Mea Culpas, Memberberries, and Starfleet Academy- Nostalgia is a Toxic Impulse

Yeah, I'd say they're more pro-voice activated software than they are AI. "Computer, search for...." instead of typing it in. Anything that eliminates humanity from the equation, even cybernetic "improvements" are generally frowned upon.

And, let's remember that Trek is not, by and large, supposed to be a simulation of a real, working world. It is a set up for individual narratives. The computers are the way they are so that we get through what would be tedious bits quickly. They aren't intended as a serious examination of how computing works.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Yep. But all individuals, not as a class.

In Picard, Season 1, the Federation/Starfleet (I forget who is actually responsible for them) makes a class of second-rate Soong-type androids for menial/dangerous work, and that ends... badly.
Sure, but it's also implied the whole process was tampered with, and we meet a whole society of fully independent and sentient androids later. And any bad decisions those guys make are their own in a very human way.

And, let's remember that Trek is not, by and large, supposed to be a simulation of a real, working world. It is a set up for individual narratives. The computers are the way they are so that we get through what would be tedious bits quickly. They aren't intended as a serious examination of how computing works.
Good point. This is true of so much science fiction, and so many people take it too seriously or demand that it all be "hard" sci fi. Sometimes it's just about a story or about a social parallel or point.
 

Sure, but it's also implied the whole process was tampered with...

Yes, but it was tampered with by? Ultimately interdimensional AI-MechaCthulhu, which is not a talking point that AI is warm and chummy.

...and we meet a whole society of fully independent and sentient androids later. And any bad decisions those guys make are their own in a very human way.

Ech. Don't get me started on the whole, "We can make an android that scans like a human" thing. It gives me heartburn, but in my brain.

Good point. This is true of so much science fiction, and so many people take it too seriously or demand that it all be "hard" sci fi. Sometimes it's just about a story or about a social parallel or point.

Even within something that is hard sci-fi, you will get an author making something work out the way they want, for the story. Interstellar is so busy holding to elements of hard science, and then... Whoopsie! It's all solved by the power of loooooove.
 
Last edited:

Yes, but it was tapered with by? Ultimately interdimensional AI-MechaCthulhu, which is not a talking point that AI is warm and chummy.
Actually it was the Zhat Vash what did it, in order to discredit AI research and push people away from it.

As to the guys you mentioned, I really wish season 2 had been about going to meet them and convince them we can all just get along. There was a lot they could have done there. Also I wanted more Narek. But I was happy with what I got for season 2 and then failed to get into season 3.
 

Actually it was the Zhat Vash what did it, in order to discredit AI research and push people away from it.

And look what that got them? That's why I said "ultimately". It is basically the prophecy that makes itself happen.

As to the guys you mentioned, I really wish season 2 had been about going to meet them and convince them we can all just get along.

Meh? I don't think that'd be a particularly Star Trek story.

But I was happy with what I got for season 2 and then failed to get into season 3.

I haven't watched Season 2 yet. I wasn't actually wowed by the whole plot of Season 1, and wasn't going to watch any more of it, but the fan service of Season 3 dragged me back in. I'll get around to Season 2 eventually.
 


Journeying to an undiscovered place and making peace with your enemies?

No, the politics of getting the humans/Federation to agree to working together any time soon - the rogue synths killed some 3000 people, and destroyed the Utopia Planitia shipyards, IIRC so getting trust there would be a major, but adventure-television-boring, political and public relations undertaking.
 

No, the politics of getting the humans/Federation to agree to working together any time soon - the rogue synths killed some 3000 people, and destroyed the Utopia Planitia shipyards, IIRC so getting trust there would be a major, but adventure-television-boring, political and public relations undertaking.
I was thinking more of the "send Picard and this same team off one a long shot chance to scout out/derail this problem," which I think is very much in the area of what was already happening. But I don't want to derail this thread with my stupid fanfic (effectively) ideas! I agree with you if they focused on the politics it would be boring as hell!

cosmic-wars-the-gathering-shadow-1280w-242897622.jpg
 

Remove ads

Top