Let's talk GMless Story-games!

Thondor

I run Compose Dream Games RPG Marketplace
Full-disclosure I am funding a GM-less (or GM-full) story-game right now. God-Killer Prophecy: Oracle Edition https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/jkitz/god-killer-prophecy-oracle-edition/ , funding ends Oct 31st.

What GM-less games have you played? What did you like about them? What didn’t you like? How about your group?

For me there is often a freedom of creativity in these games due to the dispersed authority. You get to build aspects of the world together. It fires the imagination in a unique way.

Games I have played included The Quiet Year, Palanquin, The Hourglass Sings, Home Mech x Kaiju, Wanderhome, Kingdom, Universalis, and (using the rotating GM option) Vanagard. There are likely others I have forgotten. Of course I’ve played God-Killer Prophecy and it’s new variant Star-Killer Rebellion many times.

Are there any resources you’ve found useful for this type of play experience?
 

log in or register to remove this ad

In a Wicked Age is the one that I've played the most. There were once dozens of different genre and setting specific oracles online, too (losing Abulafia's random generators was a huge blow to my enjoyment of the game).
 

In a Wicked Age is the one that I've played the most. There were once dozens of different genre and setting specific oracles online, too (losing Abulafia's random generators was a huge blow to my enjoyment of the game).
Always unfortunate when you lose a useful resource like this.
What's the main feel of In a Wicked Age -- is it more writers room?
Perhaps a more a focused experience where the game itself assumes some of the GM role (though this may best be seen like an adventure/scenario) and leaves the players with a more specific type of story?

This seems to be one of the main GMless story-game splits.
 

The only one I've played I don't consider an RPG - it's a story game, but there's no real RP in my limited experience: The Quiet Year.

I've played a couple rotating GM games: Ars Magica (troupe style - each story has a GM, but GMing rotates through party), and Cosmic Patrol (scene by scene GM rotation and heavily scripted adventures).

Cosmic Patrol I enjoyed when I had cooperative players. But even one not onboard derails it. Further, the limited GM authority and the scripted adventures mean most scenes, the only question is how they accomplish the scene, not whether they do; the only way to fail a scene is generally a TPK. It's a "play to find out how" game, but with limited agency, since the end to the scene is predetermined - and public knowledge.
 

The only one I've played I don't consider an RPG - it's a story game, but there's no real RP in my limited experience: The Quiet Year.
This depends a little on what you consider RP. You aren't playing an individual in the Quite Year, you are playing a community. This often means you will create factions and individuals in those factions. The "hold a discussion action" is where actual dialogue often takes place when I play.
I said something like this in a game last year: Francis of the cult of the rising sun says "We should expel these new arrivals with force. They cannot be trusted, caused the death of Thomas, and will corrupt our community."
As you get to the end of the game session you should have multiple factions, and multiple individuals and usually each player will have faction(s) they usually speak for.
 

The two which I've played to completion (Star Trek Captain's Log & The Dark Eye - Vampire the of Havena), I ran via my 2 VTTs. I've tried running solo in the past via tabletop, but never managed to complete one before my beloved board and mininatures games needed their table space. And despite taking a snapshot and making a record of where I was, I just never got back to them. I find having the supporting structure of a VTT with the adventures progress auto-saved, made it easier to return to them.

It's been a while, but the Vampire of Havena is prewritten with multiple choices. I'm not so familair with story-games, but VoH might just fit what constitutes one. While official TDE rules content is available for Foundry, at the time the adventure wasn't. That required me to do a fair bit of copying & pasting into a Foundry compendium. Worth the effort though, as it ran well and I definitely felt a sense of satisfaction and completion at the end. I love the lore for TDE's continent of Aventuria and VoH definitely gave me some.

The Star Trek Captain's Log are solo rules for the Star Trek Adventures TTRPG. It uses many tables for random generation of plot elements. So, it probably doesn't fit the classification of a story-game. It's available as official content for my Fantasy Grounds VTT, which meant the many tables were pre-created - thank goodness, as there's a lot! As you can imagine the overall adventure structure, content and sub-missions were very dynamic. It took a fair amount of plugging away until I could fully grok how all things work and run it fluidly. In the end it did create a sense that I'd played out at an entertaining adventure. A really good use of Captains Log though, is to more selectively use it to playtest homebrewed adventures. So if done right, not only are you homebrewing, but you're also experiencing it as a player.

I also own the Mythic Game Emulator for one of my VTTs, but haven't spent much time with it - far from mastering it. It would allow me to run solo any of the TTRPGs I own for the Fantasy Grounds VTT; 12 at last count. So yeah, VTTs really work for me, but I'm 5 years retired from the Software/Info Tech biz. I'm not sure I'd be as enthused for them, were I to be still gazing at a PC screen all day.
 
Last edited:

The two which I've played to completion (Star Trek Captain's Log & The Dark Eye - Vampire the of Havena), I ran via my 2 VTTs. I've tried running solo in the past via tabletop, but never managed to complete one before my beloved board and mininatures games needed their table space.
Hrmm, the subject of the thread is still games played in a group, not solo games. GMless games are often one-shots so you can get together with buddies and play a complete game in under four hours. There's a term I am forgetting for ones you play in about an hour or less.
Think much like a film is a complete story in 2 hours, these are complete in a single session.
 

What's the main feel of In a Wicked Age -- is it more writers room?
It's not writers' room, but it's also not GMless. (At least as written by Vincent Baker. Maybe there's a GMless variant that I don't know about?)

What GM-less games have you played? What did you like about them? What didn’t you like? How about your group?
Mobile Frame Zero:Firebrands is the only literally GMless game that I've played recently: Playing "storygames": Mobile Frame Zero - Firebrands; and Showdown

Some years ago now my group played a session of Orbital (No Dice, No Masters). The framing was a bit flabby at times.

I've played co-GMed Burning Wheel - two players, each of whom frames/adjudicates for the others' PC - and that works pretty well: Played Burning Wheel today
 

Hrmm, the subject of the thread is still games played in a group, not solo games. GMless games are often one-shots so you can get together with buddies and play a complete game in under four hours. There's a term I am forgetting for ones you play in about an hour or less.
Think much like a film is a complete story in 2 hours, these are complete in a single session.
Ah OK. The moment I saw GMless, I thought soloable - my bad. Other than a ST Captain's log session which was an episodic adventure I played through alongside my hosted players, I haven't really explored this Story genre.
 

Ah OK. The moment I saw GMless, I thought soloable - my bad. Other than a ST Captain's log session which was an episodic adventure I played through alongside my hosted players, I haven't really explored this Story genre.
There are some GMless games that are designed as and marketed as solo or group play. Some I'm familiar with are even ones I mentioned in my opening post: The Hourglass Sings and Home Mech x Kaiju. Another I can think of is A Perfect Rock.
Generally though I think these are better as group games, but I am biased towards that style of gaming. Generally if I am going to do a solo game I prefer the more game book style i.e. make a character, mechanics + chose your own adventure style.

The session I played of The Hourglass Sings with the designer Kurt Refling this summer - I can't imagine coming up with anything nearly as compelling on my own. Five players riffing on each other's ideas was so interesting.
This one is purely prompt based, so you draw a card, read the prompt and then narrate something that is going on. There's a little more to it than that (roles that rotate and the hero resetting time - emulates restarting the game).

The difference between The Hourglass Sings and my game, God-Killer Prophecy is mine has that prompt layer of shared creativity, but also rotates into a adventure phase with a strategic layer. I think we can have both great things at the same time.

edit to add - my game funded but just shy of doing a SRD, so I've thrown up a pre-order page to see if we can get there.
 

Remove ads

Top