D&D General Mearls is Wrong- Why 4e Actually "Failed"

Status
Not open for further replies.
Of course, not everyone who disliked 4e was engaging in this sort of rhetorical maneuver. There were people who genuinely struggled to articulate what they disliked about the edition, and people who simply had different expectations of what D&D should be. Those are legitimate perspectives. My criticism is more directed at the broader pattern of discourse, where subjective dissatisfaction was frequently expressed as objective condemnation, only to be reframed as personal preference when challenged.
See also: "dissociated mechanics". Picture perfect demonstration of reifying personal preference. Doubly so when its namer, the Alexandrian, then had to contort himself into knots to explain why Numenera's use of dissociated mechanics is not only good, not only great, but one of the best tools for driving roleplay....after having literally said that the use of dissociated mechanics is inherently incompatible with roleplay.

So... yeah. This is absolutely, 100% a real phenomenon, that has documented examples.
 

log in or register to remove this ad


They can be a hybrid, and be able to dabble several of these roles without being stellar in any single role.
Certainly. Every 4e class has at least one subrole, usually influenced by its power source. Some have two. So, for instance, Bard is a Leader, but the Arcane source has an innate Controller inflection, so Bards are naturally able to dabble, and can genuinely go fully hybrid.

And I think outside 4e characters often are like that.
In my experience, which at this point is quite extensive, doing so is a profoundly foolish choice for most character concepts in 3e, because trying to do more than two things is usually very detrimental. It can be done, don't get me wrong, but it requires extreme optimization skill.

In 5e, it's much rarer for three reasons. One, all characters are damage-dealers who moonlight in something else, or are fully both a damage dealer and some other thing. Two, 5e GMs are mostly extremely hostile to the only remaining levers of mechanical depth, namely multiclassing and feats, so good luck actually doing any role-mixing. And three, games mostly end before that can happen, even if you don't have my luck.

Like for example the valour bard in my 5e game does not neatly fit in these roles, as they're a leader/controller hybrid with some defender capabilities as well.
They're a striker with spellcasting, because spellcasting lets you do everything. As usual. While the non-casters are lucky if they ever get to do anything but say "I swing my sword".

You also usually have some build option that can allow you to choose what sort of stuff you want to excel at.
Not really. Fighters don't, for example. Well, I mean, you do have the Banneret, but it sucks SO BADLY that pretty much nobody wants to play it. Possibly the only subclass that threatened to take last place from the dueling pair of Beastmaster and Berserker.

Only 4e wanted to pigeonhole characters into one role because it was trying to emulate MMOs.
Nnnnnnnnnope. Great try at a strawman though.
 

Alexandrian takes the argument too far, but the disassociated mechanics thing absolutely does explain a lot of the pushback 4e got.
It really, really doesn't, mostly because it's a distinction without an actual difference.

All mechanics are necessarily dissociated to some degree. Otherwise, you'd be LARPing.
 

You keep adding non phb options. 3E that was all in the phb. Bard archer in the phb?
And you keep using this standard. None of us agreed to abide by it. Hell, you barely abide by it.

So convince me that that's the standard we should use, if you can. Show me why that is the one and only standard of valid comparison. I strongly suspect you won't be able to.
 


And, if we're talking about why olives don't go in fruit salad, then I'd 100% understand someone who said, "Olives don't feel like a fruit to me."
okay but you see how that could perhaps just as much apply to a banana or melon right? if it's just an opinion, it's not actually a reason why they shouldn't be in a fruit salad, an actual justifiable reason would be something like 'olives have a far more intense savoury taste that jarrs with the flavour profile of the rest of the salad' (if that's wrong my justification is i dont like olives and haven't eaten one in years, i don't remember what they specifically taste like) that's something objective you can point to why they shouldn't be put in a fruit salad.
 

“Some degree.” And that degree matters. It is not all the same.
If all mechanics are at least some minimum amount dissociated, then it cannot be the case that a mechanic being dissociated is a dividing line. All mechanics sit on one side of that alleged distinction.

And I guarantee that any argument claiming that there is some kind of measurable "amount" of dissociated-ness, let alone that there is some sort of hidden breakpoint, would die in the neverending throes of subjectivity, which is precisely why "dissociated" was invented in the first place. It was never about any objective quality. It was always about trying to pass off taste as objective fact.
 

okay but you see how that could perhaps just as much apply to a banana or melon right? if it's just an opinion, it's not actually a reason why they shouldn't be in a fruit salad, an actual justifiable reason would be something like 'olives have a far more intense savoury taste that jarrs with the flavour profile of the rest of the salad' (if that's wrong my justification is i dont like olives and haven't eaten one in years, i don't remember what they specifically taste like) that's something objective you can point to why they shouldn't be put in a fruit salad.
The reason to not include olives in a fruit salad is because most people don't like the combination of the flavor of olives with the flavor of other fruits. Olives are fruit, but generally understood as a culinary vegetable. Fruit salads use culinary fruits, which means mostly sweet or tart things.

Likewise, tomato is a fruit, but it is not used in fruit salad because tomatoes, despite containing a fair amount of sugar, do not taste "sweet" to most people.

This doesn't mean no one could ever make a fruit salad containing tomatoes and olives. Perhaps a variety of pear or cherry tomato bred for being especially sweet could work, since those resemble berries, and things like golden berries are surprisingly similar to tomatoes. Meanwhile, the olives could be used in a careful, restrained way, focusing on their floral, herbal, slightly peppery flavors, as a pop of contrasting flavor, or perhaps there's a way to make sweet-pickled olives, which might work well in a traditional fruit salad (I've no idea, there are sweet pickles so surely there must be some sweet olives too?)

Point being, it's not some objective law of food. It's just that fruit salads are usually sweet, and olives and tomatoes are usually savory. To make it work, you'd need to examine the ingredients carefully.
 

If all mechanics are at least some minimum amount dissociated, then it cannot be the case that a mechanic being dissociated is a dividing line. All mechanics sit on one side of that alleged distinction.

Too disassociated. Too spicy, too sweet, too scary. Not a hard concept.

And I guarantee that any argument claiming that there is some kind of measurable "amount" of dissociated-ness, let alone that there is some sort of hidden breakpoint, would die in the neverending throes of subjectivity, which is precisely why "dissociated" was invented in the first place. It was never about any objective quality. It was always about trying to pass off taste as objective fact.

It is somewhat subjective, but it is not random. Like it is subjective how scary one finds "the Ring," but it is not unexplainable mystery why a lot of people find it pretty scary, and people who want to craft movies that a lot of people find scary are indeed able to intentionally do so. Similarly it is not a mystery what sort of things people in general find make a mechanic feel disassociated and how to design mechanics so that less people feel that way.

But like I said, not amount of articulation is sufficient. If people are working very hard to not to get something, then they will usually succeed. I can only surmise that I hallucinated 4e failing, and everyone actually likes it, and it remains as the current edition of D&D, as there is not possible acceptable reason for disliking it!
 

Status
Not open for further replies.
Remove ads

Top