D&D General [+] How much information do you need?


log in or register to remove this ad

I find that I try to give more information than not. I have always felt that the actual PCs in the situation would see and sense more than I tell the players or that they ask about. Some things would be obvious to a group if I was describing it better, so I give a benefit of doubt to the PCs.

A recent intersection in a set of sewers allowed for the PCs to bust through a bricked up area at the top of a stairwell, turn left down a hall, or turn right through a barred door and go down more stairs. I described the left tunnel as having old spiderwebs across it showing it has not been used in many months. The bars at the top of the stairs has a new chain and lock securing they closed and the bricked up area appear to be old and going back to the rebuilding of the keep a few hundred years.

It was enough information to allow for further questions and inspections of the areas and to allow for a check or two if they was something more specific being asked. They looked for secret door leading up the stairs and looked for tracks going through the barred area. They skipped the more abandoned looking tunnel but had this information.
 

What do I need for information before starting to further investigate? Note this is edition-agnostic and applies to all situations....

Dimensions if indoors (including ceiling height!). Distances. Directions (either compass or left-right). Lighting if indoors, weather if outdoors. Unusual sounds if any. Unusual smells if any. Slope, stairs, or other elevation changes. With doors, are they open or closed and if closed, which way do (or would) they open if obvious. Obvious features e.g. furniture, statues, pools, tree cover. And, of course, people or creatures or monsters that are potential threats and, if there are any, what they are doing and-or how they are reacting to our presence.

After that, if I want or need further info I'll either ask (if out-of-character I think something's missing in the description - usually the ceiling height) or have my character look closer.
 


I'm not sure there's an easy way to define what information is enough for it to be informed. But I would probably separate things into low & high level of information, and furthermore whether that information tells us about the danger.

So for example,
Low level non-dangerous. This would be stuff like a mysterious glow that we can't quite make out, noise of rushing water, etc... We have information but it doesn't really us anything about the danger level.
Low level and dangerous. This would be stuff like large claw marks along the wall, a trail of fresh blood, etc... We have information but it's still not a ton, ie we don't know what monster we might face or if it's actually home, but the information does indicate a dangerous monster has travelled this path so good chance we encounter it.

High level information would be stuff like detailed maps and knowing exactly which room the BBEG, or travel paths where it's like here's a shortcut but it goes through the Ettercap forest so expect Ettercaps, giant spiders, and the like.
 

Opening a door.
Is it trapped? Can we hear/smell anything behind it? Are there any tracks leading up to/away from it?
Attacking a monster.
Is it acting hostile towards me or an ally? Is a creature classically defined as my enemy (fiends, evil dragons, etc.)?
Crossing a rope bridge over a chasm.
Trickier, and by far the most dangerous listed. How deep do we believe the chasm to be? Do we see/hear flying creatures somewhere nearby? What condition do we think the rope is in? Is it wet or sticky?
Traveling direction when leaving the starter town.
What rumors have we heard in town?
Turning left or right at a T intersection in a dungeon.
Can we see/hear/smell anything from either direction? Assuming we've been mapping, does one way lead back towards where we've explored, or away from what we've explored? Are there any tracks?

As you can see, most of these should be instigated by the players, typically resulting in a skill check. The only one that absolutely is the DM's responsibility is initial travel direction, because even in a sandbox, the DM must provide some plot hooks (or else the players wander aimlessly). Providing indicators of a creature's hostility is also under the DM's bailiwick, but sometimes it's fun to start a combat that doesn't need to be a combat.
 


Can we see/hear/smell anything from either direction? Assuming we've been mapping, does one way lead back towards where we've explored, or away from what we've explored? Are there any tracks?
One consideration for me if-when we're mapping is even if both directions lead to unexplored areas, is whether one of them is marked as a more limited area than the other. An example might be where going left has to, within 60 feet, either go up, down, dead end in a small room or group of rooms, or go outside via an entrance we missed.

More useful (and easier to explain!) in something like a typical haunted house scenario - once you've cleared the ground floor, going upstairs next always makes more sense than going downstairs, as upstairs is by definition a limited area (the house is only so big) while downstairs can go anywhere.
 

You know, all of it really depends on what sorts of consequences for catastrophic failure (such as character death or a TPK) the campaign has as options.

For example, I typically run about three types of games.

1) Theme adventure. 8-15 sessions around a theme, representing a short period of time during which the characters probably gain 1 level.
2) Mini-campaign. Something like Lost Mine of Phandelver.
3) Full Campaign. This is the one we've played for 6 years and the characters are level 5. Planning to go level 20 and beyond.

Just sticking to D&D for the moment, we can assume as a baseline that various forms of resurrection magic are available unless you are too low level to have reasonable access, but that there are some rare situations that can't be fixed with that kind of magic.

In a Theme adventure, I'd typically assume all failure options are on the table, so you might die with no way back, but if it's set at a higher level you can probably get raised. If the latter is the case I don't need to know much, because consequences for really messing up are fixable (and quite possibly funny). If death means you make a new character...well, I'd want to feel like there were usually some indication that you are about to choose death accidentally, but I would still likely laugh about it even if there weren't. It's a short game, and your character is essentially retiring after it anyway.

In a Mini-campaign, I'd ideally want to know what the options are up front, rather than making assumptions. Assuming the same as for the Theme adventure above, I would definitely want to know enough to estimate potential risk level of choices in broad terms, unless we had the resources to easily raise the dead, in which case it would be fine to occasionally stumble into something you had no idea was deadly. If on the other hand death was always going to mean making a new character, I'd want that knowledge to be a bit less broad.

In a Full Campaign, we definitely need to know what the options are. Under your standard assumptions, I would want finding out the approximate threat to be accessibly doable up until the point you have easy access to resurrection magic. And since it wouldn't make much sense to play that long with it working that way and then it suddenly doesn't, it should continue. If the game wasn't going to allow for resurrection at all, although I want to say I'd want more info, I just don't think more info beyond that point would mean more fun. So I guess that's just a situation where I'd have to try not to get attached to a character in the first place.

Now, this is where I get to the possibilty of different options than just the three I mentioned (no resurrection, resurrection at least eventually possible, or easy access). I really think an option where it is part of Session Zero that you will never lose your character unless you want to to be a great alternative for a Full Campaign (or those tiny little 1 year things these kids today think are full campaigns because of WotC marketing strategies). Some game systems have this built in by default, but D&D hasn't played with that concept much (other than the Planescape Torment video game where it was a core plot element, and the adventure in the 5e Planescape product, where they made an inferior riff on that). The dea I would propose is that it's a default D&D world so resurrection is usually possible (but not always cheap or easy), and you play the game letting the chips fall where they may. But there is a guarantee that regardless of what happens to your character, nothing will permanently take away your ability to play them. So maybe you die in a way that specifies you need a wish to come back, or someone has to go find your soul, or you need divine intervention. The DM doesn't have to just drop you the quest to get that at the start of the next session, but starting on a path that will eventually lead there has to be accessible. (Presumably you play an NPC friend or such while this is going on.) Honestly, for me this is a part of the essence of D&D. The PCs can have the possibilty of overcoming anything eventually. If that's the assumption, then I'm in the situation where I'd usually want to be able to gather threat info in broad terms, but occasionally it's probably fine to be completely surprised with no way to have prevented something from happening. Because it's fixable. (And hopefully funny. Do not underestimate the power of comical demise.)
 


Remove ads

Top