Notes From the Player
If you made it this far, thank you for reading.
How much of this happened at the table?
I’ll start with what
didn’t happen, as that’s shorter and easier.
- Unsurprisingly, her background stories (aka the Interludes) were fiction. Many of these were written before the campaign started, when I was fleshing out who Kali was as a character. Two Interludes were co-written with Qatana’s player: “Pluralism” and “Reunion”.
- Also outside the table were Kali’s conversations with her parents, and a couple of scenes with non-core NPCs. The latter were largely downtime scenes that took place between books. My goal with these was always to make Kali’s world feel lived in.
- The town square in Iqaliat was a fictionalization of a table event: Ivan’s player tried to set Kali up with a villager (don’t ask). I didn’t want to roleplay “Kali disappoints teenage suitor”, and I’m willing to bet no one wanted to watch it, either.
The rest of it really happened.
The journal captures events, decisions, and outcomes from the table, as well as the substance of the conversations. That being said, it’s not a transcript. Dialogue was reconstructed and polished, fights were heavily compressed (when I included them at all), and I supplied Kali's internal voice. However, I never changed
what happened to make the story work.
Lengthy conversations with core NPCs and a few key Harrow readings were done offline with the GM. I did some wordsmithing on these to improve narrative flow, but I did not alter their substance.
How much of Kali’s internal life was visible to the players and GM?
All of it. Journal entries were written after each game session—sometimes several entries per session—and then shared with the gaming group before the next one. Background stories weren’t tied to specific sessions, but they were shared with the group as well.
They were learning about Kali almost at the same time I was.
How were Harrow readings handled?
Our GM stacked or partially stacked these. This ensured the cards contained real information (clues, warnings, or foreshadowing that might only make sense later) so I could take them seriously. The GM would provide Koya’s dialogue, and then I would meld Kali’s responses with it. Occasionally, we combined a reading with the
Harrowing spell as well, giving me mechanical bonuses to work into the result.
This meant Kali’s final interpretations of the readings weren’t just invented fortune-telling. They were my attempt to turn both the GM’s clues and the game mechanics into a meaningful narrative.
About “Pink Agates”
This was one of the earliest stories written for Kali, before the campaign even began, though (like here) it was not shared with our gaming group until midway through.
There is no Kali without Pink Agates. It is one of her formative stories. The goal was not to shock or create Trauma Girl with a Dark Past, but rather to help people understand her as a person. It was foundational to her relationship with violence, agency, control, vulnerability, protection, and, of course, her parents.
Kali actively managed her parents for years, limiting what they knew about the extent of what was happening to her. In the process, she and Ameiko also tried to manage the bullying themselves, rather than involve anyone who could actually put a stop to it. And it worked, right up until the day it didn’t.
This would later become central to the arc with the Prince in Ordu-Aganhei.
Qatana, WTF?
As of this writing, most of our group has been playing this game together for 30 years, dating back to D&D 2nd edition. To date, Qatana is the single most disruptive and controversial character ever to come to the table.
Everything about her was extreme: her backstory, her deity, her spell choices, how she was played—even her personal hygiene. She is proof that experienced gamers can still fall prey to It’s-What-My-Character-Would-Do, and that can negatively impact the game for everyone.
By the time we realized just how far this was going to go, Kali’s and Qatana’s histories had become deeply intertwined. Kali ended up being “the character that explained Qatana.” And because I was writing the journal from Kali’s viewpoint, explaining Qatana became my problem, too.
I won’t go so far as to say that I resented being at the table with Qatana, but it was
exhausting.
How much of Kali was planned out, and how much evolved from the table?
There were three major shifts in her as a character that evolved during play.
Kali as a nonlethal combatant
This decision was made very early on, specifically after the skirmish with trolls on their journey to Brinewall. With the exception of giant spiders, she would employ lethal force against
living creatures only in the most extreme circumstances (e.g., the Skalsbridge ambush). I broke this rule once on Snorri Stoneye’s funeral ship, but otherwise she avoided using damage-dealing spells against living beings. I even went so far as to take
Merciful Spell as a feat, and Sparna would later gift her with a
+1 merciful light crossbow.
Eventually, her list of exceptions would expand. See The Yuka Possession in “Game vs Journal”, below.
Multiclassing to Evangelist of Shelyn
This was the big one. It occurred after the destruction of the shrine to Shelyn in Kalsgard. It was the point where I realized the events of the campaign had become significant enough to change Kali’s direction as a PC.
Until then, Shelyn had mostly been part of Kali's background: important to her, but not something that substantially shaped how I played her. Seeing the ruined shrine changed that. I decided her faith needed to become central to her as a character, and not just an entry on her character sheet.
Multiclassing into the evangelist PrC meant deliberately dialing back her effectiveness as a wizard, but by then the change in her story mattered more to me than keeping her optimized. At the same time, this was still a cooperative game: I knew I could pull off evangelist because it gives a wizard a mini-gish chassis. It didn’t hamstring Kali or the party.
I’ll also admit that a wizard who carried a glaive did have a certain appeal.
And, purely for fun, I also “performed” her deific obedience at the table. I folded origami flowers and animals, and gave them to the other players and the GM.
Yuka’s influence
This had a profound effect on when she employed lethal force. See The Yuka Possession in “Game vs Journal”, below.
Game vs Journal
What follows are a few events where the actual table play can help explain what you see in the journal.
Prince Batsaikhar and Ordu-Aganhei
In the campaign, the Prince really does become infatuated with a PC, and really does propose to them. The Prince chose Kali, and that decision collided with Pink Agates to create something far more serious than an uncomfortable complication.
I couldn’t include everything in the journal because there was just
so much, so I want to call out the table support I received in this arc. The other players, and by extension the other PCs, rallied around Kali, and went to
extraordinary lengths to ensure she would be safe. On her first “date” with the Prince, they cast:
Delay Poison,
Status,
Enter Image,
Message (boosted with a Reach Metamagic Rod), and others to ensure Kali was never truly alone or without support. On her second “date”, when the Prince took her on a tour of the city—only mentioned in passing in the journal—she was escorted by Olmas (who carried Suishen), and was given a similarly long list of buffs. And these are just two of many examples.
In short, the other players chose to take Kali’s distress seriously.
My goal in this arc was to treat the topic with the gravitas it deserved. These were hard game sessions.
And, yes, Ivan’s player proposed that we kill Kali and resurrect her later.
The Yuka possession
The game mechanics were: Yuka’s spirit enters the character, and you temporarily gain the monk class feature
Still Mind as a boon. While she’s possessing you, she begs and urges you to kill Munasukaru. Once you do that, she goes to rest, and you permanently gain an exotic weapon proficiency.
Once the GM told me these urgings came with flashes of her memories, and that we could communicate in a sense, I started thinking: what would it be like for a character to suddenly have access to a whole set of memories that weren’t theirs? What if those memories included that person’s
torture and
eventual murder?
That’s when I realized this experience would permanently change Kali.
First, she had to make sense of a second consciousness being present alongside hers (I didn’t want to disrupt the game, though, so I kept that content to the journal). Then, she had to be affected by these new experiences.
Throughout this arc, she didn’t become
less Kali. Hobgoblins, oni, and their allies in the Penance simply had
no moral value to her. And she stopped holding back.
It took a few combat encounters for the other players to figure out that something had changed. And someone at the table—I believe it was Olmas’s player—really did say, “Kali seems more bloodthirsty than usual.”
I never explained it out of character to either the other players or the GM.
After the Yuka possession ended, I didn’t reset her to who she was before. She became less
enthusiastic about killing oni (for a while, anyway), but that raw hatred of them remained.
And I also didn’t want to let her off the hook. It would be easy to say, “Oh, that was Yuka influencing her,” and then move on. But that wasn’t what happened. Kali changed because of what Yuka’s memories showed her. Kali was
always making her own choices. This comes out most clearly in her conversation with her mother at the end of part four.
This decision to change how she was played had lasting consequences.
Much later on, when Ivan’s player asked me why I was willing to kill oni but not others, I really did answer with, “They aren’t real people.” She would, in fact, say this or some variation of it several times for the rest of the campaign.
Seinaru Heikiko
Ordu-Aganhei collided with Pink Agates. Seinaru Heikiko collided with Qatana’s backstory.
The assault on the fortress was a
huge fight that spilled over into a second game session, and it doesn’t get a single word in the journal. Why? Because the part that mattered to Kali was what happened
after.
There isn’t any subtlety to the setup. The women here are kept as slaves and locked in bamboo cages at night. That is straight out of the book.
Qatana learns this, and hits her breaking point for reasons deeply tied to her history. She orders the surviving bandits into the cages. One of them verbally protests, and she responds with
Phantasmal Killer.
It was one of the most shocking and disproportionately violent events at the table.
Then we learned that the women had all been abused, and all the bandits had been abusers. If the Yuka possession arc taught Kali that she could devalue oni, this event taught her something
worse: she could devalue people, too, if she thought their crimes were great enough. And she could get there on her own.
This was Kali at her lowest point. She really was ready to execute every one of them. One thing that held me back was that her combat spells were mostly prepared with
Merciful Spell, but…under the game rules, enough nonlethal damage can still kill, so I realized I could do it anyway. And I was pretty sure Qatana would join in.
So why didn’t she do it? Because Qatana had already come close to fracturing the game table, and I didn’t want to push us all the way there.
Enganoka
The market in Enganoka was the logical extension of Yuka and Seinaru Heikiko. This was Kali’s breaking point.
We were in initiative. Here’s an excerpt from my raw game log:
Ameiko: No action. She points out the guards have the legal authority to execute commoners for any reason, and that right or not, the party should not get involved.
Olmas: Moves in front of Ameiko
Guard 7: Says “You are guilty of spying and smuggling”, and executes the man on the spot.
Round 2
Kali: Casts Chain Lightning, catching all 8 guards.
Once he executed the man, Kali had no time to think, and neither did I. But on an instinctual level, I knew this was what she would do.
The connections in the journal came later. I wasn't constructing a character arc at the table: I was trying to understand why casting
Chain Lightning—which she had
not prepared with
Merciful Spell—felt like the obvious choice. At the time she cast it, we didn’t even know the guards were oni.
Renshii Meida’s pregnancy
This is included in the AP solely to be used as
leverage. It is one of several pieces of information you can use to sow discord among the Jade Regent’s inner circle, to reduce their combat effectiveness.
As a member of that inner circle, Meida is also one of the enemies the PCs are expected to face in the final battle. By making her pregnancy significant, the AP knowingly puts the players into combat with a pregnant woman.
It was an idea I found abhorrent, even as fantasy game content. This was a hard stop for me, and so it had to become a hard stop for Kali.
This left us with a huge problem. Meida was dangerous, and leaving her alone wasn’t an option. I was desperate for a solution, and this is where my suggestion to kidnap her came from. I really did bring it up at the table.
Of course, it was completely insane, and it never got past that crazy-idea stage, but it led to something that was
even better: the midwife scheme, delivering the letters to fracture the alliance, and the double
limited wish/petrification strategy in the final battle (which also made it the
most expensive fight in the entire campaign).
At no point did killing her go back on the table.
I don’t believe there’s subject matter which is inherently out of bounds for an RPG. But if you’re going to put something like this in the game, then you have to deal with the fact that you’ve put it in the game. If you add something this consequential, then the context has to carry actual weight. Reducing it to “leverage against the Jade Regent’s inner circle” wasn’t good enough for me.
The white dragon
This is one of the few times when the AP actually made me angry. The scenario is: the shaman smashes a white dragon’s eggs, and she retaliates against the village. The expected solution is to kill her.
While not as severe as Meida, it’s on the same road. The weight of the event—someone killing her children—is not supported by the story around it. I couldn't accept that the justification was simply, “Well, she's a white dragon.”
I really walked into her cave, alone, with nothing more than
Resist Energy and
Protection from Energy, to negotiate with her in good faith. And it didn’t work.
The Shinobi Fuhonsen
The AP hands the players a minor artifact with a long list of issues that boil down to: can’t (or shouldn’t) use it, can’t (or shouldn’t) sell it, can’t destroy it, and can’t ignore it because it’s on a timer.
The argument at the table was whether to use it as leverage with the Emerald Branch, or use it ourselves to keep it out of circulation until we could deal with it.
This
did fracture the game table. Qatana’s player was already unhappy with the direction the AP was taking, and this was the last straw. They quit the game that night.
Qatana’s player sent us her exit by email, and the journal captures it from Kali’s viewpoint.
Operation “Big Dumb Fight”
The table play was every bit as dumb as Kali makes it sound. Here’s my game log:
The party devises a direct strategy: just Dimension Door into the room with Sennaka and go to work. Olmas and Dasi discuss giving Sennaka time to surrender or stand down before engaging him personally.
5:30 pm
Kali starts casting Arcane Eye + True Seeing. The sensor moves to the outer sitting room and she sees the daimyo come through along with several guards. About half the guards are shapeshifted oni, as is the vizier.
She conveys their locations to the others and the party splits into two groups, with Ivan and Kali each using Dimension Door to jump into the room.
No attempt to cause a distraction. No attempt to spread them out. Just straight-up scry-and-die with a group outnumbering us 3:1, putting Kali in the middle of melee. I still don’t understand it.
But it worked.
Kikonu’s play
This was a throwaway detail in book one of the AP, and we got six books of value out of it.
This is Paizo at their best. No notes.
That shouldn’t have been possible!
Pathfinder has a mechanic (called Hero Points) for making the impossible possible in limited circumstances, with GM approval. Beyond that? Sometimes the GM allowed something using the Rule of Cool. And sometimes we just got a rule wrong.
So if you read something in the journal and think, “That spell doesn’t work that way,” or “You can’t actually do that,” you may be right.
Why switch to third-person narration at the end?
The journal became a deeply personal record of Kali as a person, but it couldn’t accurately capture the final battle. Her voice and viewpoint could only show what she experienced, and that was too narrow for the culmination of the campaign. That, and I didn't want the final battle to become a list of things Kali saw other people do.
To give the other players and their characters their due, I needed a wider lens.
Other Player Changes
Etayne Exits
Real life takes priority over gaming. Etayne’s player simply had too many demands on their time, and something had to give.
Anavaru Vanishes
The player just stopped coming to games. We kept Ana on as an NPC for a while because the player kept saying they’d be back, but eventually we parked her in the caravan, and I stopped writing about her in the present tense.
Sparna Exits, Dasi Enters
This was the same player. Sparna no longer felt connected to the AP, so they brought in a new character. There’s no larger story here: the player simply felt Dasi would fit the campaign better.
Zosi Enters
Zosi was played by a long-time friend of ours, dating back to our D&D 3.0 days. They wanted to get back into 3.x/OGL/PF, and they joined us in book four.
Did any of the other players/characters keep journals?
The players for Olmas, Ivan, and Qatana (up until the player left the game) all journaled regularly. One of the joys of the campaign was seeing the same events from four different perspectives.
∎