TSR If you can't be kind, at least be vague- The History of Basic

um idk, maybe rule the known universe !! =P



Love my og RC, though we typically just play b/x with the OSE line these days.


RC/[BECM] "I", players have four paths spheres; Energy, Time, Thought, Matter .. and a fifth is Entropy and "off limits".

a petitioner has to do something big to attract an Immortal patron of the sphere, and think it was the matter/polymath that had to go through four reincarnated characters to find an artifact [each time] that they originally offered their patron. The quests are summed up nicely in the Rules Cyclopedia if I recall, never owned "Masters" rules, don't recall seeing them in the "Immortal" series so must be in "Masters"

Also, m3-twilight-calling if the players survive they get elevated to rank 0/1 Immortals, there's I think 5 tiers and 4 ranks in the first four.. based on #PP(power points) or something like that (it's in the 'I" book). Probably my favorite adventure, I mix it up reshuffle it every few years if PC hit max in the game, so i've done ad&d 2e, 3.x, 5x to date.

Entropy we found some suggestions on some nerdy D&D/Netbook/geocity sites and used that for our "Evil campaign". cool. whew still got my old notes.. my doc goes back to last mod of 2004.. where did the time go. These quests should follow the RC section on Petitioning.. except Entropy - which has been added.

Ascent to Immortality - AD&D.com The trials of life need not end with death, for great heros can become Immortal.
There were a couple of other "paths" in the Gazetteers...
 

log in or register to remove this ad

My mistake, it looks like the box for Holmes Basic Set had a red dragon on the cover but the book was all in blue. (I only have a copy of the book).

Wikipedia says "The first Basic Set was available as a 48-page standalone rulebook featuring artwork by David C. Sutherland III, or as part of a boxed set, which was packaged in a larger, more visually appealing box than the original boxed set, allowing the game to be stocked on retail shelves and targeted at the general public via toy stores."

View attachment 451340

Moldvay B/X Basic is Magenta box with a red rule book and Cook B/X Expert Box is blue as is the Cook B/X Expert rule book.

View attachment 451341
View attachment 451345

View attachment 451342

View attachment 451343

View attachment 451344

The BECMI Basic boxed set is red and the BECMI Expert set box is blue.

View attachment 451346
TIL: I got the contents of the Moldvay box (sans dice) in the BECMI red box.

Before 3e, I bought all of my gaming books used...LOL!
 




Further, there was often a snobbish attitude by players at the time around Basic. It's in the name! Basic ... that's for kids, right? ADVANCED D&D - that's what you should be playing. Simply put, a lot of people just thought that Basic was the little table where the kids were exiled; AD&D was where the adults had serious conversations. And if you were a teen, or even a kid.... you probably didn't want to be associated with the kid game, right?
I never really understood what Basic was about, but after reading your thoughtful thesis, I still don't really understand it. My group never even tried Basic as we were on the AD&D and AD&D 2nd edition bandwagon. I always figured Basic was the less advanced version of the game and everyone was playing AD&D. I remember seeing the Rules Cyclopedia on shelves but just ignored it.
 


They literally sold a game that sold better than the game they wanted to sell and so they decided to stop supporting it - the better selling game. Because it was for kids.
It did run for, what, 13-14 years? That's not insignificant.
 


One asterisk I would put here - I think that the staggering majority of home AD&D games used a mutant version of the BX/BECMI core rules, with AD&D characters, spells, monsters, etc. I think people liked the simpler, coherent rules for combat and other procedures found in Basic, but much preferred the relative flexibility (and power!) of AD&D character creation.
I very much doubt it. I was there, and playing a lot, and that wasn’t something I ever heard of. Nor is it discussed in any articles I ever saw. Almost no modules were written for Basic. And Expert had a fraction of Basic’s sales, so how would all these people be using it in a hybrid game? Most people were just playing AD&D.

Edit: also, basic did not “sell better” (as another poster claims) than AD&D unless you are just looking at the raw numbers of the red box, at $10 a pop and typically bought as a gift. The dollar sales of AD&D were exponentially greater than the dollar sales of basic, and beyond the red box the rest of the basic line had almost negligible sales.

There was no buzz around Basic. It was the kiddie game. You were expected to graduate from it, if you played it at all. That’s not to say that attitude was justified, but let’s not pretend basic was the main game. It very much was not. It was the toy store version.
 
Last edited:

Remove ads

Top