OSR IS LYING TO YOU! A reasonable discussion about OSR

Joking comments or not, D&D characters are, especially in recent editions, at minimum pulpy action-adventure heroes, the literal precursors to superheroes. The old notion of zero-to-hero died somewhere along the way. Modern editions start at hero and scale up to saviors of the multiverse. To refuse to acknowledge that’s some superhero levels of awesome is to kinda miss the point.
They have always been pulpy action-adventure heroes. From the moment Dave Arneson gave them hit points. Conan and Fafhrd and the Grey Mouser were pulpy action adventure heroes. "zero to hero" has been a colloquial expression for a long time, but D&D characters, despite their fragility at 1st level, were never intended to start out as zeroes. Since 1974 a 1st level Fighter has been a Veteran, with more HP than an ordinary man, befitting his superior skills at the start of play.

And AD&D characters, since at least 1979, were always intended to scale up to Planes-Hopping Worlds Saviors at higher levels, to every bit the same extent that 5E ones are. AD&D makes clear that the endgames are A) Domain management and Great Kingdom-style wargaming (which almost no one was interested in), or B ) Divine Champions on the Chessboard of the Gods.


In the 2024 PHB, on page 43, the tiers of play are described as follows. Tier 1: “Characters are apprentice adventurers, though they are already set apart from the broader populace by virtue of their extraordinary abilities.” Tier 2: “The characters now face dangers that threaten cities and kingdoms.” Tier 3: “characters have reached a level of power that makes them special among adventurers… These adventurers often confront threats to whole regions.” Tier 4: “The fate of the world or even the order of the multiverse hang in the balance during their adventures.”

That looks an awful lot like a superhero progression. Sidekicks or street-level superheroes, classic city-based superheroes, globe-trotting superheroes, and cosmic superheroes.
It doesn't look like a "superhero progression". Superheroes rarely progress from tier to tier. Those power tiers normally define a superhero for all or most of its career unless a writer decides to revamp the heck out of them for some reason. Daredevil doesn't progress over his lifetime to Spider Man power level and then to Thor power level.

D&D characters are defined in large part by their progression, and that's a major contrast between them and superheroes.

If we want to dig into specific definitions of what is or is not a superhero, we could. But that seems pointless as any criteria will be riddled with exceptions. The best one I’ve come across that is more involved than “I know it when I see it,” is from Peter Coogan’s book Superhero: The Secret Origin of a Genre. His schema is simple enough: Mission, Powers, and Identity. I think it was mentioned in a recently linked blog.

They’re all fairly clear. Mission means have some overarching, usually unachievable, do-gooder goal. Powers means having abilities that set you apart from ordinary people. And Identity means some kind of secret ID, costume, etc. If you’re a fan of superheroes at all, you should have about a dozen characters in mind that are exceptions to each of those. Hulk has no mission to speak of. Batman has no powers, unless you count white privilege and being a billionaire. The Fantastic Four have no secret identities, though they do have costumes. Etc.

So would 5E PCs fit into those categories? Most of them quite easily.

Mission? Are you playing in an official AP? You’ve got a do-gooder mission. Does your character have an overarching goal like saving a prince or a kingdom? You’ve got a do-gooder mission. While most if not all old-school PCs are more greedy and self-serving, many or most modern PCs are far more explicitly heroic as in wandering do-gooders.

Powers? Absolutely. You’ve got a laundry list of powers, skills, and abilities that ordinary people will never get. Even tier 1 PCs are explicitly called out as having extraordinary abilities that set them apart, and their character sheets prove it. One of the most striking powers that every PC gets is nearly 100% regeneration after 8-hours’ sleep. Though PCs powers obviously are not on the scale of most classic superheroes. But if your baseline for what counts as a superpower is Superman lifting a 747, you're clearly begging the question.

Identity? Not really, no. 5E PCs don’t broadly have secret IDs or go around in spandex with logos on their chests. Some groups make a big deal about shopping and clothes, but that’s not really the same thing. Striking outfits, sure. To the level of a typical superhero costume, clearly not.

D&D characters are not defined by a singular, usually unachievable life's mission like Coogan is talking about. On the contrary, D&D characters almost definitionally go on many missions/quests, and these quests by and large are discrete and achievable. D&D characters with a superhero-style overarching mission "to rid the world of evil" or similar are exceptions rather than the rule, often falling specifically into a paladin-type role.

Powers, sure, all magical characters have some powers. But again, the progression of them sets them in distinct contrast to superheroes. Superheroes are normally defined by a set, distinct suite of thematic abilities, which (Marvel Superheroes-style Power Stunts aside) rarely get added to. The powers of D&D characters also normally have very different thematic limitations and scope. Calling out recovery of HP overnight as "regeneration" is- man. I don't want to call it bad faith, but I KNOW you know better than this. Jason Bourne is not Wolverine. And a D&D character recovering HP has always been intended to be more akin to Jason Bourne. You know as well as I do that they're not Meat Points.

Identity as you note is clearly at odds.

The Origin Story. And this the vast majority of 5E PCs have in spades. An over-long and often over-dramatic tragic origin story. You could easily swap in Spider-Man’s or the Punisher’s origin for a 5E character and no one would bat an eye. You might need to change a few details, but most superhero origins wouldn’t be out of place. "My entire family was wiped out by [something], so here I am seeking revenge." It happens to be the Punisher's origin story but also about 1/2 of the 5E PCs I've had at my table. "I could have used my power for good, but didn't and someone close to me died as a result." It happens to be Spider-Man's origin story but also featured in quite a few of the 5E PCs at my table.
All superhero origin stories are fictional character backgrounds. IME a very small percentage of fictional character backgrounds are superhero origin stories.

I don't think I've ever seen someone do a Spider-Man. "The vast majority of 5E PCs"? Dude, wat?

So where’s that leave us with 5E PCs and the superhero criteria Coogan put forth but expanded to include Origin? Mission. Many if not most. Powers. Yes, all of them. Though early tiers are closer to sidekicks and street-level superheroes. Identity. Almost none. Origin. Many if not most. So, yeah. Many if not most 5E PCs fit 3/4 of the criteria for being superheroes.
It leaves us usually at 0/4 in my experience, for D&D characters. 1/4 for some. 2/4 rarely.

How accurate this is depends on your table. At my table? Yeah, 100% of the 5E players I ran for were playing fantasy superheroes while I was trying to run something far more grounded. I've posted several times about the player who rage-quit because the Mold Earth cantrip didn't make him a master Earth-bender. If you don't see this kind of thing at your table, you should feel lucky. But don't tell other people their experiences aren't actually happening.

I'm not telling you that your experiences aren't happening. Howzabout you stop telling me that your terrible experiences are representative of the world in general? Because they're certainly not representative of my play groups, or those of most of the people on here. 🤷‍♂️
 
Last edited:

log in or register to remove this ad

Not to mention all the hirelings and henchmen everyone was supposed to be bringing along. So instead of a four-person party, you might have 20 characters, PC and NPC, exploring the dungeon together.

Did you see groups that large in reality, though?

Anyhow, my two 3.5e games have, respectively, 8 characters and 9 characters. They’re over email, so it’s mostly manageable. Part of the issue is adopting NPCs and in each campaign, one player has two characters. So the total number of players is 5 in each.

In BG3, I did want to bring the whole party, but I haven’t done that mod (yet?).
I have played in OD&D groups where we had anywhere from 6-10 players routinely, and most of the characters would bring at least one hirelings or henchman as a matter of course (plus sometimes a torchbearer and/or muleskinner hired by the party as a whole). So we'd usually go into Castle Greyhawk or other situations with 10+, sometimes 15+, characters.

We know that D&D tournaments in the '70s routinely were cramming 8-12 players at tables, so a lot of D&D's early modules were written to support that. That being said, we also see B2 and other modules starting around 1980 written with an awareness that groups might be as small as 3-4 and need NPC reinforcements.

I've played with as many as seven or eight players in 3E and 5E and IME it gets super unwieldy and slow. The simpler combat rules and fewer options of early TSR editions* support use of hireling reinforcements or even multiple characters per PC better, as their greater lethality makes use of those hirelings to bolter your numbers and provide meatshields more desireable.

*(AD&D something of an exception, but in practice most folks simplified it, and the folks who didn't simplify it practiced like hell to make it run faster)
 
Last edited:

In college, if everyone showed up, we would have 12 people. That was pretty rare though. Even when there weren't that many people around, there were groups that would play multiple characters at once. We did that in first edition because we thought we were supposed to. The way the modules were described and the large party of pregens that many modules included made us think it was a requirement. It didn't bother us though. We could have the information for 10 characters on one side of a single sheet of paper. Instead of each person having a character sheet everyone had the full party sheet. If someone didn't show up, someone else would control them (we did start using the other side for spellbooks and treasure). With far fewer modifiers and very few things like feats, it was easy to control multiple characters - the detail level of the game was small enough that analysis paralysis never really happened.
 

One other thing of note was that spellcasting in AD&D was MUCH more impactful than in 5e, comparatively speaking. 5e has multiple saving throws even if you fail the first, and they are much easier to pass than in 1e. Your magic in 1e was almost guaranteed to affect the bad guy, and if they failed, they were done for the duration. Not just one round and try again (let alone legendary actions). A 9th level MU casting a 9d6 fireball/lightning bolt in 1e was about twice as effective as a 9th level Wizard casting fireball in 5e because of HP inflation. Magic in 1e was much more "superhero" than it is in 5e.
Casting, however, was also much easier to interrupt; and every spell was valuable 'cause you didn't have all that many of 'em per day.

So sure, spells provided great bang for the buck but only a) if you could get them away and b) if you had any left. High risk, high reward. Love it!
 

Casting, however, was also much easier to interrupt; and every spell was valuable 'cause you didn't have all that many of 'em per day.

So sure, spells provided great bang for the buck but only a) if you could get them away and b) if you had any left. High risk, high reward. Love it!
Plus you're not guaranteed any specific spells. Rolling to learn whatever spell you found, based on whatever spells the referee allowed in the game. Some of the magic was more impactful, yes. But it cut both ways. The polymorph you were so happy to cast on the monsters could be cast on you. Etc.
 

Did you see groups that large in reality, though?
Our average party size including adventuring NPCs is between 7-10. In my game: four players, each typically running one or two PCs, plus there's an NPC or two. In the games I play in, five or six players with one PC each, plus NPCs and henches.
Anyhow, my two 3.5e games have, respectively, 8 characters and 9 characters. They’re over email, so it’s mostly manageable. Part of the issue is adopting NPCs and in each campaign, one player has two characters. So the total number of players is 5 in each.
In the 3e game I was in our party was also around 7-9 characters on average; over time we ranged from 4 to 6 players, usually 5.
 

Also, this mod -- and the one that makes them more chatty than they would be otherwise -- is 100% worth it, if you're not the kind of person intending to replay a 50-hour videogame, but just want to get the full Critical Role experience of having a dozen characters joking and sniping and flirting all up front.
I’m the kind of player with 200+ hours in, to a single run, and stuck in Act 3 by indecision and decreased interest.
 
Last edited:


Casting, however, was also much easier to interrupt; and every spell was valuable 'cause you didn't have all that many of 'em per day.

So sure, spells provided great bang for the buck but only a) if you could get them away and b) if you had any left. High risk, high reward. Love it!

Plus you're not guaranteed any specific spells. Rolling to learn whatever spell you found, based on whatever spells the referee allowed in the game. Some of the magic was more impactful, yes. But it cut both ways. The polymorph you were so happy to cast on the monsters could be cast on you. Etc.
Sure, spell interruption was a thing, but I never played in a game where the MU didn't have magic missile, fireball, lightning bolt, or some other similar spell. And clerics didn't have to roll--they just got the spell they wanted, like chain lightning or hold person.

  • In AD&D, you cast charm person, they fail their save (likely because saves were much harder in AD&D), and you basically have a best-friend henchman for a week or a month before they can attempt another save, let alone be freed.
  • Damage is roughly doubled vs. 5e when you compare HP averages of PCs and monsters. That 3rd-level druid casting call lightning is doing 3d8 HP in a 10-ft radius each round for 3 rounds. Nothing in 5e has a 3rd-level PC doing 6d8 damage in a 10-ft radius each round for 3 rounds (again, most saves are failed in AD&D). Sure, it has to be outside, but plenty of encounters happen outside.
  • A 9th-level MU is casting 5 magic missiles with a 1st-level slot. That's 5d4+5 auto damage (again, roughly 10d4+10 damage comparatively for 5e's HP). Can a 9th-level Wizard in 5e cast 10d4+10 auto-hit damage with a 1st-level slot? You get the point.
  • High-level casters in AD&D had several more spell slots than the 5e caster, especially high-level spells.
  • It's not just damage--many spells like charm person, hold person, finger of death, confusion, entangle, feeblemind, etc. are much easier to affect the target because of how saves work, and they last a long time (some permanent!), not a new save each round.

In fact, I'd say looking at how saving throws work alone makes AD&D casters more of a superhero than a 5e caster. Then when you factor in damage as a ratio to average HP, it's just icing on the cake. And I didn't even mention scrolls or magic items ;) Spell interruptions are a thing, sure, but they've been pretty rare in the 45 years I have continuously played AD&D. Players learn quickly and make sure they have the best chance.

TL;DR version, when I hear people say modern editions feel too superhero and not like old school, I disagree with that because in many ways, the 1e character was more of superhero than the 5e counterpart in the context of how they compared in each edition, especially casters.
 

TL;DR version, when I hear people say modern editions feel too superhero and not like old school, I disagree with that because in many ways, the 1e character was more of superhero than the 5e counterpart in the context of how they compared in each edition, especially casters.

Again, I have to push back on you a little. Not because you are wrong in what you are feeling, but because I do not think you are trying to take into account the reason why other people feel this way!

Let's start with something I think needs to be acknowledged- I don't think this discussion (or argument for most people) is really about the facts. I think that people feel a certain way about games and play styles and they are looking for a way to describe those feelings. Fair?

From there, I can also confidently state that, for many people, "superhero" has certain associations. I know that there are a few posters here who actually like the term and employ it to defend their love of 5e- in fact, they will argue that 5e should be MORE superhero, MORE anime, and MORE wuxia. There is one person in particular I am thinking of, and I would at them if I could remember their user name. I blame the gin.

But ... I think a lot of people view it as a pejorative instead of a term of differentiation or to explain "the feels" of a game. So we don't get discussions that produce a lot of light, but instead heat, as people who primarily play 5e argue that it isn't that superhero-y, and instead, older games were so so sudio ... um, suerhero-y. Whereas the other side will say that every old school player died before second level and all 5e players are just souped-up versions of the Avengers.

Then we can add in how people will inevitably talk about "how they played," or "what they saw," .... which, again, is pretty meaningless given that this whole discussion starts from people trying to identify their own feels about one game and play style as opposed to another.

So why is this so complicated? Because this is the internet, and we can't compare, I guess? Something has to be better, and something worse. We can't just say, "Sometimes I like have more high-powered characters, and sometimes I don't."

Personally, I get the feels behind the superhero comment. It's an imperfect way of discussing the difference. If you look at your comments, you will see that you're always talking about magic items in the old games- and it's true that characters would get magic items! But that's really the salient difference, isn't it? 5e doesn't even require magic items ... because characters have so much inherent power. There are always-on cantrips. Magic is not risky (you don't age, it doesn't backfire, etc.). Classes just don't have "dead levels." You almost never worry about healing resources. Seriously- I cannot recall the last time I played 5e when I was worried about healing, whereas I am always thinking about healing in B/X, OD&D, and 1e.

None of this is to say that characters couldn't become powerful in the old days! You could get an artifact or relic (hopefully not with too terrible a drawback)! But the feel of the game is different. I understand why people use the term- because superheroes tend to have powers that are intrinsic to them. In the old days, they didn't come with those powers. They EARNED THEM. By, um, looting corpses and tombs.
 

Remove ads

Top