Mannahnin
Scion of Murgen (He/Him)
They have always been pulpy action-adventure heroes. From the moment Dave Arneson gave them hit points. Conan and Fafhrd and the Grey Mouser were pulpy action adventure heroes. "zero to hero" has been a colloquial expression for a long time, but D&D characters, despite their fragility at 1st level, were never intended to start out as zeroes. Since 1974 a 1st level Fighter has been a Veteran, with more HP than an ordinary man, befitting his superior skills at the start of play.Joking comments or not, D&D characters are, especially in recent editions, at minimum pulpy action-adventure heroes, the literal precursors to superheroes. The old notion of zero-to-hero died somewhere along the way. Modern editions start at hero and scale up to saviors of the multiverse. To refuse to acknowledge that’s some superhero levels of awesome is to kinda miss the point.
And AD&D characters, since at least 1979, were always intended to scale up to Planes-Hopping Worlds Saviors at higher levels, to every bit the same extent that 5E ones are. AD&D makes clear that the endgames are A) Domain management and Great Kingdom-style wargaming (which almost no one was interested in), or B ) Divine Champions on the Chessboard of the Gods.
It doesn't look like a "superhero progression". Superheroes rarely progress from tier to tier. Those power tiers normally define a superhero for all or most of its career unless a writer decides to revamp the heck out of them for some reason. Daredevil doesn't progress over his lifetime to Spider Man power level and then to Thor power level.In the 2024 PHB, on page 43, the tiers of play are described as follows. Tier 1: “Characters are apprentice adventurers, though they are already set apart from the broader populace by virtue of their extraordinary abilities.” Tier 2: “The characters now face dangers that threaten cities and kingdoms.” Tier 3: “characters have reached a level of power that makes them special among adventurers… These adventurers often confront threats to whole regions.” Tier 4: “The fate of the world or even the order of the multiverse hang in the balance during their adventures.”
That looks an awful lot like a superhero progression. Sidekicks or street-level superheroes, classic city-based superheroes, globe-trotting superheroes, and cosmic superheroes.
D&D characters are defined in large part by their progression, and that's a major contrast between them and superheroes.
If we want to dig into specific definitions of what is or is not a superhero, we could. But that seems pointless as any criteria will be riddled with exceptions. The best one I’ve come across that is more involved than “I know it when I see it,” is from Peter Coogan’s book Superhero: The Secret Origin of a Genre. His schema is simple enough: Mission, Powers, and Identity. I think it was mentioned in a recently linked blog.
They’re all fairly clear. Mission means have some overarching, usually unachievable, do-gooder goal. Powers means having abilities that set you apart from ordinary people. And Identity means some kind of secret ID, costume, etc. If you’re a fan of superheroes at all, you should have about a dozen characters in mind that are exceptions to each of those. Hulk has no mission to speak of. Batman has no powers, unless you count white privilege and being a billionaire. The Fantastic Four have no secret identities, though they do have costumes. Etc.
So would 5E PCs fit into those categories? Most of them quite easily.
Mission? Are you playing in an official AP? You’ve got a do-gooder mission. Does your character have an overarching goal like saving a prince or a kingdom? You’ve got a do-gooder mission. While most if not all old-school PCs are more greedy and self-serving, many or most modern PCs are far more explicitly heroic as in wandering do-gooders.
Powers? Absolutely. You’ve got a laundry list of powers, skills, and abilities that ordinary people will never get. Even tier 1 PCs are explicitly called out as having extraordinary abilities that set them apart, and their character sheets prove it. One of the most striking powers that every PC gets is nearly 100% regeneration after 8-hours’ sleep. Though PCs powers obviously are not on the scale of most classic superheroes. But if your baseline for what counts as a superpower is Superman lifting a 747, you're clearly begging the question.
Identity? Not really, no. 5E PCs don’t broadly have secret IDs or go around in spandex with logos on their chests. Some groups make a big deal about shopping and clothes, but that’s not really the same thing. Striking outfits, sure. To the level of a typical superhero costume, clearly not.
D&D characters are not defined by a singular, usually unachievable life's mission like Coogan is talking about. On the contrary, D&D characters almost definitionally go on many missions/quests, and these quests by and large are discrete and achievable. D&D characters with a superhero-style overarching mission "to rid the world of evil" or similar are exceptions rather than the rule, often falling specifically into a paladin-type role.
Powers, sure, all magical characters have some powers. But again, the progression of them sets them in distinct contrast to superheroes. Superheroes are normally defined by a set, distinct suite of thematic abilities, which (Marvel Superheroes-style Power Stunts aside) rarely get added to. The powers of D&D characters also normally have very different thematic limitations and scope. Calling out recovery of HP overnight as "regeneration" is- man. I don't want to call it bad faith, but I KNOW you know better than this. Jason Bourne is not Wolverine. And a D&D character recovering HP has always been intended to be more akin to Jason Bourne. You know as well as I do that they're not Meat Points.
Identity as you note is clearly at odds.
All superhero origin stories are fictional character backgrounds. IME a very small percentage of fictional character backgrounds are superhero origin stories.The Origin Story. And this the vast majority of 5E PCs have in spades. An over-long and often over-dramatic tragic origin story. You could easily swap in Spider-Man’s or the Punisher’s origin for a 5E character and no one would bat an eye. You might need to change a few details, but most superhero origins wouldn’t be out of place. "My entire family was wiped out by [something], so here I am seeking revenge." It happens to be the Punisher's origin story but also about 1/2 of the 5E PCs I've had at my table. "I could have used my power for good, but didn't and someone close to me died as a result." It happens to be Spider-Man's origin story but also featured in quite a few of the 5E PCs at my table.
I don't think I've ever seen someone do a Spider-Man. "The vast majority of 5E PCs"? Dude, wat?
It leaves us usually at 0/4 in my experience, for D&D characters. 1/4 for some. 2/4 rarely.So where’s that leave us with 5E PCs and the superhero criteria Coogan put forth but expanded to include Origin? Mission. Many if not most. Powers. Yes, all of them. Though early tiers are closer to sidekicks and street-level superheroes. Identity. Almost none. Origin. Many if not most. So, yeah. Many if not most 5E PCs fit 3/4 of the criteria for being superheroes.
How accurate this is depends on your table. At my table? Yeah, 100% of the 5E players I ran for were playing fantasy superheroes while I was trying to run something far more grounded. I've posted several times about the player who rage-quit because the Mold Earth cantrip didn't make him a master Earth-bender. If you don't see this kind of thing at your table, you should feel lucky. But don't tell other people their experiences aren't actually happening.
I'm not telling you that your experiences aren't happening. Howzabout you stop telling me that your terrible experiences are representative of the world in general? Because they're certainly not representative of my play groups, or those of most of the people on here.
Last edited:






