TheHand
+3 Backscratcher
Thanks for sharing your insights, just be aware the post you replied to was written 12 years ago so that person may not reply.I think you may be mistaken on the weight issue. Having handled both, in my experience, a European long sword FAR outweighs a Katana. Likewise, look at the many techniques that involve holding the scabbard with one hand while producing initial slashing strikes (and proceeding strikes depending on stance and fighting style) with the other hand.
The Katana was used by infantry and cavalry with a one handed slash straight from the scabbard (saya) in an upward or downward arc respectively.
Look at old Japanese art. Mounted warriors often wore their saya "upside down", while ground based infantry always wore the scabbards with the hilt sticking up.
The ideal was one draw, one slash, conflict ended.
Given the emphasis on precision over force in Bushido and the lesser martial philosophies, I find the Finesse property to be necessary, not just possible.
The historical switching between one and two handed use demands, not suggests, versatility.
A possible, non game breaking, benefit to a katana could be the use of the saya/scabbard as a low damage bludgeoning, off hand weapon used more for forcing movement and negating dex based AC.
The European longsword variations and the various takes on the katana have lent themselves to quite different fighting styles throughout real world history. They should do the same in our dork worlds.
And also, welcome to the forums!






