bland. I don't think just throwing sand at an experienced combatant who's ready for a deadly fight would be all that effective, and I don't think it's a creative idea, it's something people do IRL and something easily seen in movies, plus there's the 'pocket sand' meme. I don't think 'rule of cool' is good if what it means is 'if I add a little bit of narration referencing a meme, I suddenly become twice as powerful in game'

In the actual example, I would just have throwing sand be the narration for the help action, giving the next attack against the orc advantage. No save or hit chance, but also not giving everyone advantage against him for a round, his own attacks disadvantage, and shut down his opportunity attacks (depending on exactly when the blindness ends). I don't think that every minor thing someone does in combat needs a special rule, or needs to be made incredibly effective, I think it's fine to narrate minor things as part of the flavor of combat without creating lots of mechanics, and without making them into extreme power moves.

I didn't want to throw this in on the original reply because it's a tangent to the issue of 'players declaring DM can't do that', but that discussion seems to have gone quiet.
 


Of course the DM can come up with a ruling for how to stop/gag/etc. a spellcaster.

It's a bit weird it's not in the RAW, though.

I suspect that the designers generally wanted to avoid making it ~straightforward to neutralize what would often be a huge part of the power budget. Similarly, the rules by default means that martials rarely have to worry about losing their equipment -- disarming is an optional rule hidden in the DMG (at least in 2014), and there's little support for damaging equipment that is currently worn or wielded outside of specific monster abilities.

As a result there certainly are some unanswered questions such as "how do city guards safely imprison a criminally-minded wizard", but that's something for DMs to just homebrew if it actually comes up.
 


What slow down the game with drinking a potion is not that it uses a Bonus Action to do so, it's the action of doing so and rolling the dice that comes with it. Doing it as part of the movement or action doesn't really make it much faster just check Free Item Interaction as an example.
 

What slow down the game with drinking a potion is not that it uses a Bonus Action to do so, it's the action of doing so and rolling the dice that comes with it. Doing it as part of the movement or action doesn't really make it much faster just check Free Item Interaction as an example.
I think you wanted to post this in another thread? XD

I agree though. And just making potions heal a fixed amount would already be a bit faster.
 


Remove ads

Top