D&D 5E (2024) Hand of Harm (Warrior of Mercy Monk) likely does NOT double on a critical hit

Areoph

Villager
Hey guys. First time poster here. I recently came across the Warrior of Mercy Monk and was looking at Hand of Harm (whether or not it gets multiplied on a critical hit). I think I found the answer for RAW and RAI purposes to both be NO. However, the wider community seems to think it does, so I'll add a detailed breakdown how I came to this conclusion here.

The Feature: Hand of Harm: "Once per turn when you hit a creature with an Unarmed Strike and deal damage, you can expend 1 Focus Point to deal extra Necrotic damage equal to one roll of your Martial Arts die plus your Wisdom modifier."

Quick disclaimer up front: don't get hung up on specific word choices like "extra" vs. "additional," or "after" vs. "when". Those aren't the important part of this argument and can be explained multiple ways (down to semantic discussions, which aren't gonna be helpful). The actual crux is "hit" vs. "hit and deal damage."

The core argument:
Features that key off just hitting (Sneak Attack, Smite, Hex, basically everything adding dice to an attack) can trigger the moment the attack roll succeeds aka before the damage roll is even finalized. That means their bonus dice get folded into the same, still-open damage roll, which is why the crit rule's "roll all the attack's damage dice twice" doubles them too.

Hand of Harm, however, requires the attack to hit AND deal damage -> meaning the base damage roll has already happened and resolved before the feature can even trigger. Proof this is a hard requirement, not just phrasing: if you hit a creature immune to Bludgeoning with an unarmed strike (or the creature has an ability to reduce incoming damage), you deal 0 damage, and Hand of Harm can't be used (because you don't deal damage). But you'd have no way of knowing that without the damage roll already having happened. That makes it a separate, subsequent damage event, not part of the attack's original (still-open) damage roll — so it shouldn't be doubled by the crit rule.

Supporting precedent: The Psi Warrior's near-identical Psionic Strike ("immediately after you hit a target... and deal damage... you can expend one Psionic Energy Die... dealing Force damage") got exactly this ruling from Jeremy Crawford: "The damage of the Psi Warrior's Psionic Strike occurs after the attack that delivers it. That damage is therefore not rolled twice on a crit." Worth noting his tweets aren't RAW, but it's a strong signal of intent from an actual designer who wrote both features — and both share the same die-plus-flat-modifier structure, adding to the parallel.

TL;DR: "Hit" alone = triggers before damage is locked in = doubles. "Hit and deal damage" = only triggers after damage is already resolved = separate damage event = doesn't double. Hand of Harm falls in the second bucket.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

@Areoph welcome to the boards.

The logic seems sound that you need to deal damage for that to work and crits deal extra damage on the dice rolled- which happens before this power. I suspect that many will just allow it since it is more dice and dice are doubled.

The wording might also be for things that do not damage on a hit which I'm not thinking of right now. Adding this for those situations to not use the power, but allow for the critical attacks/hits.
 


Welcome in Areoph !

I would allow Hand of Harm to benefit on a Critical Hit because it's an extra damage, meaning its part of the attack's damage, and not it's own damage instance.

Critical Hits: A Critical Hit lets you roll extra dice for the attack’s damage against the target.

Critical Hits: Roll the attack’s damage dice twice, add them together, and add any relevant modifiers as normal.
 

I guess it is worded this way to prevent you from doing extra damage if you chose the push or grab option of unarmed strike.

During the playtest you just chose the option after hitting the target, not before making the attack roll. This might be a remnant of that rule.

If you read the grappler feat carefully we also see that the change of the unarmed strike options was not completely incorportated in the final rules, as a strict reading of the grappler feat does not make sense anymore.
 

Thank you all for the welcomes and replies :). I'll just go over in order.

@aco 175: yeah that's the gist of it. Frankly, even this RAW reading (Which I think it is btw) can be interpreted somewhat flexibly and it's obviously up to the DM to decide. But it's almost certainly not RAW and very likely not RAI either (given the Psionic Strike example. The only other "extra" damage that depends on dealing damage for the effect to trigger and incidentally also the only one, I'm aware of, that has the same Dice + Attribute scaling)

@Umbran: Yeah it's possible. Funnily enough there's also the example when fighting another Monk that uses Deflect Attack to reduce damage to 0 (Also barring use of Hand of Mercy).

@Plaguescarred: Of course you can. Heck it's a pen and paper game so you can do pretty much anything you want. It's probably just not RAW since it explicitly depends on dealing damage (instead of all the other features that depend on hitting only). Supported by the Psionic Strike example (only other feature I'm aware off that depends both on hitting and damaging and incidentally also the only other feature that deals Dice + Modifier damage). I wouldn't get hung up on the "extra". It's functionally identical to additional, which some other effects that multiply on a crit use. It's basically semantics (Which 5.5 as well as 5e are unfortunately rather poor at) so we have to look at the "trigger" condition, which is damage already being present (the step at which extra damage would usually get multiplied). I think there's also a rather large hint that this is the RAI interpretation given its similarity to Psionic Strike.

@UngeheuerLich: Yeah my suspicion is that this went through a few iteration and ended up being worded this way because of that (classic 5.5e muddiness). I just think the "hit and deal damage" part makes it functionally so similar to Psionic Strike that it's hard to argue that either RAW or RAI it gets multiplied on a critical hit, because it's a separate instance of damage.
 

I agree with the others saying that I would rule that you would get the crit damage on hand of harm and they've covered the reasons.

I would also add that when evaluating rules like this I ask a couple of questions. Is there a balance issue? What is going to be fun. Sometimes the balance issues overrides the fun issue by I don't see that here. I see no reason from a balance - or fun - to nerf this. I would keep doubling the dice on a crit.

I guess you can read it so that it wouldn't work but it is such a narrow interpretation that I don't think it makes sense. When in doubt I err on the side of the players.
 

I agree with the others saying that I would rule that you would get the crit damage on hand of harm and they've covered the reasons.

I would also add that when evaluating rules like this I ask a couple of questions. Is there a balance issue? What is going to be fun. Sometimes the balance issues overrides the fun issue by I don't see that here. I see no reason from a balance - or fun - to nerf this. I would keep doubling the dice on a crit.

I guess you can read it so that it wouldn't work but it is such a narrow interpretation that I don't think it makes sense. When in doubt I err on the side of the players.
Thank you for your reply!

Well I'm not saying how anyone should rule this. Just that from a RAW and RAI standpoint I question whether that concurs with the rules though. I haven't really gotten an argument so far why it should be multiplied and neither do I think my interpretation is narrow. Not to throw any of the commentors under the bus as everyone has been lovely so far (you included), but a real counterargument against any of my points hasn't really come forward.
We basically have one other example that has the hit and damage wording (to my knowledge) and a rules designer has stated that it's supposed to be a separate instance that doesn't get multiplied. Of course that alone isn't RAW (because it was an informal comment on the matter), but it supports at least the RAI interpretation. And I also think I outlined why even going purely of the written word it should be a separate instances (it requires damage already being dealt to trigger aka happens after the step where crit multiplication happens).

On your second point you are obviously correct. You are right that it's almost certainly fine to let it multiply. However, I'm not talking about a nerf here because not multiplying is how the feature actually functions as a baseline. It's inverted -- you can let it multiply but that's a buff over how the feature is supposed to work.
 

Thank you for your reply!

Well I'm not saying how anyone should rule this. Just that from a RAW and RAI standpoint I question whether that concurs with the rules though. I haven't really gotten an argument so far why it should be multiplied and neither do I think my interpretation is narrow. Not to throw any of the commentors under the bus as everyone has been lovely so far (you included), but a real counterargument against any of my points hasn't really come forward.
We basically have one other example that has the hit and damage wording (to my knowledge) and a rules designer has stated that it's supposed to be a separate instance that doesn't get multiplied. Of course that alone isn't RAW (because it was an informal comment on the matter), but it supports at least the RAI interpretation. And I also think I outlined why even going purely of the written word it should be a separate instances (it requires damage already being dealt to trigger aka happens after the step where crit multiplication happens).

On your second point you are obviously correct. You are right that it's almost certainly fine to let it multiply. However, I'm not talking about a nerf here because not multiplying is how the feature actually functions as a baseline. It's inverted -- you can let it multiply but that's a buff over how the feature is supposed to work.

The wording for the two is different and I think you're looking at the wrong part of the description (bold added):
Hand of Harm​
Once per turn when you hit a creature with an Unarmed Strike and deal damage, you can expend 1 Focus Point to deal extra Necrotic damage equal to one roll of your Martial Arts die plus your Wisdom modifier.​
​
Psionic Strike​
Once on each of your turns, immediately after you hit a target within 30 feet of yourself with an attack and deal damage to it with a weapon, you can expend one Psionic Energy Die, rolling it and dealing Force damage to the target equal to the number rolled plus your Intelligence modifier.​

The phrasing that I see as different is "when you hit" vs "immediately after you hit". The former is taking place at the moment you hit - it is part of the hit. The latter is you hit - you hit and and then follow up with the psionic strike as a secondary follow-up effect. I don't think having to spend a resource to do it means anything, if it did most damage modifiers wouldn't apply crit damage which isn't the intent.

Hopefully that makes more sense because that's my story, I'm sticking to it. :)
 

@Plaguescarred: Of course you can. Heck it's a pen and paper game so you can do pretty much anything you want. It's probably just not RAW since it explicitly depends on dealing damage (instead of all the other features that depend on hitting only). Supported by the Psionic Strike example (only other feature I'm aware off that depends both on hitting and damaging and incidentally also the only other feature that deals Dice + Modifier damage). I wouldn't get hung up on the "extra". It's functionally identical to additional, which some other effects that multiply on a crit use. It's basically semantics (Which 5.5 as well as 5e are unfortunately rather poor at) so we have to look at the "trigger" condition, which is damage already being present (the step at which extra damage would usually get multiplied). I think there's also a rather large hint that this is the RAI interpretation given its similarity to Psionic Strike.
Well Psionic Strike doesn't deal extra damage so it's effectively a seperate damage instance that should not be doubled on a Critical Hit.

IMO its RAW wether you must hit and damage or just hit, scoring a Critical Hit should double any extra damage as they're part of the attack's damage like any other extra damage. But you are free to disagree with my take on it of course.
 
Last edited:

Remove ads

Top