Hey guys. First time poster here. I recently came across the Warrior of Mercy Monk and was looking at Hand of Harm (whether or not it gets multiplied on a critical hit). I think I found the answer for RAW and RAI purposes to both be NO. However, the wider community seems to think it does, so I'll add a detailed breakdown how I came to this conclusion here.
The Feature: Hand of Harm: "Once per turn when you hit a creature with an Unarmed Strike and deal damage, you can expend 1 Focus Point to deal extra Necrotic damage equal to one roll of your Martial Arts die plus your Wisdom modifier."
Quick disclaimer up front: don't get hung up on specific word choices like "extra" vs. "additional," or "after" vs. "when". Those aren't the important part of this argument and can be explained multiple ways (down to semantic discussions, which aren't gonna be helpful). The actual crux is "hit" vs. "hit and deal damage."
The core argument: Features that key off just hitting (Sneak Attack, Smite, Hex, basically everything adding dice to an attack) can trigger the moment the attack roll succeeds aka before the damage roll is even finalized. That means their bonus dice get folded into the same, still-open damage roll, which is why the crit rule's "roll all the attack's damage dice twice" doubles them too.
Hand of Harm, however, requires the attack to hit AND deal damage -> meaning the base damage roll has already happened and resolved before the feature can even trigger. Proof this is a hard requirement, not just phrasing: if you hit a creature immune to Bludgeoning with an unarmed strike (or the creature has an ability to reduce incoming damage), you deal 0 damage, and Hand of Harm can't be used (because you don't deal damage). But you'd have no way of knowing that without the damage roll already having happened. That makes it a separate, subsequent damage event, not part of the attack's original (still-open) damage roll — so it shouldn't be doubled by the crit rule.
Supporting precedent: The Psi Warrior's near-identical Psionic Strike ("immediately after you hit a target... and deal damage... you can expend one Psionic Energy Die... dealing Force damage") got exactly this ruling from Jeremy Crawford: "The damage of the Psi Warrior's Psionic Strike occurs after the attack that delivers it. That damage is therefore not rolled twice on a crit." Worth noting his tweets aren't RAW, but it's a strong signal of intent from an actual designer who wrote both features — and both share the same die-plus-flat-modifier structure, adding to the parallel.
TL;DR: "Hit" alone = triggers before damage is locked in = doubles. "Hit and deal damage" = only triggers after damage is already resolved = separate damage event = doesn't double. Hand of Harm falls in the second bucket.
The Feature: Hand of Harm: "Once per turn when you hit a creature with an Unarmed Strike and deal damage, you can expend 1 Focus Point to deal extra Necrotic damage equal to one roll of your Martial Arts die plus your Wisdom modifier."
Quick disclaimer up front: don't get hung up on specific word choices like "extra" vs. "additional," or "after" vs. "when". Those aren't the important part of this argument and can be explained multiple ways (down to semantic discussions, which aren't gonna be helpful). The actual crux is "hit" vs. "hit and deal damage."
The core argument: Features that key off just hitting (Sneak Attack, Smite, Hex, basically everything adding dice to an attack) can trigger the moment the attack roll succeeds aka before the damage roll is even finalized. That means their bonus dice get folded into the same, still-open damage roll, which is why the crit rule's "roll all the attack's damage dice twice" doubles them too.
Hand of Harm, however, requires the attack to hit AND deal damage -> meaning the base damage roll has already happened and resolved before the feature can even trigger. Proof this is a hard requirement, not just phrasing: if you hit a creature immune to Bludgeoning with an unarmed strike (or the creature has an ability to reduce incoming damage), you deal 0 damage, and Hand of Harm can't be used (because you don't deal damage). But you'd have no way of knowing that without the damage roll already having happened. That makes it a separate, subsequent damage event, not part of the attack's original (still-open) damage roll — so it shouldn't be doubled by the crit rule.
Supporting precedent: The Psi Warrior's near-identical Psionic Strike ("immediately after you hit a target... and deal damage... you can expend one Psionic Energy Die... dealing Force damage") got exactly this ruling from Jeremy Crawford: "The damage of the Psi Warrior's Psionic Strike occurs after the attack that delivers it. That damage is therefore not rolled twice on a crit." Worth noting his tweets aren't RAW, but it's a strong signal of intent from an actual designer who wrote both features — and both share the same die-plus-flat-modifier structure, adding to the parallel.
TL;DR: "Hit" alone = triggers before damage is locked in = doubles. "Hit and deal damage" = only triggers after damage is already resolved = separate damage event = doesn't double. Hand of Harm falls in the second bucket.






