OSR IS LYING TO YOU! A reasonable discussion about OSR

Unless the party is the size of a village with feet, a typical module will give each character more than enough money to train*, assuming they sell off some (or all) of the magic items they don't need and maybe make a few hard choices about ones they do need. If they only divide the non-magic loot, though, they're gonna come up short.

* - even more so if you're not giving xp for treasure; in which case it might take them a couple of adventures to bump and they'll consequently have loads of wealth.
This is one reason I love XP for gold spent. As long as it’s not spent on stuff that’s a mechanical benefit. You get XP for spending gold on training, but not buying a new weapon or piece of armor.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

In-fiction premise and rationale: a specific item - very useful but also kinda cursed - in the lowest level would, if left alone for a week (and it had been there for centuries), summon a completely random monster (or small group of monsters) to an unoccupied room in the building or complex it was in (in this case, a dungeon) and there put it in stasis until something either disturbed it or shone a light on it, on which the stasis would end and the very annoyed monster would almost certainly attack. When every room in the dungeon had an occupant, the summoning ceased until-unless one or more rooms was empty, at which point it would restart.
The Forgotten Realms has Deepspawn that serve a similar purpose.
 

This is one reason I love XP for gold spent. As long as it’s not spent on stuff that’s a mechanical benefit. You get XP for spending gold on training, but not buying a new weapon or piece of armor.
Kind of a sibling of the systems that give you xp or plot points or whatever when a disadvantage is actually a burden. I like the principle.
 

This is one reason I love XP for gold spent. As long as it’s not spent on stuff that’s a mechanical benefit. You get XP for spending gold on training, but not buying a new weapon or piece of armor.
That could and would quickly lead to a bizarre and rather frustrating spiral, where you spend gold to train and by so doing get enough xp to need to train again, but you can't because now you're out of gold......

The DM I play with introduced a variant on this into his game where if you spend gold on public works (buildings, art, fountains, etc.) you can get xp for doing so on something like a 1 xp per 3 gp basis; and I gotta say, I'm not a fan. It takes xp, which IMO should be a somewhat direct reflection of the character's in-fiction growth and learning, and turns them into something of a reverse metacurrency where you can buy them but not spend them.
 

That could and would quickly lead to a bizarre and rather frustrating spiral, where you spend gold to train and by so doing get enough xp to need to train again, but you can't because now you're out of gold......

The DM I play with introduced a variant on this into his game where if you spend gold on public works (buildings, art, fountains, etc.) you can get xp for doing so on something like a 1 xp per 3 gp basis; and I gotta say, I'm not a fan. It takes xp, which IMO should be a somewhat direct reflection of the character's in-fiction growth and learning, and turns them into something of a reverse metacurrency where you can buy them but not spend them.
Ah. No, sorry. In that setup, mechanically, you get the XP from spending the gold to train, not the actual training. In use this leads to broader worldbuilding from the players. They train, carouse, tithe, bribe, build shrines, etc. All of it gets them XP. They just flavor it how they want as befits their character.
 

Ah. No, sorry. In that setup, mechanically, you get the XP from spending the gold to train, not the actual training.
Yes. If I've levelled up and then spend 2000 gold on training, that gets me 2000 xp - which is enough to bump me yet again, but now I've no gold left to spend on the next round of training I suddenly find I need....
In use this leads to broader worldbuilding from the players. They train, carouse, tithe, bribe, build shrines, etc. All of it gets them XP. They just flavor it how they want as befits their character.
I get this idea and have seen it proposed elsewhere. It's far from the worst idea I've seen for how to earn xp, but I'm personally more a fan of xp being something earned in the field adventuring.
 

Yes. If I've levelled up and then spend 2000 gold on training, that gets me 2000 xp - which is enough to bump me yet again, but now I've no gold left to spend on the next round of training I suddenly find I need....
No. You’re double dipping. You spend 2000 gold to get that 2000 XP. You’re just calling it training. The training doesn’t then give you 2000 more XP. This replaces the AD&D training to level mechanic, it doesn't add to it.
I get this idea and have seen it proposed elsewhere. It's far from the worst idea I've seen for how to earn xp, but I'm personally more a fan of xp being something earned in the field adventuring.
To each their own. I prefer the worldbuilding that comes from XP for gold spent.
 


No. You’re double dipping. You spend 2000 gold to get that 2000 XP. You’re just calling it training. The training doesn’t then give you 2000 more XP. This replaces the AD&D training to level mechanic, it doesn't add to it.
So spending gold for training is the only way to gain xp?

I get that the training itself doesn't give me any xp but the gold I spend to get it does. I assume I can't train until I've already got enough xp to have gained a level. So my half-facetious, half-real issue is this sequence: (assume the bump points are 2K, 4K, 8K...)

Step 1 - I've by whatever means earned 2000 xp or more, and now need to train to 2nd level
Step 2 - I spend 2500 gold to train to 2nd level and by so doing gain 2500 xp; this leaves me short of cash
Step 3 - that 2500 xp I just got means I now have 4500 xp, yay me: now I've bumped to 3rd level
Step 4 - I can't train to 3rd because I've run myself out of gold.
To each their own. I prefer the worldbuilding that comes from XP for gold spent.
I'm good with anything that encourages interaction with the setting beyond the bare-bones basics required for adventuring. This does so, only in a way that turns xp into something I'd prefer they not become.
 

So spending gold for training is the only way to gain xp?

I get that the training itself doesn't give me any xp but the gold I spend to get it does. I assume I can't train until I've already got enough xp to have gained a level. So my half-facetious, half-real issue is this sequence: (assume the bump points are 2K, 4K, 8K...)

Step 1 - I've by whatever means earned 2000 xp or more, and now need to train to 2nd level
Step 2 - I spend 2500 gold to train to 2nd level and by so doing gain 2500 xp; this leaves me short of cash
Step 3 - that 2500 xp I just got means I now have 4500 xp, yay me: now I've bumped to 3rd level
Step 4 - I can't train to 3rd because I've run myself out of gold.

I'm good with anything that encourages interaction with the setting beyond the bare-bones basics required for adventuring. This does so, only in a way that turns xp into something I'd prefer they not become.
You don't get the gold for spending it, only acquring it, in OD&D and AD&D RAW.
 
Last edited:

Remove ads

Top