D&D 5E (2014) Katana in 5th edition - finesse?

I think you may be mistaken on the weight issue. Having handled both, in my experience, a European long sword FAR outweighs a Katana. Likewise, look at the many techniques that involve holding the scabbard with one hand while producing initial slashing strikes (and proceeding strikes depending on stance and fighting style) with the other hand.

The Katana was used by infantry and cavalry with a one handed slash straight from the scabbard (saya) in an upward or downward arc respectively.

Look at old Japanese art. Mounted warriors often wore their saya "upside down", while ground based infantry always wore the scabbards with the hilt sticking up.

The ideal was one draw, one slash, conflict ended.

Given the emphasis on precision over force in Bushido and the lesser martial philosophies, I find the Finesse property to be necessary, not just possible.

The historical switching between one and two handed use demands, not suggests, versatility.

A possible, non game breaking, benefit to a katana could be the use of the saya/scabbard as a low damage bludgeoning, off hand weapon used more for forcing movement and negating dex based AC.

The European longsword variations and the various takes on the katana have lent themselves to quite different fighting styles throughout real world history. They should do the same in our dork worlds.
Thanks for sharing your insights, just be aware the post you replied to was written 12 years ago so that person may not reply.

And also, welcome to the forums!
 

log in or register to remove this ad


It's a katana. Realistic stats should be

1d20 slashing versatile (2d20), reach, finesse, thrown (100/400)

:)

wrong, the katana needs to be at least 6d4 slashing, bludgeonging or piercing, versatile (12d4). It also grants a +4 shield bonus due to its awesomeness, and allows its wielder the ability to fly at twice their foot speed twice per day.

Don't forget

Special: Folded Steel Sundering. As a result of the katana's superior forging using many layers of thinly folded steel, any time you hit with an attack against an enemy holding a weapon and/or shield, you can instead choose to deal damage to one weapon or shield they are holding.

Look, fact man, when we want facts, we'll call you. Until then, we are talking about katanas. :p

A katana is definitely Brutal 20.

And does double damage to incorporeal creatures.

Thaumaturge.
THE POWER OF NIPPON STEEL!!
 

I blame an early Dragon Mag, namely the October 1976, Issue 3 (reprinted in The Best of Dragon Vol 2 (1981). They outlined a Samurai class, along with special rules for Katana, Wakizashi, and Yumi, including an incredibly OOT "optional" critical hit system for the swords. I played a Samurai in late 1e using those rules, hooboy.
 

I’m not convinced that a katana must be finesse. Versatile, yeah, for sure. As to which 5.5e mastery property it should have, I’m not sure.

As far as Japanese finesse weapons are concerned, I would suggest: the wakizashi, ninja-to, sai, kama, nunchaku… all of these definitely benefit from dextrous usage a lot more than a katana does, in my opinion.

Of course, from a true simulation perspective, all weapons actually benefit from both Dex and Strength, not just one or the other. D&D is a gross simplification. But in any case, a real katana is fairly heavy and harder to use quickly than the other weapons I mentioned above.

That’s just based on my limited experience training with these various weapons (with much less training volume than a samurai, I might add). Your mileage may vary.
 

Odd that this was reopened after all these years, but I am pretty certain we all collectively agreed that Katanas have the "Draw-Win" mastery property.

Draw-Win: When a weapon with this weapon mastery is drawn, regardless of the weilder's mastery proficiencies, that player wins the game as all foes immediately fall to pieces. Those with the proper mastery proficiency also win the next game.
 

THE POWER OF NIPPON STEEL!!
Behold Nippon power- from 175 yards and in, then I need something with a graphite shaft.

1792782255965.png
 

FWIW, I house ruled in my game that, with some extra training and practice (on top of proficiency), elven longswords can be used as finesse weapons when used in two hands. I also describe them in a vaguely katana-like manner. They're also more expensive.
 

FWIW, I house ruled in my game that, with some extra training and practice (on top of proficiency), elven longswords can be used as finesse weapons when used in two hands. I also describe them in a vaguely katana-like manner. They're also more expensive.
I would do it as a feat probably:
+1 dex or con
pick one melee weapon that you are proficient
you can use Dex instead of STR for attack and damage.
you can use Vex as it's weapon mastery
 

Remove ads

Top