Spoilers Lanterns season 1 spoilers discussion

Oh, I'm sure it'll be hilarious.
On the level of the Lanterns finale. ;)
I mean, it's literally a Looney Tunes portable hole, to the point it can just be hung in space. Like, how does one set the coordinates of one in the first place? There's no keypad, no interface, no anything. It's a hole. The Guardians technology is basically magic, so maybe all it needs is an idea of where the place is. Who knows. It's honestly not that important, and the breakout is less important than him being broken out.
Got it, wish-bridge to match the wish-rings it all tracks.

And "fortified" against what? Direct attack? Regular forms of teleportation? This is Guardian tech; it's clearly the same sort of bridge they used with John when he had his interview. Simply put, why would they defend against their own tech when they don't think anyone else out there would be able to make it? It doesn't matter how fortified something is if someone already is using your own codes.
I only meant that if he couldn't initially wish-bridge to Sinestro directly he would be wish-bridging to Spazkaban and doing reconnaissance work to find Sinestro - that would mean he would have to avoid fortification in terms of "patrols" and "cameras"
 

log in or register to remove this ad

On the level of the Lanterns finale. ;)

On the level of your media literacy. :p

Got it, wish-bridge to match the wish-rings it all tracks.

I see how you missed explicit facts in the show now. :unsure:

I only meant that if he couldn't initially wish-bridge to Sinestro directly he would be wish-bridging to Spazkaban and doing reconnaissance work to find Sinestro - that would mean he would have to avoid fortification in terms of "patrols" and "cameras"

Maybe, or maybe not. We have no real idea of what the limits of Guardian or Manhunter tech, what it requires, what it does. We see one ship/craft, whose purpose is not immediately identifiable. We see nothing really on the walls. There's an energy door. What he has to bypass and how isn't obvious... but also isn't the  point: as much as I'd love a space heist, that's not the focus here. We know that Manhunter tech is basically at the top of the chain. The important thing is that Sinestro was broken out, not the exact specifics of how.
 

I see how you missed explicit facts in the show now. :unsure:
That is because the wish-rings require the user to imagine the item they are creating, but these wish-bridges require nada.

But lets help the writers so that others reading this can too enjoy the wonderful job they have done.

Grandma Manhunter had perfect memory of Sinestro (she must have encountered him). This memory was then passed down through Manhunter code to the Miracle that is Noah. He then using this artificial genetic memory record was then able to perfectly capture the image of Sinestro thus being able wish-himself into his waiting arms via the wish-bridge.

Thus with our collective help we are able to enjoy the writing that is the Lanterns.
The Alexandrian Be Praised!

Many shows rely on show us and tell us,
And many prefer show, don't tell us,
Lanterns is unique, in that
It neither shows or tell us.
 
Last edited:

That is because the wish-rings require the user to imagine the item they are creating, but these wish-bridges require nada.

No, this is wrong. We don't know what they require. We literally know nothing of their creation, their setup, or anything other than they link two spots and you can move them. Like, do we know if you can track them? I would assume so, given that Noah found out where John and the Halogram hid it. But then again, he could have also figured that out on his own, since they weren't watching for him. Does this need to be explained? No. You understand it's possible in a variety of different ways, so the exact way he figured out where the hole was doesn't really matter.

But lets help the writers so that others reading this can too enjoy the wonderful job they have done.

Why? What more needs explaining? The exact method of this don't matter, any more than the physics of hearing spaceships in Star Wars. We don't need to see the heist because, ultimately, the heist isn't important: it could be amazing, it could be mundane, it could be any amount of things. What matters more is that Sinestro is out.

Grandma Manhunter had perfect memory of Sinestro (she must have encountered him). Th-is memory was then passed down through Manhunter code to the Miracle that is Noah. He then using this artificial genetic memory record was then able to perfectly capture the image of Sinestro thus being able wish-himself into his waiting arms via the wish-bridge.

Or she just knows where the Science Cells are because the Manhunters were around when they were around and the Guardians aren't exactly known for changing things up.

Or they are able to backtrack through Guardian tech because they are Guardian tech and the Guardians aren't on the lookout because they think they are all dead.

Or Manhunters are programmed with the location of the Science Cells since they were always meant to bring people back anyways, they just stopped doing it because they found a "better" way.

None of these really matter. It's not impossible or beyond their ken to be able to do such things: it's clear that the Manhunters can build portable holes to other planets. They have fantastic technology so amazing that Hal comments on it. This isn't D&D and we don't need to know the exact specifications of everything and how everything is done because we don't need to explain the why or why not of if a player can do it. Rings work on willpower, but we have no clue how that functions, why it's hard light, why any of that. It just is. In the end, the details of Sinestro's escape aren't the point: it's that he escaped and who broke him out.

Thus with our collective help we are able to enjoy the writing that is the Lanterns.
The Alexandrian Be Praised!

I mean, this was about as good as your last rewrite, which... well, don't give up your day job.

Many shows rely on show us and tell us,
And many prefer show, don't tell us,
Lanterns is unique, in that
It neither shows or tell us.

Nitpick here,
Nitpick there,
Some unneeded edits of plots,
That's how we miss the point today
And never connect the dots
 

No, this is wrong. We don't know what they require. We literally know nothing of their creation, their setup, or anything other than they link two spots and you can move them. Like, do we know if you can track them? I would assume so, given that Noah found out where John and the Halogram hid it. But then again, he could have also figured that out on his own, since they weren't watching for him. Does this need to be explained? No. You understand it's possible in a variety of different ways, so the exact way he figured out where the hole was doesn't really matter.
Why? What more needs explaining? The exact method of this don't matter, any more than the physics of hearing spaceships in Star Wars. We don't need to see the heist because, ultimately, the heist isn't important: it could be amazing, it could be mundane, it could be any amount of things. What matters more is that Sinestro is out.
I was reflecting on how if we use internal consistency on the wish-rings one can justify it with the wish-bridges.
You do not have that requirement necessary for enjoyment. That is fine. I do not believe your way makes for good entertainment.

Or she just knows where the Science Cells are because the Manhunters were around when they were around and the Guardians aren't exactly known for changing things up.

Or they are able to backtrack through Guardian tech because they are Guardian tech and the Guardians aren't on the lookout because they think they are all dead.

Or Manhunters are programmed with the location of the Science Cells since they were always meant to bring people back anyways, they just stopped doing it because they found a "better" way.
Thank you for DMsGuilding it. ;)

I mean, this was about as good as your last rewrite, which... well, don't give up your day job.
I'm utterly crushed, I hate my day job but I am loving my D&D these days.

Nitpick here,
Nitpick there,
Some unneeded edits of plots,
That's how we miss the point today
And never connect the dots
Connecting the dots is not important - just that the dots exist. :p
 

I was reflecting on how if we use internal consistency on the wish-rings one can justify it with the wish-bridges.
You do not have that requirement necessary for enjoyment. That is fine. I do not believe your way makes for good entertainment.

You can't reflect on "internal consistency" without knowing what's there: We don't have a clue how they operate beyond their function, trying to find "internal consistency" comes down to "makin' s*** up". If was contradicting something, then you'd have something, but instead we just have a lack of knowledge.

Thank you for DMsGuilding it. ;)

That's not "DMsGuilding it", that's "Midochlorian counting", creating reasons and explanations for things that just don't need them. TTRPGs and film media are just very different and trying to analyze them with the same stuff leads to the worst sort of "We need to explain this" in the sort of way that just misses the point. It's how you get Glup Shitto cameos that are only there to justify lore and not the story.

I'm utterly crushed, I hate my day job but I am loving my D&D these days.

I mean, your writing would probably be better for that, because it's a different kind of writing. It's like the reverse ZeeBashew joke about crunchy cyberpunk systems.


Connecting the dots is not important - just that the dots exist. :p

Connecting the dots means following what's there, not complaining about a lack of dots going in the direction you want. The dots connect fine, but you want a different set connecting to a different point before proceeding to its original destination. That's not a complaint about making the connection, it's a complaint about the route.
 

Anyway related to Guy generally being a dick I still think it was odd how entitled and possessive the Stewarts came off with regards to the Green Lantern role. Maybe they were intentionally riffing off of Gollum a wee bit there, idk.

I am not a comics reader nor have I seen much of Stewart outside of the cartoons. I guess I was mostly under the impression that he was maybe the steadiest GL. But maybe some of you could speak for the roundedness of his characterization over the years.
 

Sure.


So given that you are a GL fan in which comic will we see Guy being a lapdog?
Where in the lore could you logically reason that a Guy of 10 years GL experience give up Earth to a nobody?
That is what tv John Stewart is - a nobody.

You may want to refresh your memory about Guy with the 90's GL #25 - Guy willingly has a street fight with Hal to keep his position on the JLA. And he does this knowing full well the Guardians are behind Hal.
But with tv John Stewart who does not have Guardian support egocentric Guy is ok to leave Earth.

EDIT: Guy was in Emerald Fallout rather than Emerald Twilight during the Warrior run and in Emerald Dawn II he really features as a cameo as the councilor who wishes to assist Jordan who was in jail. This is pre him becoming a GL.


You just defeated your own argument. Alternate Universe :ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO:
So not like in the standard comics, so we are in agreement.


Ok. 🤷‍♂️
ok.
 

I will deal with the rest in a separate email

So let me get this straight this Einstein-Rosen bridge is a wish bridge where you need not have any familiarity with the place (or person) or coordinates you are going to? So Noah wished to go to a dude in the galaxy named Sinestro and that is where the bridge went to? Cause I imagine asking to go to Spazkaban would not be enough, presumably it is well fortified.
We could allow for Spazkaban reconnaissance but that is not much of a hurdle when we are having to overcome the ridiculousness of wish bridges in a supposedly grounded show which gets its ideas from Looney Tunes. :ROFLMAO:
It's a bridge, with two sides. Manhunter was on the planet before Sinestro was placed there, when killing the population. Left one side there. Brought the other with it, which was found later and used to travel to the planet.
 

Anyway related to Guy generally being a dick I still think it was odd how entitled and possessive the Stewarts came off with regards to the Green Lantern role. Maybe they were intentionally riffing off of Gollum a wee bit there, idk.

I am not a comics reader nor have I seen much of Stewart outside of the cartoons. I guess I was mostly under the impression that he was maybe the steadiest GL. But maybe some of you could speak for the roundedness of his characterization over the years.

You raise your kid to be a GL and do unspeakably s****y things to them, you gotta believe that it was all for a purpose. So yeah, you are going to think that spot is his, unquestionably. Otherwise, you were just abusing your kid for nothing.

As it stands, John is... I dunno, he became the second-dullest GL by default after Hal, largely because the cartoon defaulted him to "Marine" and that became one of the biggest touchstones in the comics after; he kept the background as an architect, but a lot of who he was got wrapped up in being a sniper. The show has, somehow, managed to put his Marine background pretty close to the front while also keeping the anti-authority bent which really defined him for his early period. He's not exactly Mosaic John, but I feel like his background here is one of the best meshes of both his original identity and the one he ended up gaining from Justice League.
 

Remove ads

Top