D&D General Mearls on Why D&D 4E "Failed"

For Balance maybe, but i think a world where it's just humans that breathe fire, humans that live long lives, humans that are tall and can carry alot and that's the only fictional differences - i would find that world very bland.
Well, there would be cultural mindsets as well, depending where the character grew up. And most ancestries would have a few abilities and riders rather than just one (that sometimes tie wonderfully into how certain classes operate and open up interesting play options).

But if you're saying that adjustments to attributes are the prime thing that differentiates ancestries from just being "humans that can breathe fire", then there I disagree. Ability adjustments and limits are both odd to me (PCs often break the mold) and also the least interesting thing to do to try and say "this is not just a human with long ears." :)
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Indeed, I think 3E introduced some social skills, but never really any good instruction on how to use them in an encounter. So, there was often, "I say some things and chuck a D20" and the GM rules by do or do not there is no degree. While I like degrees of success systems, I dont think D&D absolutely needs one.
I'm more than fine with degrees of success systems and, informally, am constantly using them. Roll barely more than what you need and I'll narrate it that you barely succeeded or there was some minor complication; roll barely less than you need and I'll narrate it as close but no cigar. Roll really well, and I'll narrate that you sailed through with ease; roll really badly and I'll tell you

What I will not do is narrate a fail roll as a success with complications. The fail-success is still binary; and you can't succeed if the roll says fail.
I think moving forward to 4E the skill challenge often failed to excite because it was basically a group roll off best of (number of players) situation. If you stretched the skill challenge out to an actual series of scenes with interesting twists from start to finish, they wouldnt seem so group binary. I actually took the same social scenes from above and did the same with exploration. Entire sessions moving through interesting and dangerous places without a combat in sight. It's all in how you present and run it. YMMV.
In my defense, all I had to go on when looking at 4e skill challenges were the first DMG and some modules. That said, the whole idea left me rather unimpressed.
 

And yes, I'm far on the War side when it comes to war-v-sport. It saddens me that combat-as-sport in the game even became a thing, outside of when someone is running something like an in-game jousting tournament.
Yep once those pesky videogames started getting popular, especially those darn Japanese Role-Playing Games and Last Fantasies or Final Stories, Tales of What-have-you, it was pretty much inevitable.

Good thing too, its probably brought more people into the hobby, even if we don't always agree.
 

They shouldn't be though... the reason you're tracking failiures VS success SHOULD be so you can have a conclusion to the challenge where things don't always have clear cut outcomes. That's what skill challenges SHOULD be about, and the DMG1 just messed them up from the get go.
I never read it that way, instead seeing it as just a very elaborate version of a single-roll skill check; a dice game where you needed to reach X before Y.
But 3e already had saving throws (FORT, REF and WILL), why not use THOSE? Why invent a while new form of AC when you could just have spells against FORT or REF? Or, like in 4e, ranged attacks against Fortitude, Reflex or Will defenses.
Because sometimes a spell has a physical element that has to get through the target's defenses, or a visible element that can maybe be dodged or that the caster can mis-aim (e.g. a ray), before any saving throw even comes into play. It makes such spells that much harder to land - I assume by design - as two rolls have to go your way rather than just one.
 

Same way I model the situation where the act of delivering said blow causes fatigue: I don't.

There's an argument to be made that I should, perhaps; but as the combatants would all tire at roughly the same rate it's easy to say that it all just cancels out and thus can be ignored.

That's the sort of thing fumble rules are for. :)
Let's consider some extreme examples -- where indirect hit point loss actually kills someone:

Myocardial Infarction
Odo deftly turns your blow, but his exhaustion is now apparent. Suddenly, he freezes and clutches his chest. He crumples to the ground. You kneel next to him as his eyes glaze over.

“Too much salt pork,” you whisper, and smile pitilessly.

Cerebrovascular Event
Hans puffs and strains. His skin is flushed from exertion. You lunge at him and he avoids the thrust, but his face suddenly twitches and convulses. His sword drops from his hand and he collapses. You kneel next to him as his eyes glaze over.

“An apoplexy?” You inquire. “How ignoble.”

Subdermal Hematoma
Kurt stumbles back as he avoids your onslaught. He trips and falls, his head smashing into the ground. Blood seeps from beneath his helmet. You kneel next to him as his eyes glaze over.

“An inglorious end to a worthy foe,” you acknowledge. You reflect that falls are the leading cause of accidental deaths since 2003 according to the CDC.

How would you model these events? Do you think that they offer an opportunity for pathos -- or humour?
 

Let's consider some extreme examples -- where indirect hit point loss actually kills someone:

Myocardial Infarction
Odo deftly turns your blow, but his exhaustion is now apparent. Suddenly, he freezes and clutches his chest. He crumples to the ground. You kneel next to him as his eyes glaze over.

“Too much salt pork,” you whisper, and smile pitilessly.

Cerebrovascular Event
Hans puffs and strains. His skin is flushed from exertion. You lunge at him and he avoids the thrust, but his face suddenly twitches and convulses. His sword drops from his hand and he collapses. You kneel next to him as his eyes glaze over.

“An apoplexy?” You inquire. “How ignoble.”

Subdermal Hematoma
Kurt stumbles back as he avoids your onslaught. He trips and falls, his head smashing into the ground. Blood seeps from beneath his helmet. You kneel next to him as his eyes glaze over.

“An inglorious end to a worthy foe,” you acknowledge. You reflect that falls are the leading cause of accidental deaths since 2003 according to the CDC.

How would you model these events? Do you think that they offer an opportunity for pathos -- or humour?
Truth be told, I probably wouldn't even try to model them. Yes they offer opportunities for some pathos, humour, and one-way roleplaying; but there's two things running against it:

--- the players wouldn't like it if I started killing their PCs this way; and if something works on NPCs then it works on PCs too
--- magical healing would at some point likely have cured these conditions in any case, and most worthy foes will have had lots of access to such over time just like the PCs have.
 

I never read it that way, instead seeing it as just a very elaborate version of a single-roll skill check; a dice game where you needed to reach X before Y.
It was badly explained and badly written. A lot of fans made better variation on the concept. A skill challenges really work better as a tracking mechanic for a DM of how well the Players are doing reaching a specific goal, and should be pretty much invisible to the players. Heck, you can even stretch it to more than one session if they get distracted. Like in the sandstorm navigation, a fail at a certain moment could end up with the heroes getting into a fight they didn't plan on. You should also prepare outcomes beforehand, including what happens when the players fail.

I've done it and in play it worked pretty well, you just have to sometimes prod the players like "and while this is going on are any of your guys doing anything else?" but I foolishly hadn't prepared for a failiure state... Oops. Oh well, lesson learned.
 

Truth be told, I probably wouldn't even try to model them.
That seems like a missed opportunity to expand verisimilitude.
Yes they offer opportunities for some pathos, humour, and one-way roleplaying; but there's two things running against it:

--- the players wouldn't like it if I started killing their PCs this way; and if something works on NPCs then it works on PCs too
Don’t you let players narrate the particulars of their own character’s demise?
--- magical healing would at some point likely have cured these conditions in any case, and most worthy foes will have had lots of access to such over time just like the PCs have.
Your world has cured high cholesterol, high blood pressure and accidental death from banging your head? That must be nice.
 

Indeed, I think 3E introduced some social skills, but never really any good instruction on how to use them in an encounter. So, there was often, "I say some things and chuck a D20" and the GM rules by do or do not there is no degree. While I like degrees of success systems, I dont think D&D absolutely needs one. Or, I guess I sort of worked it out over the years. I'd set up entire sessions that were dinners with well to dos, court room trials, taverns full of strangers, getting the lay of a new village/town, etc.. There would be a series of checks as the PCs would try and discover information, determine dispositions, change minds, gain allies, create enemies, etc.. There was never a final determination based on a single die roll. Paizo did a great job of expanding skills and encounters in the APs and with Ultimate Intrigue. Something ive never really seen in a D&D product.

I think moving forward to 4E the skill challenge often failed to excite because it was basically a group roll off best of (number of players) situation. If you stretched the skill challenge out to an actual series of scenes with interesting twists from start to finish, they wouldnt seem so group binary. I actually took the same social scenes from above and did the same with exploration. Entire sessions moving through interesting and dangerous places without a combat in sight. It's all in how you present and run it. YMMV.
I do think that 4e Skill Challenges were meant to help counter the 3e Diplomancer who "I roll Diplomacy to persuade to guard, and it autosucceeds because I have a +X skill check as well as Y and Z..." Skill Challenges were meant to disrupt the binary pass/fail as well as make skill checks a bit more interesting. I think that a number of problems with how skills worked in 4e were far more egregious in 3e D&D and even Pathfinder 1. FWIW, I also think that this is also what rubbed some people the wrong way about 4e: it curbed some of the excesses of 3.X that some players enjoyed.

I do think that if fiction-first mechanics had been more in-vogue at that time, 4e likely would have adopted something more along those lines. But "fiction-first" wasn't really being articulated as such until, ironically enough, around 2008.

Despite not wanting folks yelling out go for the "NADs" when playing, I want my damn saving throws! Nothing is more exciting than having the fate of your character's life in your own dice throwing hands. 4E defenses may have been more expedient, but they were far far less exciting for me as a player.
Oh, I loved them as a GM and as a player.

If we are talking about some of the big babies that I had not wished that 5e had thrown out with the bathwater, I would say that one of my personal ones was Defenses. Having attacks, spells, and abilities roll against the targets' Defenses was a fantastic change. Getting rid of that though felt like a step backwards again.
 

It was badly explained and badly written. A lot of fans made better variation on the concept. A skill challenges really work better as a tracking mechanic for a DM of how well the Players are doing reaching a specific goal, and should be pretty much invisible to the players.
How can it be invisible to the players when they're rolling all those dice? Or are you saying the DM should do the rolling?
Heck, you can even stretch it to more than one session if they get distracted. Like in the sandstorm navigation, a fail at a certain moment could end up with the heroes getting into a fight they didn't plan on. You should also prepare outcomes beforehand, including what happens when the players fail.
With the sandstorm piece I was in react mode: they'd try something, I'd do some rolling (if needed) and say what happened next. Fairly granular. For the most part they sailed through, but they did get split up at one point (they were lucky and managed to reunite), and someone had a very expensive magical cloak blow away in the wind never to be seen again.

Preparing the fail state ahead of time would probably have ended up being constraining.
 

Remove ads

Top