D&D General Mearls on Why D&D 4E "Failed"

That seems like a missed opportunity to expand verisimilitude.

Don’t you let players narrate the particulars of their own character’s demise?
No-one's ever expressed any desire to do so.
Your world has cured high cholesterol, high blood pressure and accidental death from banging your head? That must be nice.
I read your examples as being caused by deformity rather than disease. The first two would be caught by Cure Disease (I'm not sure if 5e still has that spell or whether disease is even still considered a hazard); and given the amount of hard hits these guys take if the third hasn't manifested by the end of 1st level the character is probably good to go. :)
 

log in or register to remove this ad

No-one's ever expressed any desire to do so.

I read your examples as being caused by deformity rather than disease. The first two would be caught by Cure Disease (I'm not sure if 5e still has that spell or whether disease is even still considered a hazard); and given the amount of hard hits these guys take if the third hasn't manifested by the end of 1st level the character is probably good to go. :)

Lesser restoration now.
 

I'm not trying to answer for @soviet ; however, I do feel your question misses the mark a bit. The PC doesn't need to associate the mechanic with every possible fiction, just the one(s) they are presented with.

My group never faced and ooze, so they had no need to consider how "Come and get it" might work on an ooze. It only works once because the opportunity only comes up once (i.e it doesn't work all the time). The assumption is the fighter is always taunting, but only once in a great while does it actually work - that is when the power is spent.

But that is disassociated then. The PC does not know they have ability to taunt anything without a fail and that they can do so only once.

What you have here is player using a plot coupon, and a fictional rationalisation what happens in the fiction once they do. But that is not what association requires, it requires association of the character and player decision making.
 

Because the changes required to answer those concerns would require adding more fiddly rules. If you're willing to tolerate adding two to five steps to every combat round to make it associated, be my guess.

And that is perfectly valid reason to not bother to associate the rules. It would be too much of a hassle. It however has nothing to do with anyone's imagination.
 

Absolutely. To me, the ideal would be a very grounded, relatively low magic L1-6, a more magical but still pretty grounded L7-12, a high magic, high concept L13-16, and a gonzo superhero L17-20.

Whilst 5e has the tiers of play, they actually do not do anything with it and it is not emphasised. I actually really liked how 4e codified the character's epicness progression with paragon paths and epic destinies. However, counter-intuitively, I feel 4e is the edition where the feel of the play changes the least over the levels. You are a Hollywood action hero from the get go and the top tier magic is nerfed. Granted, I've only played 4e to level 20, and did not experience epic destinies. We chose them, but at that point the GM was fed up with the system and decided that switching to some sort of Fate-hack would better support the characters slowly ascending to godhood.

But I think this sort of explicit tier progression is a good thing, and it is something I'd like to see better implemented in the future editions of the game.
 

All this talk around hitting, dodging, blocking and damage is really reminding me why I prefer armour as damage reduction.

And martial training in general should make you better at avoiding and dealing damage. A Wizard with +3 Dex and a Fighter with +3 Dex out of armour should not be equally as easy to hit.

I actually really like the idea of the martial die pool, because I think it's an excellent way to model a trained fighter. Expending die to boost attack rolls, damage rolls, AC, and class-dependent techniques is a great way to model a combatant's short-term reserves and stamina. Let them spend HD to recharge the pool, and the stamina/exhaustion mechanics get tied together.
 

For me, meta-mechanics, where the player can choose to change something in the at-table game state without regard to how this makes sense in-fiction, are always dissociative. Example: pretty much any mechanic that after a player knows the result of a die roll, lets that player choose to alter that result or re-roll that die.
In my opinion, "meta-mechanics" like that are something immune from falling under the definition because they do not directly resolve into something seen in-world at all. Things I would consider immune:
  • Rerolls, they happen before an action is resolved and appears in the fiction
  • Advantage/disadvantage, they happen before an action is resolved
  • Random table rolls, sometimes, when they are modeling the unknown
  • e.g. Fate points, as they are player narrative and not what a character is even aware of.
They are not associated, I will grant you, but they really can't be, either, because they make no appearance in world, they modify the effects of a game element or guide the narrative with an unseen hand.

EDIT: I forgot the big one, doing arithmetic on a die roll; the character knows abstractly they are better or worse at something (sometimes) sure, but not that it is rendered as a discrete mathematical superiority/inferiority over the average.
 
Last edited:

I'm not trying to answer for @soviet ; however, I do feel your question misses the mark a bit. The PC doesn't need to associate the mechanic with every possible fiction, just the one(s) they are presented with.

My group never faced and ooze, so they had no need to consider how "Come and get it" might work on an ooze. It only works once because the opportunity only comes up once (i.e it doesn't work all the time). The assumption is the fighter is always taunting, but only once in a great while does it actually work - that is when the power is spent.
However, that one time opportunity to get a creature, regardless of intelligence or tactic, so angered and frustrated they run at you black-ninja style and get hit, happens once every encounter. Oozes? CaGI. Hobgoblins? CaGI. Mind flayers? CaGI. Orcus? CaGI! If you can hit their defense, Its CaGI'in Time!
 

Because the changes required to answer those concerns would require adding more fiddly rules. If you're willing to tolerate adding two to five steps to every combat round to make it associated, be my guess.
It's the age-old problem of encounter design and how much your willing to shut down a players abilities. Monsters have had resistances and abilities that shut down certain classes (creatures requiring magic to be hit, creatures with magic resistance, creatures immune to sneak attack) but you run real risk of making a character useless if used too much (ask as 3e rogue in a undead filled tomb). However, 4e tried to eliminate that because encounter powers were so vital to the math, you could not afford losing them to immunity or other shut down defenses. Which is why the game removed magic resistance, immunity to normal weapons, and only sparingly used energy resistance (red dragon and fire) or condition resistance (ghosts immune to fear), which helped make most monster we encounters interchangeable with other monsters of a similar level and role.

5e I think stuck a good balance between creatures having sensible resistances and immunities and not hosing whole classes. I'm disappointed they went back on nonmagical weapon resistance in 5.5, especially since it killed the primary feature of creatures like Werewolves.

So I would rather have extra fiddly rules used to make creatures unique and sensicle rather than everything being susceptible to everything to keep people from wasting their encounter power on a creature who resists or is immune to it.
 


Remove ads

Top