D&D General If you had to choose between quality of story or combat

Story or gameplay?

  • Great story, boring combat and gameplay

    Votes: 60 40.8%
  • Great encounters and gameplay, bland story

    Votes: 87 59.2%

It's not subjective to say that an elephant weighs more than a gnat, even if we don't have the specific measurements.
Right, this is what I struggle with! If I said I think a gnat weighed more than an elephant, I'd be provably wrong, yeah? I think D&D and Pendragon play equally here. So this should be provably wrong, but no one's helping me with that proof. It sounded very simple as it was originally described.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

I know, it sounds so obvious to some of you, I'm worried I might be game-play-choice-restriction blind! I can't see the metaphorical beer here. You could tell me the weight of the glasses or volume of liquid to prove the objective reality to me, I'm just asking for the same understanding of game-play-choice-restriction, because it was claimed we have an objective measure. Then I could measure game-play-choice-restriction in all sorts of situations on my own and really understand this objectively.

One of @Lanefan's pints is slightly less full, something you can objectively determine without measuring to the milliliter. But you know that.
 

I know, it sounds so obvious to some of you, I'm worried I might be game-play-choice-restriction blind! I can't see the metaphorical beer here. You could tell me the weight of the glasses or volume of liquid to prove the objective reality to me, I'm just asking for the same understanding of game-play-choice-restriction, because it was claimed we have an objective measure. Then I could measure game-play-choice-restriction in all sorts of situations on my own and really understand this objectively.
As I explained earlier, the way Pendragon has been described here indicates that there are restrictions involved with social interaction. Whether those come form character traits, roll results, binding stakes or whatever, they exist. D&D has no such restrictions. Some restriction(Pendragon/partially full beer glass) is objectively greater than no restriction(D&D/empty beer glass).
 


Pendragon is just different. I think a big component here is what players of a particular game have signed up for. I think D&D is very much in the 'only I get to make decisions for my character' camp and that's part of the lens through which I see the fail to spot trap = mind control thing. Other games (and I'm thinking less here of Pendragon and more of something like Sorcerer or Burning Wheel) have a different focus and offer much greater agency in other areas, such that 'you are convinced' is a different proposition in both weight and scope.
 

Right, this is what I struggle with! If I said I think a gnat weighed more than an elephant, I'd be provably wrong, yeah? I think D&D and Pendragon play equally here. So this should be provably wrong, but no one's helping me with that proof. It sounded very simple as it was originally described.
I don't know what you are referring to anymore.
 

Pendragon is just different. I think a big component here is what players of a particular game have signed up for. I think D&D is very much in the 'only I get to make decisions for my character' camp and that's part of the lens through which I see the fail to spot trap = mind control thing. Other games (and I'm thinking less here of Pendragon and more of something like Sorcerer or Burning Wheel) have a different focus and offer much greater agency in other areas, such that 'you are convinced' is a different proposition in both weight and scope.
Taking the veil off, this is pretty close to what I think --- the "you are" is directed differently than it would be in D&D "mind control" --- as if I might say "you are right, GM, I am convinced, that's how I made my character!" Games with these rules and mechanics --- such as "you hate all Saxons" or "you have maximum compassion and must struggle with your virtues in every battlefield and city" --- are certainly different games than D&D, but I don't feel they lead to "restrictions" in my choices any more than it is true that I "restricted" my choices to absorb damage because I built a squishy wizard or I chose to follow an imposed religious code because I'm playing a paladin or took a vow of poverty because I'm playing a monk. Or so on.

I limited the maximal universe of my options via game elements in all these situations, yes, but by choosing those elements and embracing the role, they don't manifest in play as "restrictions" --- they are just my character.
 

Taking the veil off, this is pretty close to what I think --- the "you are" is directed differently than it would be in D&D "mind control" --- as if I might say "you are right, GM, I am convinced, that's how I made my character!" Games with these rules and mechanics --- such as "you hate all Saxons" or "you have maximum compassion and must struggle with your virtues in every battlefield and city" --- are certainly different games than D&D, but I don't feel they lead to "restrictions" in my choices any more than it is true that I "restricted" my choices to absorb damage because I built a squishy wizard or I chose to follow an imposed religious code because I'm playing a paladin or took a vow of poverty because I'm playing a monk. Or so on.

I limited the maximal universe of my options via game elements in all these situations, yes, but by choosing those elements and embracing the role, they don't manifest in play as "restrictions" --- they are just my character.

The restrictions are different. D&D has plenty of board-game-adjacent features in combat. For some of use the restrictions on who our character is, what they think and feel matters to some of us. If you don't care, you don't.
 

Taking the veil off, this is pretty close to what I think --- the "you are" is directed differently than it would be in D&D "mind control" --- as if I might say "you are right, GM, I am convinced, that's how I made my character!" Games with these rules and mechanics --- such as "you hate all Saxons" or "you have maximum compassion and must struggle with your virtues in every battlefield and city" --- are certainly different games than D&D, but I don't feel they lead to "restrictions" in my choices any more than it is true that I "restricted" my choices to absorb damage because I built a squishy wizard or I chose to follow an imposed religious code because I'm playing a paladin or took a vow of poverty because I'm playing a monk. Or so on.
Nevertheless, those are in fact character restrictions. If you must obey the vow of poverty, you don't have the same options my rogue does. I can opt to be poor and give stuff away, or keep stuff and have wealth. I don't have that limitation. That you wouldn't try to get around the vow of poverty because you chose it, doesn't make it any less of a limitation. It just makes it a limitation that doesn't bother you, or that you don't push against.

Now let's look at the "you hate all Saxons" portion. I once had a character that hated all orcs. He killed many of them over the course of the campaign. Eventually the group travelled to a different portion of the Forgotten Realms and we came across a group of orcs that didn't know we were there. We attacked and slaughtered all but one who surrendered to us. As the group was questioning it, it became apparent that it wasn't an evil orc, which was new to us. I cast Know Alignment(this was a 2e game) and sure enough, it was a NG orc. My character felt horrible about what he had done, even though they were orcs. He hated them because they were evil and had raided his homeland many times. I took in that orc who now had no home, no family, and no way to take care of himself, and eventually earned his trust and loyalty.

That was an option D&D let me have with my "you hate all orcs," that would not have been present in a game that required me to always "hate all Saxons." You would have that limitation and I would not, regardless of feelings on the matter.
I limited the maximal universe of my options via game elements in all these situations, yes, but by choosing those elements and embracing the role, they don't manifest in play as "restrictions" --- they are just my character.
You don't push against those restrictions, so they don't have force, but they still remain restrictions, even if you don't feel them. There are laws that restrict folks from murdering others. That I have never felt the desire and would never murder someone, and therefore never feel those laws upon me, doesn't mean that I am not restricted from murdering folks. It just means that I will never push against and meet that restriction.
 

D&D still has paladin oaths, and it used to have a lot more behavioral restrictions in the form of alignment constraints based on class and behavioral expectations of deities on clerics IIRC. It's not completely unconstrained.

The setting also generally imposes some expectations, obviously; like a character native to the Forgotten Realms really should believe that magic and deities are quite real and that they have noticeable effects on the world; and will likely have their thinking heavily influenced by whatever culture(s) they grew up in.
 

Remove ads

Top