OSR IS LYING TO YOU! A reasonable discussion about OSR


log in or register to remove this ad

Did you see groups that large in reality, though?
I saw that a bit in the early years of playing, yes. But that petered out really quickly. We regularly had 6-7 players plus some hirelings. I know we used hirelings as replacement characters a lot. I wouldn’t mind using hirelings as extra lives for PCs. Fail a save vs death and scratch one hireling for games where the players are really attached to their characters.
 


I don't think I ever played in a game with more than five players.
I've only done it a couple times in 45 years. Granted, largely because in the 80s I never knew that many gamers in one place to even make it a possibility. Later, it quickly became unmanageable to have more than a half dozen or so players. It just took to long to get round the table and too much time between turns. People got bored waiting.
 



And do you try to "balance for 5", or just run what you want to run. I do the latter - and it's always a mix of levels, too.
My group talked about it, and there was some fairly strong opposition to having uneven levels. I'd have preferred to run things differently, but I balance for a party of six now.
 
Last edited:

In BG3, I did want to bring the whole party, but I haven’t done that mod (yet?).
Also, this mod -- and the one that makes them more chatty than they would be otherwise -- is 100% worth it, if you're not the kind of person intending to replay a 50-hour videogame, but just want to get the full Critical Role experience of having a dozen characters joking and sniping and flirting all up front.
 

I don't think I ever played in a game with more than five players.
I've run a few games that way -- it turns out that the Radiant Citadel's faux Mexico and faux India settings bring all of the more casual players back to play -- and it definitely works, although I'm exhausted at the end. And, to make fights even remotely interesting, I need to play the NPCs like military masterminds, otherwise they get action ecomonied into red smears almost immediately.
 

And, to make fights even remotely interesting, I need to play the NPCs like military masterminds, otherwise they get action ecomonied into red smears almost immediately.
That's why I reworked the MM on a Business Card math to make things more flexible. Swapping monster attacks to # of PCs really helps. You have to fiddle with the damage a bit to not wipe the party. But it helped a lot.
 

Remove ads

Top