TSR If you can't be kind, at least be vague- The History of Basic

Other than initiative what do people think people used from Basic as rules in 1e?

My memory is I mostly used a d6 high wins initiative with the 1e fighter extra attacks go first and last while ignoring a lot of 1e DMG complications like weapon length when closing and weapon speed and figuring out segment interactions. So the description in the 1e PH mostly without even the Basic specific movement and ranged and melee order of operations. Its been a while though and I am a big fan of the 3e-5e style individual in order initiative system and I was a big fan of the individual initiative options in 2e using casting times and weapon speeds in that era.

I used Basic modules and monsters and magic items in my 1e games but I can't really think of Basic-specific rules I used instead of 1e ones.

From Basic I learned a lot of how to play and style and philosophy of DMing and an understanding of D&D rules and rules concepts in general, but the actual rules specifics I applied in my 1e games as DM were 1e rules, even if not always all the full 1e complicated specifics.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Other than initiative what do people think people used from Basic as rules in 1e?
Even if they are using side initiative (higher d6 wins), did they get it from Basic D&D or did they get it by stripping out all of the additional grit from AD&D? While those may be the same general method, how they got there would determine whether they are using the Basic rules or not.
 

Even if they are using side initiative (higher d6 wins), did they get it from Basic D&D or did they get it by stripping out all of the additional grit from AD&D? While those may be the same general method, how they got there would determine whether they are using the Basic rules or not.

I keep thinking that there is this misapprehension about the way people understood rules back then.

It wasn't like ... you played RAW. If you didn't use the RAW, you had to use the RAW from a different game. It was more ... people just kind of played, with the rules as guidelines and helpful sources.

Initiative is something I think about a lot. I sometimes post a link to the ADDICT sheet, which is someone's attempt to make sense of all the conflicting rules about initiative that could be gleaned from various rules and exceptions ... and it's spectacular!

The thing is, though ... I played a bunch of AD&D, and initiative was never a big deal. I'm trying to remember all the ways that I saw initiative handled ... and while I know I'm forgetting some, here are the ones that come to mind-

1. Simple. Players go, monsters go, repeat.
2. d6, no modifiers.
3. d6, dex modifiers.
4. d10 was the segment (this was used for spell casting, interrupting).
5. d20, no modifiers.
6. d6, some of the rules were used.

All of these had variations- some tables did initiative for each "side" and some did initiate for each participant. Some did it for each round, some "locked in" initiative with the first roll.

I never remember it being a big deal, just, "This is how we're doing it," and then people did it. That said, I've been doing some research into the Competitive (Tournament) play for AD&D recently and I'm trying to dredge up details of how they followed the rules.
 

One asterisk I would put here - I think that the staggering majority of home AD&D games used a mutant version of the BX/BECMI core rules, with AD&D characters, spells, monsters, etc. I think people liked the simpler, coherent rules for combat and other procedures found in Basic, but much preferred the relative flexibility (and power!) of AD&D character creation.
Curiously, when I approached the d20 era stuff with this same perspective, it seems that the play culture had changed, and most people thought my freewheeling mix and match of various d20 games elements was kind of weird. I'd still be up to run a 3.5 Pathfinder 1e hybrid.
I find this history pretty fascinating, since I didn't really discover D&D until the early 00s, well after the end of Basic as a separate game line. Honestly I think it's kind of a shame that the Basic line was so overlooked because it seems like a much more streamlined and well-thought out system in my admittedly-limited reading.
Everything has its time. It was overlooked at the time, but shortly after OSRIC came out and essentially "kicked off" the OSR as a real thing and not just an aesthetic (Necromancer Games) or a hybrid (Castles & Crusades) the basic line really came into its own and became the driving force in the OSR for many years (until, arguably systems that are less overtly D&D-ish came to prominence.) But to Mike's point above which I also quoted, I wonder if the real darling of the OSR is a modified B/X retro-clone that actually clones the Basic/AD&D hybrid gaming that most people actually played in the 80s. I know that for me personally, I wasn't really super aware of which system which rule came from, or at least I didn't remember it very well.
When I eventually inherited a BECMI immortals set when a friend moved and was downsizing, I flipped through it and mostly did not care for it. I was into D&D for the explorations and discovery and combat and interactions, and adventuring, not for running domains (companion), adventuring to master yourself to a path to immortality (master), or being a low level lackey immortal (immortals). I was much more a B/X kind of adventure seeker.
I think honestly that the enduring popularity (or resurgent popularity, if you will) of the Basic paradigm has to do with exactly that; the "modules", if you will, of play at higher level just didn't have the same pull or appeal, so they never really took off. Which is both good and bad; while I agree that the "regular" lower level game play loop is what I prefer, it sometimes led to weird things like 3e's Epic Level Handbook trying to prolong that game play loop into super high levels with super high numbers, but no other real changes.
 

Even if they are using side initiative (higher d6 wins), did they get it from Basic D&D or did they get it by stripping out all of the additional grit from AD&D? While those may be the same general method, how they got there would determine whether they are using the Basic rules or not.
I think initiative is going to be the most common thing to take mechanically from Basic, many who have read basic and go to the 1e DMG and read the complications there might throw up their hands and pull out their Basic book to apply those rules verbatim or what they remember of them. But I was asking what other rules besides initiative were used? Do you have any examples?

For me I on initiative I had played a bunch of both Basic and 1e before I was DMing which was using 1e, but I had first read the rules in Moldvay and then read the 1e rules and when I was DMing my 1e games and then longterm campaign and running initiative I was trying to apply the 1e rules while consciously not applying a bunch of the complications like the ties or closing or segment times.

Basic initiative itself has some idiosyncratic specifics such as its order of operations with spells going off before melee attacks start and I was not trying to do those Basic rules in my 1e games.

B24:

A. Each side rolls for initiative (1d6).
B. The side that wins the initiative acts first (if simultaneous all
actions are performed by each side at the same time):
1. Morale checks, if needed (page B27).
2. Movement per round, meleed opponents may only move
defensively (spell casters may not move and cast spells).
3. Missile fire combat:
a. choose targets
b. roll 1d20 to hit; adjust result by Dexterity adjustment,
range, cover, and magic
c. DM rolls damage
4. Magic spells (roll saving throws, as needed: 1d20).
5. Melee or hand-to-hand combat:
a. choose (or be attacked by) opponents
b. roll 1d20 to hit; adjust result by Strength adjustment and
magic weapons
c. DM rolls damage; adjust result by Strength adjustment
and magic weapons
C. The side with the next highest initiative acts second, and so on
using the order given above, until all sides have completed
melee.
 

Oh yeah totally... word of mouth and "learn at the table" was the most common path to the rules.
In a sense, perhaps 'learn at the table' is still the most common path to the rules ? I only got into D&D with 5e and immediately bought the PHB before my very first session, but did not attempt to (well, perhaps I did, but quickly abandoned the idea) fully read and memorize the entire PHB before ever playing the game. Mostly, the rules were explained to me as we played. It wasn't until quite a few sessions in before I picked up the PHB again and tried to make sense of it: but that was after learning the majority of the rules 'at the table'. It would not surprise me at all if that would be the common way to learn the game for anyone who first was introduced to the game with 5e (and perhaps older editions as well, as you noted).
 

Other than initiative what do people think people used from Basic as rules in 1e?
A few we used back in the day:
  • Basic rules for dungeon and outdoor exploration. They were easier to parse and reference, so that's what got used.
  • Domain rules from the Companion set.
  • Wrestling rules from the Companion set.
There's a third game that replaced both B/X and AD&D - Pool of Radiance. Everyone I gamed with had played it. It's rules became the default for handling combat, combined with 2e's initiative system when it eventually came out. Stuff like the guard action, how backstab work, and all of that came straight out of the SSI Gold Box games.
 

Basic rules for dungeon and outdoor exploration. They were easier to parse and reference, so that's what got used.
I can see that, stuff like wandering monsters on B53:

"At the end of
every 2 turns, the DM should check for Wandering Monsters. To
do so, roll Id6: a result of 1 indicates that the party will encounter a
Wandering Monster in the next turn. The Wandering Monster will
be 20-120 feet away from the party when encountered (roll 2d6,
multiply the result by 10) in a direction of the DM's choosing, and
will be headed toward the player characters."

is very easy to apply.

All searching taking a turn instead of the DMG making some one round, using d6s to listen at doors instead of the 1e DMG d20 chart, did you allow everyone the Basic 1 in d6 search for traps?
 

Were there people that played the "I" and enjoyed it?
Raises hand

This was back in my youth, when my gaming group was my schoolmates, and we literally played D&D nearly every day for about 6 years straight - so we were able to play enough to crank through all 36 levels and into the Immortals rules.

One of the things I do think BECMI did well was prepare players to transition to "new modes of play" every few levels - once you mastered dungeon delving (Basic), it was time to hexcrawl (Expert); once you had figured that out, it was time for Dominions/War Machine (Companion) and once you had steadied your domain and defended it from threats, it was time for epic cross-planar adventures and artifact chasing (Master), and once you had figured out the path to immortality, it was a completely new game (Immortality). It kept things from getting stale; I cannot imagine daily dungeoncrawls for six years, and I appreciated the every-expanding scope that the rules let you move into.

The thing with the Immortals rules is at least as I experienced it we did a lot of "plane hopping" with "demigod powers" and similar - which, frankly, is more or less AD&D/EPIC 3E/Level 16+ 5E, just with slightly different mechanics - you get much the same adventure experiences as you do at the peak of 20-level modern D&D, it's just with a different rule set and some unique setting flavor.
 

Other than initiative what do people think people used from Basic as rules in 1e?.
Surprise me would be the other big one, since segments and complex action order in AD&D again muck up an otherwise simple system from Basic. The ability to modify ability scores (ie the lower 2, raise 1) rule was popular, and I think the simpler definition of infravision are two more. I would not be surprised if morale rules got intermixed to.

One example I remember was a DM who used warhammers doing 1d6 damage rather than the 1d4+1 in AD&D. I don't know if that was intent or misremembering the rules.
 

Remove ads

Top