Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Yaarel" data-source="post: 9131678" data-attributes="member: 58172">The species description is discrete. But each species would be followed by three prominent Forgotten Realms cultures where the species is prominent. For the Elf, the Forgotten Realms cultures might be Everelsk (or the island of Evermeet) as examples of the traditional High cultures, the High Forest culture as the homeland of the Wood Elf cultures. Historically, both the High Forest culture and Everelsk and Evermeet cultures derive from the same elven Eaerlann culture in the land that is today Savage Frontier. But now these diaspora elven communities are distinct enough to warrant separate cultural descriptions.At first I assumed the Underdark town of Menzoberranzan with its Lolth Uda culture would continue the Drow traditions. But now I am thinking it is probably better to have a more "normal" non-Evil culture to continue the "drow player race" traditions. Baldurs Gate mentions a Seldarine community. The Elf section might mention the culture of the small Drow enclave in the nearby High Forest. Its citizens might be Loren culture immigrants. Perhaps there is the Aeven culture that is prominent somewhere under the glaciers of the Ice Wind Dales region. Possibly a more distant Loren culture in Chuult is possible, and its tree-canopy there.If Menzoberranzan is absent from the Players Handbook, it means it and its Uda citizens are controlled by the members of the theocratic Lolth faction that is "typically Chaotic Evil". There are still Good Elves who inhabit Menzoberranzan but they grow up with it being normal for the faction to be in power, and they fear it. The faction hidden away in the Underdark can be a locale from where the DM can introduce some of the more villainous Drow traditions.We dont know enough about the various Drow cultures: Uda, Aeven, Loren, and High Forest might be its own distinct culture. I assume Drow are an elven ethnicity who share the same historical origin, but each culture of the diaspora evolves differently. Possibly, Uda, Aeven, and Loren are prominent branches, who historically separate from each other during a civil war in response to when Lolth transmogrified into a Fiend.Notably, because these are Backgrounds, they wont be a genericized Forgotten Realms. The Backgrounds can be setting-specific and are free to refer to the minutia of the Forgotten Realms canon.That said, the Forgotten Realms setting is rife with racism at every level, both reallife racist tropes and racist pseudoscience theories. The unofficial fan websites can be even worse. Some of the websites still refer to "Humanoid" in the sense of monstrous Orc and Goblin, rather than the sense of the 5e creature type that includes Human, Elf, Dwarf, and other humanlike Species as well. It seems difficult to free the Forgotten Realms setting from racism. The official books from 2024 onward must be nonracist. Maybe DnDBeyond can offer a free official guideline to help fan websites avoid racism.Anyway, each species description is setting-neutral, but the three examples of cultures afterward are setting-specific to the Forgotten Realms. Each culture lists prominent backgrounds, which the players can find in the Backgrounds chapter. The Human Species will also list three specific cultures, perhaps one urban, one agrarian, and one nomadic.</blockquote>

Verification