D&D 5E (2024) Has anyone played the new 2024 Banneret?

I remember one of those class reviews for the new one.

They never saw one (PDK) get played.

I suspect a few tashas things may be in that category.
 

log in or register to remove this ad


A lot of the subclasses in SCAG were bad. I did have an NPC with the PDK subclass, because they were a PDK. They didn’t see much action, but what they did showed how bad the subclass was.
I dont get how they can still today have such huge quality drops in certain books. They also had it in 4e but there it was almost always the same designer but they hot rid of that one...
 


I dont get how they can still today have such huge quality drops in certain books. They also had it in 4e but there it was almost always the same designer but they hot rid of that one...
As I understand it SCAG was written in a hurry by an outside team with prototype 5.0 core rules, so the subclass power level wasn’t established. This was when 5e was a last ditch attempt to save a dying franchise.

The updated one was a panicked replacement when people got hysterical about changing the Purple Dragon Knights. Since they went ahead and changed the lore anyway, without the cool subclass, it was doubly stupid. It’s almost like the new Banneret was WotCs way of punishing the players who rejected the PDK subclass.
 

I dont get how they can still today have such huge quality drops in certain books. They also had it in 4e but there it was almost always the same designer but they hot rid of that one...

SCAG was the first expansion for 5E, so I think that is part of why. The other ones did not have that that, well maybe the free Astarion one but all the others had mostly quality content I think.

Even in SCAG though you had the original Bladesinger, and the original blade Cantrips which were both good and well received. The blade Cantrips were nerfed and the Bladesinger buffed later in rewrites but they were considered good in SCAG.

I will also say Undying Warlock is to this day my favorite Warlock subclass. Underpowered generally (unless the entire campaign is undead-oriented in which case it would be OP), but it is still really fun. Undying Warlock/Shadow Sorcerer is what I played in POTA back in the day, and then I also dipped it with a Halfling Moon Bard in a 3rd party short 1-9 adventure this past spring.

The original PDK and Battlerager were truely awful though.
 
Last edited:



The Banneret is still nerfed Warlord and gates any possible fun behind too many restrictions.

Battlemaster/Valor Bard multiclass is the better option for the flavour
Oh, yes. My Conan the conqueror, leader of men is a spell caster. Precisely what I'm going for.

When in doubt, make everything a spellcaster!!!
 

A lot of people online seem to think negatively of this subclass, I was wondering if anyone has experience with it in play.

Personally, I have not played one or seen one in play as another player or DM. However, looking at the abilities in a white room it seems you could build a pretty fun and effective PC. Team Tactics seems to be really good and rallying surge seems awesome as long as your party has a Rogue or Barbarian or someone else that is going to hit hard with opportunity attacks. The Polygot ability seems nice for out of combat use.

I am thinking of playing one in a future 1-20 campaign, probably with a 2-level Warlock dip worked in during early tier 2.

Here is what I am thinking:

A high Charisma Aasimar PC on point buy S15 D13 C13 I8 W9 CH17. She is hard core Lawful Good (almost Lawful Stupid) sent from the heavens to bring justice to evildoers.

Start at 1st level with the Tough Feat, Arcane Warrior Fighting style with Truestrike and Blade Ward, Weapon Mastery in Heavy Crossbow, either Trident or Warhammer and either a Greataxe, Greatsword or Maul. Proficiency in Perception, Deception, Intimidation, Athletics.

Level 3 Persuasion with the Banneret subclass

Level 4 grab Heavy Armor Master (Con 14)

Take a level in Warlock at level 5 (F4/W1) for Pact of Blade, Hex and Protection from Good and Evil.

Take another Warlock level at level 7 (F5/W2) for Arcane Vigor and Magic Initiate-Cleric with Sanctuary and Thamaturgy.

Level 8 (F6/W2) take Magic Connoisseur for Prayer of Healing so I can recharge Action Surge, 2nd Wind and my 2 Warlock slots in 10 minutes without needing a short rest, get either a second casting of Sanctuary or Shield of Faith to go along with it.

Level 10 (F8/W2) Charisma 20

Level 14 (F12/W2) Not sure what Feat to get. Maybe Observant (Wisdom 10) and getting expertise in Perception or maybe Great Weapon Master (Strength 16) if I am still swinging a Heavy weapon in melee or maybe Sentinel (Dex 14) or maybe Speedy (Dex 14) or maybe Skill Expert (Dex 14)

Level 16: (F14/W2) Either Speedy or ASI for Con 16 depending on what I took at level 14

At this point You would need to consider whether you want F18 or W4. W4 is probably more powerful because you get one more Epic Boon than you do with F18. I am not sure what I would do there because I also really like 2xAction Surge and 3xIndomitable. Also if I go 3 levels in Warlock the only thing that makes sense thematically is Celestial and I've done so many of them recently it is getting old.

Thoughts?
The trouble with Banneret in 5.5e is that almost all of its features are once per Short Rest. This makes it really only useful if you take short rests after every combat. It would've been more useful to make it free to use Group Recovery every Second Wind.

Make Team Tactics explicitly and separately apply to you.

Give Rallying Surge another option like allies can use a weapon mastery you have, even if they otherwise wouldn't have access to weapon masteries.

Bolstered Rally should give two of the Rallying Surge options.

Something like that.
 

Remove ads

Top