D&D General Nonstandard Species: How Monstrous do they look in your game?

No. I can't think of any direct connections there. I would say that I think whomever insists Dragonborn need human female secondary sexual characteristics probably has a severe lack of empathy, or at the very least that person assumes that people playing Dragonborn have a severe lack of empathy/imagination and need familiar sexual dimorphism before they are comfortable. But that's about creating content and not about consuming it. The creator may very well be correct about what it requires to motivate someone to want to play say a Dragonborn, in which case that's high empathy (properly predicting another minds emotions and reasoning whether conscious or unconcious). But about consuming Dragonborn I could imagine that there are a lot of motives for that, and no direct mapping function of empathy to wanting to play Dragonborn.

Are you trying to say that reptilian species have a severe lack of empathy, and therefore anyone who wants to play them wants to do so because of their own severe lack of empathy? Or are you saying that you think that is what I would assume. Because I don't think you could assume reptilian species have a severe lack of empathy, unless you make some other assumptions about that species.

Honestly, I'm struggling to understand the motives of your question. You clearly think it's some sort of revealing gotcha, but I'm not sure why.
No. I was trying not to leap to a conclusion.

Because everything you wrote before read, to me, as fairly shouting, "People who prefer to play noticeably different-from-human species have a critical pack of empathy, presuming everyone else is just a carbon copy of themselves." In other words, it sounded incredibly insulting and uncivil, to the point of feeling like fighting words. I endeavored to follow the other user's example, because their own effort helped me see that I was taking statements at face value that could be off-the-cuff or viewed from a perspective I had not considered.

However, your continued examples still give me significant concern. Your use of dragonborn having secondary sexual characteristics associated with mammals, for example. Have you considered that there could be aspects you have overlooked where empathy is concerned? I have, personally, known multiple female players who were varying degrees of pleased that dragonborn women brought wonderful things to the table. Warrior women whose warrior nature will not be questioned simply because they are female. Recognizing the presence and beauty of broad, tall, stout ladies, without any hint of fat-shaming or derogative presentation. Feeling seen and recognized as women even while having significant differences relative to "traditional" femininity and feminine beauty. Orcs, goliaths, and dwarves also allow shades of this, but for some reason dragonborn had that extra kick that really worked for some women I've known. Certainly not all! But enough to be noteworthy.

By and large, I have found that the people most upset by dragonborn breasts are men, not women. That, to me, looks like an actual failure of empathy, not for fictitious beings described in a book, but the real flesh-and-blood humans who share our tables.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

I would broadly agree that empathy for the real humans at the table is more important than empathy for fictional beings of fictional species which consist of stat blocks, flavor blurbs, and inconsistent art.
 

For me, it depends. For instance, tieflings and genasi can run the gamut from human-passing to monstrous. But species like kenku, dragonborn, tortles, etc. look more monstrous.
 



For me, it depends. For instance, tieflings and genasi can run the gamut from human-passing to monstrous. But species like kenku, dragonborn, tortles, etc. look more monstrous.
I've usually been in this camp, but it's occurred to me that some players may see that different. Especially when players are influenced by different media. You tell a player that a harengon is a bunny person, one player might see this:

: Harengon.webp
And another this:
FFXII-VieraCG_render.webp

That can it hard to describe them properly in the game..
 

I would broadly agree that empathy for the real humans at the table is more important than empathy for fictional beings of fictional species which consist of stat blocks, flavor blurbs, and inconsistent art.
In fairness to other perspectives, there is a tendency to flatten non-human people into "just human with rubber foreheads" (a zillion Star Trek species) or "just human with One Weird Quirk" (Vulcans started here, but eventually got better) or "technically super not human, but it never comes up" (elves are here, but so are things like Andorians). That can be quite disappointing, and can reflect a cavalier attitude about characterization, authenticity, and groundedness. All of which are to say: I can understand why another would feel really not great about having a sense that a player acts like their dragonborn or thri-kreen or aarakockra is indistinguishable from a human except in the few, rare moments where it isn't.

The bigger issue, of course, is that there is a difference between "flattening this sucks, and that happens too often", and "almost nobody actually does it well, so we just shouldn't."
 

I've usually been in this camp, but it's occurred to me that some players may see that different. Especially when players are influenced by different media. You tell a player that a harengon is a bunny person, one player might see this:

:View attachment 447759
And another this:
View attachment 447760

That can it hard to describe them properly in the game..

Do we need to describe them?

If you just say there is a bunnyfolk people know what there is and they can imagine it different. There is no need for people to imagine it the same.


Daggerheart even has for the images of races kind of both the above pictures.

When a player plays it they can describe themselves.


But I dont see any gain of a GM doing detailed description of how people look. Just takes time for unimportant details.
 

Yeah I didn't want that to reflect on how the species is viewed in game, but how the players perceive (or DM describes) them.
A person who is role-playing a Dragonborn has to look at their character as something normal and at members of a different species as something different. The OP used the words in game in the title of their thread, that means that the player has to be in character.

How does a player view their character from an in-game point of view?

I am role-playing a Dragonborn. I am from a species that is taller than most humans within the setting. I am covered in scales that might be chromatic, metallic or gem-like in color. I have a tail and my head is adorned with horns and crests of varying sizes. I can make my breath into something destructive. To other Dragonborn, I might be considered plain or particularly handsome. I would also know that I was born in the image of a Dragon.

Would I be aware of how members of other species might view me? That's what Insight checks are for. ;)
 

A person who is role-playing a Dragonborn has to look at their character as something normal and at members of a different species as something different. The OP used the words in game in the title of their thread, that means that the player has to be in character.

How does a player view their character from an in-game point of view?

I am role-playing a Dragonborn. I am from a species that is taller than most humans within the setting. I am covered in scales that might be chromatic, metallic or gem-like in color. I have a tail and my head is adorned with horns and crests of varying sizes. I can make my breath into something destructive. To other Dragonborn, I might be considered plain or particularly handsome. I would also know that I was born in the image of a Dragon.

Would I be aware of how members of other species might view me? That's what Insight checks are for. ;)
Not sure if I just wasn't paying attention or if it's actually new, but hey, great new profile pic!
 

Remove ads

Top