MarkB
Legend
Admittedly I didn't do much D&Ding back in those days beyond a few games at school, but my impression from reading the spell description is that once you come back in animal form you lose your class levels, and that is not reversed by killing you a second time - and even if you keep your levels they're being halved again with each new casting. So, short of the Wish option, all you're really getting back through repeated kill-and-recast cycles is a 1st level character who has the memories and approximate species of the original character, nothing else.The 'initial Con # of times' rule is specific to raised and resurrected. That and the lack of either res. survival or system shock* checks makes me think that in Gary's mind the creation of a new body was somehow important to all this. I also suspect that it might have been a deliberate way around the raise/res limit ('here's a line in the sand. ...but if it's reeaaally important to you...').
*as mentioned, for reincarnation, with reincarnate having the Cf. (Note that Cf. is a supportive comparative signal, if EGG meant Compare disfavorably, he would use 'contra,' so who knows how he intended people to take it).
So here's the thing: I'm not sure that that wasn't (at least one of the) expected play patterns. Not for grade/middle-schoolers, or even high school/college kids -- for the adult wargamers Gary originally envisioned the game as for. Why include the option to bring your PC back as a black bear*, if you did not intend for players to immediately go casting about for ways to get the character back to being not a black bear**?
*and not have rules for how to continue to adventure as a black bear.
**because the character would want to be alive (even if the player couldn't use them for adventuring)? That doesn't sound very oD&D-AD&D/Gary.
My group, even before 2e codified it, decided that a wish could restore a person to their old form, so when we reincarnated into something undesired, our first notion was to go quest for a wish somewhere. And my impression is that Gary's games had more wishes than AD&D ended up giving out*. However, if you find yourself in a situation where castings of reincarnate/reincarnation are plentiful, but wishes are not, then 'retry until you get the results you like' seems a perfectly reasonable strategy.
*why add the rule about stats over 16 taking 10 and eventually 20 wishes to raise a point if people hadn't been able to spam wishes to great scores before such a rule existed?
It does have the ring of shenanigans in a modern gaming context, but that wasn't explicitly against the norm of the time. Rather famously, Gary and the playtesters of proto-oD&D had their characters load up on iron and steal when in Greyhawk, Blackmoor, etc. to sell when they showed up next session in iron-poor Tekemul -- so much so that they crashed the economies of all three cities. Shenanigans were part of the game.
Not saying I'd want to do that now--but then again, if a well-liked character dies and the only way back is reincarnate that ends with them as a bear or boar or donkey, you darn well bet there'll be some polymorph or wish or other workarounds going on.
That being the case, it hardly seems abusive to do it if the only difference between that and starting over with a new first level character is that you don't need to think up a new name and figure out how to introduce them into the party.






