AI/LLMs Navier-Stokes "Solved" by AI

Sabine Hossenfelder took a look at this and said she'd leave it up to the trained mathematicians to decide if it's really "solved." She suspects that there's circular reasoning involved in OpenAI's proof. Have you made a professional judgment on it, or is
I'm not sure anyone here has made a professional judgement. The Clay Institute holds off on awarding the prizes for 2 years to give time for commentary for the community. It is often the case that very talented mathematicians claim a proof that turns out to be wrong. This has the benefit of a Lean formalization, which is quite strong but doesn't guarantee a lack of error.

That said, OpenAi has some incredibly talented mathematicians, and Anthropic does as well, and the people looking at this so far haven't afaik raised many doubts. So it seems solid from the outside.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Yup The Scandalous History of the Cubic Formula | Quanta Magazine and that's not even getting into the whole Calculus thing with Newton or Edison/Tesla and others. I guess when it's ONLY humans doing it to other humans it's okay.

I believe you have missed the point here by a fairly large margin.

It's NOT okay when humans do it to other humans.

Also, Newton and Leibniz was a case of parallel development. And Edison/Tesla was a business dispute; it was never an issue of proofs, math, or peer reviewed science. So those analogies only throw things further afield.
 

I believe you have missed the point here by a fairly large margin.

It's NOT okay when humans do it to other humans.

In fact, this case IS humans trying to do it to humans. The AI is not a willful actor here - a human told the AI to do it, so that the human could reap the financial rewards of the AI looking powerful.

Also, Newton and Leibniz was a case of parallel development.

Correct. My understanding is that there was no communication between Newton and Leibniz on calculus. And Newton actually did develop his first, by a decade and more (Newton's calculus was already circulating in 1668, Leibniz had his first breakthrough on the matter in 1675, and didn't publish his calculus until 1684).

It is just that we find Leibniz has much better notation.

So, this is nothing like anyone trying to scoop another's discovery, at all.
 

I believe you have missed the point here by a fairly large margin.

It's NOT okay when humans do it to other humans.

Also, Newton and Leibniz was a case of parallel development. And Edison/Tesla was a business dispute; it was never an issue of proofs, math, or peer reviewed science. So those analogies only throw things further afield.
so human theft is bad but adding AI makes it even worse?
 



so human theft is bad but adding AI makes it even worse?

Well, Newton/Leibnitz isn't even a case of human theft. It is merely parallel development in an age when such things communicated very slowly.

And, everyone knows Edison was a big honkin' greedy jerk. You keep asserting others are claiming this was "worse" (as if there's a known measurement of unethical behavior), but I don't see anyone other than you has made that assertion.

So, you know, maybe back off?
 


This misses the bigger scandal: OpenAI presumably private work from an academic to finish his work before he himself could, thus stealing the credit.

but I don't see anyone other than you has made that assertion.

So, you know, maybe back off?
See Justice using the word "stealing"

Now my using the Newton/Leibnitz and Edison were incorrect. But Justice did make the assertion that it was stealing and given that the topic is AI I think asking "why is this worse than humans stealing from other humans" is worth asking.
 

See Justice using the word "stealing"

Now my using the Newton/Leibnitz and Edison were incorrect. But Justice did make the assertion that it was stealing and given that the topic is AI I think asking "why is this worse than humans stealing from other humans" is worth asking.

Two things:

1) As already noted, this is still humans stealing from other humans - the AI didn't do this of its own accord - it was a tool for human ambition.

2) Justice DID NOT claim this was "worse" than other stealing. Just that it was an attempt to steal credit. The "worse" thing is all you.

Why are you asking people to justify statements that they didn't make?
 

Remove ads

Top