D&D 5.5E (2024) Grappling does not prevent spellcasting in 5e?!

When reading posts on a message board, one has to interpret what they mean to engage with them. If I'm making an unwarranted presumption about what you mean when I'm attempting to interpret your posts, you could explain what you actually mean to show that I'm being unreasonable. If all you do is say something that amounts to 'oh no, you have interpreted what I said as meaning something, stop doing that', well...

Seriously, I have no idea what calling the current level of rules about stopping spellcasting 'weird' would mean other than that the person calling it weird thinks that those rules should be at a different level of detail.
I don't owe you jack. You just don't have to presume I'm making a comparison to a previous edition of the game. Maybe I just think a couple of lines for newbies you have never played D&D before would be helpful.

If you can't engage with my posts without presumption, don't engage, please and thank you.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

I don't owe you jack. You just don't have to presume I'm making a comparison to a previous edition of the game. Maybe I just think a couple of lines for newbies you have never played D&D before would be helpful.
This response is odd because the game does have a couple of lines of text on the topic, it just doesn't have detailed rules for gags or gagging or unfreeing hands.
If you can't engage with my posts without presumption, don't engage, please and thank you.
Don't worry, I'm done trying to engage with whatever idea you are attempting to convey, I'll just point out factual inaccuracies like the above if they catch my eye.
 


Mod note:

@Eric V and @Dessert Nomad

I think we all have to wonder if either of you really find this to be an enlightening or constructive way to engage with each other, especially in public.

So, maybe, stop? Thanks.
 

5e doesn’t have any rule-based condition that hinders spell casting, last I checked. Shutting down spell casting by blocking components requires narrative positioning and GM agreement (i.e. tying up and gagging a spell caster is sufficient to bar them from V,S,M components.)

Incapacitated (and all the things that cause Incapacitated) eliminate all actions, including all spells as far as I am aware. It also ends concentration on a spell already in progress.

Being silenced, while not a specific condtion eliminates all spells with a Verbal component.

Being blinded eliminates all spells that require you to see the target, which is most of the offensive combat spells.
 

Incapacitated (and all the things that cause Incapacitated) eliminate all actions, including all spells as far as I am aware. It also ends concentration on a spell already in progress.

Being silenced, while not a specific condtion eliminates all spells with a Verbal component.

Being blinded eliminates all spells that require you to see the target, which is most of the offensive combat spells.
Sorry, I meant specifically in the case of grappling.

Does holding down a mage’s hands block S components and/or M components (can’t reach them)?

Does putting your hand over their mouth block V components?

Does covering their eyes cause the blinded condition (and thus block line of sight)?

Those are all common narratives for what happens when two humanoids grapple that people often look for the game rules to adjudicate, but in 5e relies on GM’s judgment to decide.
 

The current design is built around class balance, not detailed simulation.
Should a CR 2 berserker (+3 Str, frenzied advantage on attacks) be able to consistently shut down a level 15 wizard because her grapple prevents all of his spellcasting?
I wouldn't want that for my spellcasting players.
 

The current design is built around class balance, not detailed simulation.
Should a CR 2 berserker (+3 Str, frenzied advantage on attacks) be able to consistently shut down a level 15 wizard because her grapple prevents all of his spellcasting?
I wouldn't want that for my spellcasting players.

I want that for my spellcasting players.

A sneaky level 2 rogue or a raging level 2 barbarian managing to heroically get behind enemy lines (by subterfuge, by a sacrificial charge, or simply by good die rolls) to stop an evil wizard from casting the spell that threatens the whole town sounds like a great game to me.

And a high level party that gets cocky and doesn't bother protecting their main caster, only to have him taken out of battle by a couple mooks that snuck between the lines sounds like an equally deserved fate for a careless 15th level wizard PC.

I'm pretty sure I've seen both in earlier editions and loved it (or loved to hate it, at least).
 

But if grappling cancels spellcasting, it’s not a sneaky highly cinematic moment — it’s overarching world strategy that nerfs spellcasters, almost to the point where they wouldn’t be adventuring.
 

In general, the point of capturing a PC party is to allow them to escape.

The more interesting question is "If the game engine allows for spellcasters to be uncapturable, how does that affect the worldbuilding around how spellcasters are handled?"

My NPCs will just keep them near death at 0 - they can also be gamey..
 

Remove ads

Top