D&D General Nonstandard Species: How Monstrous do they look in your game?

Tieflings, Aasimar and Genasi are all over the place, some appear very close to their main mortal lineage (remember they aren't necessarily part Human) but other resemble fiends/celestials/elementals a lot more. Subtler Tieflings don't necessarily have horns and tails, they might only have 1 of those or none, more monstrous Tieflings might have multiple tusks, spikes, scales and extra limbs. Aasimar might have small parts of their body that are radiant energy or animal-like features. Genasi might slightly warm fire, tree branches and pebbles, water/sludge, clouds of smoke as hair for example.
In Pathfinder 1st edition's Blood of Angels and Blood of Fiends, there were % tables for any player who wanted to customize their Aasimar or Tiefling character's looks and abilities.

Aasimar


Tiefling


PF1 also had alternate racial traits for their Planetouched that would allow them to appear more like their mortal lineage. Pass for Human for Tieflings, Scion of Humanity for Aasimar and Mostly Human for the Geniekin. These alternate racial traits replaced a trait that each of these races originally had, and they bestowed the character with two types- Humanoid and Outsider (Native). For 5e, this would be Humanoid plus Celestial, Fiend or Elemental.

5e really needs to bring back a more updated version of 2e's Complete books for its' species. 😛
 

log in or register to remove this ad


I use Tolkien plus some non-standard species.

Humans, Elves, Dwarves: pretty much like you'd expect.

Half-Elves: As D&D norms.

Goblins, Hobgoblins: Rock colored skin (roughly as varied in tone as real rocks), small horns like sheep horns, wiry coarse hair, large mouths, pointed predatory teeth (obligate carnivores). Goblins are small and usually hunched backed, hobgoblins tall and muscular. In terms of "comeliness" the racial write up suggests that most goblins find even themselves ugly, but that the most attractive goblins with symmetrical faces and more balanced proportions achieve a sort of noble barbaric splendor that some in the other races may find attractive. (Why goblins find themselves ugly is a campaign level secret, not known to most beings, including most goblins.)

Orine: Very attractive avian people, tall and muscular, quite human in appearance except for the eyes and feathers/down in place of hair. Humans, Elves, and Orine all find each other mutually attractive, but Orine can only procreate with their own race - leading to a lot of dalliances.

Idreth: Stooped back, thin, with long gray hair, and large noses, sometimes axe shaped and sometimes bulbous. Large feet and hands. Facial features inspired by the grain of a piece of wood on my closet door, vaguely resembling the Mystics from "The Dark Crystal". Body shaped like a hunched backed Marshwiggle from "The Silver Chair". Neither monstrous nor particularly attractive to other species, and in general they in turn do not find any other species either particular attractive or monstrous.

Sidhe, Pixie, Changling: Fairie races, closely related to each other. Widely varied in appearance, even within close lineages. There is virtually no "wrong" appearance a player could select for a Sidhe as long as they are roughly 3 feet high. A Sidhe that appeared like a halfling or gnome would be perfectly valid. Fairies with plant like, insect like, animal like, monstrous, sylvan or ethereal appearances would all be valid. Appearance often reflects alignment and personality and in NPC's spiritual/magical gifting. PC's can look however they like.

All other species are verboten as PC races, and in general most would never be seen in a civilized place. For one thing, they generally lack free will or varied alignment the way PC races do. All minotaurs are for example evil lesser avatars of a fiend lord, fully reflecting his sadistic brutal personality and continually craving the flesh of the innocent. All gnolls are similar. Nothing is just humans with bumps on their head, but in particular nothing that is not a PC race is remotely human in outlook at all. A nixie has vastly more in common with a human than any NPC monstrous race. Species absolutely determines your character outside of the above approved list.

In general, most of the above get along fine, but for real and valid historical and present reasons a lot of people deny that goblins are people. There are also a few societies that deny that fairies are people, and even the fairies themselves deny that the lesser fairies like sprites and atomies are people and are more akin to say cats. Cruelty to them is cruel, but on the other hand, too many feral cats can require action - what are you going to do? I should note that animals in my world are as intelligent as fairy tale animals, and that the world is very animistic. So yeah, if you want to eat a cow or a deer you have to had made peace with the idea you could have talked to that animal. See animistic cultural attitudes toward eating animals.

Technically, the "Giants" are varied enough and possess the freewill to be a PC race, and Hill Giants and Ogres even have mortal blood (effectively races of half-giants), but as they are generally too powerful to be PCs so they aren't allowed. The same is true of the genies (and gods!) from which giants are descended.

Sorcerers are a special case. Sorcerers in general are free peoples tainted or cursed with some association with a servitor race or some other monstrous thing. In most societies, sorcerers are treated therefore as being members of the monstrous race, and so sorcerers have to do their best to disguise or hide their magical abilities, pretend to be wizards, etc. They are not considered "people". Of course, individual attitudes can vary, and some societies are more open and cosmopolitan than others, but there are game mechanics that enforce "people really distrust you" if the sorcerer's supernatural powers are known. Think X-Men mutants.
 
Last edited:

One of my ideas with Goblins are that since they are Fey/Humanoid they're as varied in appearance as some Fey are, typical Goblins are trickster Fey that lean towards Unseelie court. But it's not a definite thing their court and Fey role, so their nature and appearance varies Goblin to Goblin. Could be a surprise to some if the Fey princess they meet, is a small rebellious green skin punk girl.

Hobgoblins might be less varied in appearances, in some ways closer to Humans and Orcs but skinnier than Orcs, slightly more feral with a variety of noses and teeth configurations, but mouth sizes are more within Human ranges. I guess you could think of them as between Orcs and Elves, though a Half-Orc Half-Elf doesn't necessarily look like a Hobgoblin. They are often orange or reddish in colour.

Bugbears are the most bestial of the Goblinoids, with some looking like a furry monster from some Children's book and others more like humanoids with some exaggerated features. Bugbears though vary a lot more in appearances than Hobgoblins do, some are really hairy with fur all over their bodies others have more hairless bodies. Noses with it's different shapes tend to be a different colour than the rest of their skin colour. Some Bugbears might be more Batlike in appearance and others have horns. Their teeth and tusks tend to be more prominent and they have wider mouths. Based on the fact they have reach as a PC ability, Bugbears do have longer arms and a more built-up upper body than most humanoids.
 

OK, typically in my homebrew, creation started with lots of begats. Prime and negative planes begat the elemental planes, they begat the quasi-elemental planes, etc until we have the world and its environs. When Chaos invade the plane, the Natural Order created the elves and dwarves to help combat it. The first born were the sun and moon elves which were literally the children of the daytime sky and forests and the nighttime sky and the forests respectively. The Sun Elves have yellow hair with pale to light blue skin. There is of course, the occasionally red head with redish skin. The Moon Elves have dark blue to black skin with similalry colored hair with occational amounts of pure white to go along with the phase of the moon. They also sometimes have multicolored freckles that resemble the display of stars in the night sky. (They would later become known as the Drow.) Similarly, other elves ar children of other animistic aspects of the world and resemble such as the dark brown skins and green hair of the wood elves. Dwarves are children of geographical features and the rock and thus have skin and hair in various shades of grey or red typically with cracking and chipping of the skin as they get older. Gnomes are more pastorial being children of the fields, lakes, and clearings rather than woods.

Next came the humanoids such as ogres and hobgoblins. Their skin is yellow ochre as that is the paint I decided to use to paint the figures.

Orcs, depending on the setting either are midpoint between the humanoids and human races, or their own separate thing that is the union of Choas and the elves. That brings them to darker colors to green as seems suitable.

Goblins are, of course, dark to bright green, because they are goblins and that's what the goblin players want.

Halflings and humans are humankind came last and vary in skin and hair color in degrees of tan depenant mainly on their latitude of habitation.

I said elves and dwarves were first, but actually kobolds which are the corrupted children of dragons and Chaos that range greatly in color and between the dragon like and dog like. They are a species older than the elves and there are cities deep in the earth left to prove it, but this knowledge is so old it is all but forgotten even by the elves.

Dragons are their own thing existed before the kobolds and are their own thing.

Teiflings have their generic look but technically are random and can appear however a PC wants for the most part.
 

Honestly, I can go either way. I'm a Furry, so I like me some standard nonhuman beastfolk design like lizardfolk, dragonborn, gnolls and tabaxi.

But I also see the appeal in versions that still look mostly humanoid, such as a dragonborn that looks like a human with small horns and patches of scale along their skin, or a tabaxi looking more like one of the Thundercats than like Puss in Boots.

I guess it depends on your setting. If it's something meant to look more like medieval Europe with the serial numbers filed off, make your nonhumans capable of hiding their monstrous features with a decent hood. If your world's taverns look like the fantasy version of the Mos Eisley Cantina, go ahead and go as wild as you want.
 

As a DM for PC's I will usually defer to the Player's image of their own character's race/species, especially if they want to play around with their physical appearance as a roleplay lever. Then I will usually go with how the species are presented in offical canon if we are playing in an established setting.

I prefer my DnD campaigns to feel very cosmopolitan in the make up of the fantasy races/species present as "People", I think roleplaying multicultural interactions is a key focus for my tables (while not shying away from the negative aspects that can occur, I also don't want to play Fantasy racism simulator 2000).

So I do think it's interesting when the more monstrous or bestial species feel different than just "Humans in Halloween costumes".
 

Orcs are Warcraft-y. That's how I came into things and has shaped my orc-opinions. Pig orcs do not look right, that's a pigman or piglin right there and we're probably in the Nether throwing gold at him to get ender pearls, that's not an orc.

Tabaxi are full on cat people. They're not the humans with cat ears, that's a whole other thing.
 

Honestly, it depends on what system and setting we're talking about. In my own game and setting,"Slightly larger than man sized, Orcs are green skinned humanoids with pig snouts and small horns." Very much cast in the mold of classic Tolkien orcs. But when I run, for example, D&D 5e (any setting) they are portrayed as much less bestial.
 

Are your orcs humanlike or pig-like, can your tieflings pass for humans or appear as full devilish looking beings? Do you have a set appearance or do you let players choose? Do you opt for exaggeration or aim for "human in cosplay makeup" appearances?
I let players choose. I run for a table who go back to first edition, and they prefer the more subtle appearances for tieflings (and aasimar), with just a few features that people might notice if they look closely but otherwise passing for human. I think the players like the idea of their characters being able to blend in and yet having a secret.
 
Last edited:

Remove ads

Top