D&D 5E (2014) No backgrounds

I'm confused about this. Do you mean "all dwarves have +2 to Con" or "All dwarves have a 14 Con"? That feels like you are probably locking each race into a thin band of classes (dwarves are melee warriors, elves are mages, tieflings are charisma casters, etc).

I mean that all characters got the same six ability scores (not in order). I decided the scores starting from what you can get with point-buy, then adding +2/+1 as from a generic race in the most favorable way, then tipping up even a bit more. Once they choose a class, we put the scores to the abilities that mattered most. So no locking because in fact the ability bonuses did not depend on race.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

There's a "fast" version where you just say "I was a merchant before questing" (background as past) or "I am a merchant when not questing" (background as meanwhile) and the PHB gives you a small package of crunch to add to your character sheet. The package has occasional glitches such as redundant/overlapping proficiencies with class, you can ignore them if you don't mind or fix them on the ground that backgrounds are customisable anyway, it's just a bit less "fast".

Then there's the "slow" version of choosing all the traits and such, which is very rewarding when the players have all the time to explore the suggestions and make informed choices.

For me it’s the opposite… I usually come into the character building process knowing fairly precisely what I want as an end result, and so the fast path would be to craft a custom background that gives me exactly the ASIs, origin feat and skills I’m hoping for.

The slow path, on the other hand, is staring at an Excel sheet of the countless unsatisfactory backgrounds out there, and soul searching whether I prefer giving up the origin feat I wanted, or the ASI I wanted, etc.

Obviously, it’s clear that I should simply play with custom backgrounds, but unfortunately some DMs have somehow gotten into their minds that that is cheating or cheesy or min-maxing and that the clean way to play is with a vanilla background. Nowhere do the rules say that, but the DM still gets to decide what constraints they want for their campaign so here we are.
 

I mean that all characters got the same six ability scores (not in order). I decided the scores starting from what you can get with point-buy, then adding +2/+1 as from a generic race in the most favorable way, then tipping up even a bit more. Once they choose a class, we put the scores to the abilities that mattered most. So no locking because in fact the ability bonuses did not depend on race.
Ah. So, everyone got a (for example) 17, 15, 14, 13, 12, 10 but nothing modified those scores (race or background). Then they placed them wherever their class should as the best option.
 

I would have made up several pre gen characters using your modified rules. Let the new players each pick one. Then let the experienced players design theirs while you give a quick how to talk to the new folks. Strongly suggest that the experienced players design characters that complement the two picked by the new players. Avoid the 3 Fighters and a Monk party. If the game works well and folks want to round out the characters, let them choose a background that makes sense for the new world. So what that you are several sessions in? Maybe the world transition caused temporary amnesia and the characters now remember their backgrounds.
 

Remove ads

Top