D&D General Reincarnate is and has always been, weird.

The 'initial Con # of times' rule is specific to raised and resurrected. That and the lack of either res. survival or system shock* checks makes me think that in Gary's mind the creation of a new body was somehow important to all this. I also suspect that it might have been a deliberate way around the raise/res limit ('here's a line in the sand. ...but if it's reeaaally important to you...').
*as mentioned, for reincarnation, with reincarnate having the Cf. (Note that Cf. is a supportive comparative signal, if EGG meant Compare disfavorably, he would use 'contra,' so who knows how he intended people to take it).


So here's the thing: I'm not sure that that wasn't (at least one of the) expected play patterns. Not for grade/middle-schoolers, or even high school/college kids -- for the adult wargamers Gary originally envisioned the game as for. Why include the option to bring your PC back as a black bear*, if you did not intend for players to immediately go casting about for ways to get the character back to being not a black bear**?
*and not have rules for how to continue to adventure as a black bear.
**because the character would want to be alive (even if the player couldn't use them for adventuring)? That doesn't sound very oD&D-AD&D/Gary.


My group, even before 2e codified it, decided that a wish could restore a person to their old form, so when we reincarnated into something undesired, our first notion was to go quest for a wish somewhere. And my impression is that Gary's games had more wishes than AD&D ended up giving out*. However, if you find yourself in a situation where castings of reincarnate/reincarnation are plentiful, but wishes are not, then 'retry until you get the results you like' seems a perfectly reasonable strategy.
*why add the rule about stats over 16 taking 10 and eventually 20 wishes to raise a point if people hadn't been able to spam wishes to great scores before such a rule existed?

It does have the ring of shenanigans in a modern gaming context, but that wasn't explicitly against the norm of the time. Rather famously, Gary and the playtesters of proto-oD&D had their characters load up on iron and steal when in Greyhawk, Blackmoor, etc. to sell when they showed up next session in iron-poor Tekemul -- so much so that they crashed the economies of all three cities. Shenanigans were part of the game.

Not saying I'd want to do that now--but then again, if a well-liked character dies and the only way back is reincarnate that ends with them as a bear or boar or donkey, you darn well bet there'll be some polymorph or wish or other workarounds going on.
Admittedly I didn't do much D&Ding back in those days beyond a few games at school, but my impression from reading the spell description is that once you come back in animal form you lose your class levels, and that is not reversed by killing you a second time - and even if you keep your levels they're being halved again with each new casting. So, short of the Wish option, all you're really getting back through repeated kill-and-recast cycles is a 1st level character who has the memories and approximate species of the original character, nothing else.

That being the case, it hardly seems abusive to do it if the only difference between that and starting over with a new first level character is that you don't need to think up a new name and figure out how to introduce them into the party.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Admittedly I didn't do much D&Ding back in those days beyond a few games at school, but my impression from reading the spell description is that once you come back in animal form you lose your class levels, and that is not reversed by killing you a second time - and even if you keep your levels they're being halved again with each new casting. So, short of the Wish option, all you're really getting back through repeated kill-and-recast cycles is a 1st level character who has the memories and approximate species of the original character, nothing else.

That being the case, it hardly seems abusive to do it if the only difference between that and starting over with a new first level character is that you don't need to think up a new name and figure out how to introduce them into the party.
Where are you getting the halved levels part?

In the 1e descriptions it only says "If an elf, gnome or human is indicated, the character must be created." which does not say whether the created character is 1st level, existing level/xp, or something else. I just looked up and added the DMG commentary to my original post to see if it had anything relevant for that as there are a lot of hidden spell rules there but no it is just adding that monster and animal PCs like PC badgers advance too.

In 3e there was a one level loss on the reincarnated character for each casting so that was a disincentive there for the tactic.
 

Where are you getting the halved levels part?
It's in 2nd edition AD&D (PHB, p.234 "If the reincarnated character returns as a creature eligible to be the same class as he was previously (i.e., a human fighter returns as an elf), the reincarnated character has half his previous levels and hit points. If the character returns as a new character class, his hit points are half his previous total, but he must begin again at 1st level. If the character returns as a creature unable to have a class, he has half the hit points and saving throws of his previous incarnation."). That's enough of a change that I don't imagine a lot of people used this as a replacement for being raised/rezzed. Of course I don't know a lot of people that played 2e with RAW being more than a mild suggestion, so I think a lot of people didn't use that part (especially if they came from 1e, BX, BECMI, etc.).
 
Last edited:

It's in 2nd edition AD&D (PHB, p.234 "If the reincarnated character returns as a creature eligible to be the same class as he was previously (i.e., a human fighter returns as an elf), the reincarnated character has half his previous
levels and hit points. If the character returns as a new character class, his hit points are half his previous total, but he must begin again at 1st level. If the character returns as a creature unable to have a class, he has half the hit points and saving throws of his previous incarnation."
). That's enough of a change that I don't imagine a lot of people used this as a replacement for being raised/rezzed. Of course I don't know a lot of people that played 2e with RAW being more than a mild suggestion, so I think a lot of people didn't use that part (especially if they came from 1e, BX, BECMI, etc.).
Yeah, thanks, that was the version I was going from as most of the discussion seemed to have mentioned 2e.
 

There's a bit of an oddity here, in that there are two such spells in AD&D: reincarnation (Wiz 6) and reincarnate (Drd 7).

In AD&D 2E, both bypass the need for any sort of resurrection survival check, system shock roll, or saving throw.

But in AD&D 1E, this failure-proof status is only given to the wizard's reincarnation spell; the druid's reincarnate spell does not have that caveat (though its note about "Cf. sixth level magic-user spell reincarnation" likely caused a lot of confusion in that regard).
But the raise dead and resurrection limitations look like they are specific to those spells and methods of coming back from the dead.

1e PH page 12:
Resurrection Survival shows the percentage chance the character has of being successfully raised from the dead or resurrected by a cleric. The score of the percentile dice must be equal to or less than the number shown on the table, or the character fails to be revivified and is completely and totally dead forever. Remember that a character can never be raised from the dead/resurrected a total number of times in excess of the character’s initial constitution score.

Reincarnation into a new body seems specifically not raising from the dead or resurrecting which seems to be the same body.

So while the MU description calls out specifically that it does not trigger a system shock or resurrection survival roll, I think that applies to both versions of reincarnate. This seems analogous to the power word hp limit applying to current hp being specified in power word stun but then not repeated in the other power words.
 

Where are you getting the halved levels part?

In the 1e descriptions it only says "If an elf, gnome or human is indicated, the character must be created." which does not say whether the created character is 1st level, existing level/xp, or something else. I just looked up and added the DMG commentary to my original post to see if it had anything relevant for that as there are a lot of hidden spell rules there but no it is just adding that monster and animal PCs like PC badgers advance too.

In 3e there was a one level loss on the reincarnated character for each casting so that was a disincentive there for the tactic.
See it on the bright side, the 1e halfling fighter being reincarnated to a badger can finally reach level 6!

:cool:
 

It's in 2nd edition AD&D (PHB, p.234 "If the reincarnated character returns as a creature eligible to be the same class as he was previously (i.e., a human fighter returns as an elf), the reincarnated character has half his previous
levels and hit points. If the character returns as a new character class, his hit points are half his previous total, but he must begin again at 1st level. If the character returns as a creature unable to have a class, he has half the hit points and saving throws of his previous incarnation."
). That's enough of a change that I don't imagine a lot of people used this as a replacement for being raised/rezzed. Of course I don't know a lot of people that played 2e with RAW being more than a mild suggestion, so I think a lot of people didn't use that part (especially if they came from 1e, BX, BECMI, etc.).
Thanks, I did not remember that change in 2e.

Is that the original 2e PH? The PDFs that are sold are of the revised different art ones and they contain that language for the priest version but not for the wizard one, they say:

Wizard level 6 spell page 230:
Reincarnation
(Necromancy)
Range: Touch Components: V, S, M
Duration: Permanent Casting Time: 1 turn
Area of Effect: Person touched Saving Throw: None
With this spell, the wizard can bring back to life a person who died no more than one day per level of experience of the wizard before the casting of the spell. The essence of the dead person is transferred to another body, possibly one very different from his former body. Reincarnation does not require any saving throw, system shock, or resurrection survival roll. The corpse is touched, and a new incarnation of the person will appear in the area in 1d6 turns. The person reincarnated recalls the majority of his former life and form, but the character class, if any, of the new incarnation might be different indeed. The new incarnation is determined on the following table. If a player character race is indicated, the character must be created.
D100 Roll Incarnation
01–05 Bugbear
06–11 Dwarf
12–18 Elf
19–23 Gnoll
24–28 Gnome
29–33 Goblin
34–40 Half-elf
41–47 Halfling
48–54 Half-orc
55–59 Hobgoblin
60–73 Human
74–79 Kobold
80–85 Orc
86–90 Ogre
91–95 Ogre mage
96–00 Troll
Note: Very good or very evil persons will not be reincarnated as creatures whose general alignment is the opposite.
The material components of the spell are a small drum and a drop of blood.

The priest version pages 297-298:
Reincarnate
(Necromancy)
Sphere: Necromantic
Range: Touch Components: V, S
Duration: Permanent Casting Time: 1 turn
Area of Effect: 1 person Saving Throw: None
With this spell, the priest can bring back a dead person in another body, if death occurred no more than one week before the casting of the spell. Reincarnation does not require any saving throw, system shock, or resurrection survival roll. The corpse is touched, and a new incarnation of the person appears in the area in 1d6 turns. The person reincarnated recalls the majority of his former life and form, but the character class, if any, of the new incarnation might be very different indeed. The new incarnation is determined on the accompanying table or by DM choice. If a player character race is indicated, the character must be created. At the DM’s option, certain special (expensive) incenses can be used that may increase the chance for a character to return as a specific race or species. A wish spell can restore a reincarnated character to its original form and status.
If an unusual creature form is indicated, the DM can (at his option only) use the guidelines for new player character races to allow the character to earn experience and advance in levels, although this may not be in the same class as before. If the reincarnated character returns as a creature eligible to be the same class as he was previously (i.e., a human fighter returns as an elf), the reincarnated character has half his previous levels and hit points. If the character returns as a new character class, his hit points are half his previous total, but he must begin again at 1st level. If the character returns as a creature unable to have a class, he has half the hit points and saving throws of his previous incarnation.
Reincarnated Forms
D100 D100
Roll Incarnation Roll Incarnation
01-03 Badger 41-44 Hawk
04-08 Bear, black 45-58 Human
09-12 Bear, brown 59-61 Lynx
13-16 Boar, wild 62-64 Owl
17-19 Centaur 65-68 Pixie
20-23 Dryad 69-70 Raccoon
24-28 Eagle 71-75 Stag
29-31 Elf 76-80 Wolf
32-34 Faun/satyr 81-85 Wolverine
35-36 Fox 86-00 DM’s choice
37-40 Gnome
 

See it on the bright side, the 1e halfling fighter being reincarnated to a badger can finally reach level 6!

:cool:
If only.

This is specifically covered in 1e.

First in the 1e DMG:

Reincarnation: Regardless of the form of the creature in which the character
is reincarnated, allow the new form to progress as far as possible in
characteristics and abilities. For example, a badger character could grow to
giant size, have maximum hit points, plus bonus points for a high constitution,
and the intelligence level of its former character.
A centaur reincarnation might
eventually gain hit dice up to 5, 6, 7, or even 8, and it would be eligible to
wear armor, use magic items, etc.

From the 1e MM:

BADGER
FREQUENCY: Uncommon
NO. APPEARING: 2-5
ARMOR CLASS: 4
MOVE: 6” (3”)
HIT DICE: 1 + 2
% IN LAIR: Nil
TREASURE TYPE: Nil
NO. OF ATTACKS: 3
DAMAGE/ATTACK: 1-2/1-2/1-3
SPECIAL ATTACKS: Nil
SPECIAL DEFENSES: Nil
MAGIC RESISTANCE: Standard
INTELLIGENCE: Semi-
ALIGNMENT: Neutral
SIZE: S
PSIONIC ABILITY: Nil
Attack/Defense Modes: Nil
These burrowing animals are typically solitary. Their speed accounts for their
high armor class rating. They are fierce fighters and will staunchly defend
their territory. If more than 1 is encountered it will be a mated pair (and
young). The pelt of the badger is typically sold for from 10-30 gold pieces.
Giant Badger: There is a very rare variety of badger which grows to twice the
size of the normal sort: Hit dice: 3; 1-3/1-3/1-6; Size: M. They are otherwise
identical.

So the halfling fighter would then turn into a 1 HD badger able to advance up to a 3 HD giant badger and then to a max hp one. Still not 6th level.
 

If only.

This is specifically covered in 1e.

First in the 1e DMG:

Reincarnation: Regardless of the form of the creature in which the character
is reincarnated, allow the new form to progress as far as possible in
characteristics and abilities. For example, a badger character could grow to
giant size, have maximum hit points, plus bonus points for a high constitution,
and the intelligence level of its former character.
A centaur reincarnation might
eventually gain hit dice up to 5, 6, 7, or even 8, and it would be eligible to
wear armor, use magic items, etc.

From the 1e MM:

BADGER
FREQUENCY: Uncommon
NO. APPEARING: 2-5
ARMOR CLASS: 4
MOVE: 6” (3”)
HIT DICE: 1 + 2
% IN LAIR: Nil
TREASURE TYPE: Nil
NO. OF ATTACKS: 3
DAMAGE/ATTACK: 1-2/1-2/1-3
SPECIAL ATTACKS: Nil
SPECIAL DEFENSES: Nil
MAGIC RESISTANCE: Standard
INTELLIGENCE: Semi-
ALIGNMENT: Neutral
SIZE: S
PSIONIC ABILITY: Nil
Attack/Defense Modes: Nil
These burrowing animals are typically solitary. Their speed accounts for their
high armor class rating. They are fierce fighters and will staunchly defend
their territory. If more than 1 is encountered it will be a mated pair (and
young). The pelt of the badger is typically sold for from 10-30 gold pieces.
Giant Badger: There is a very rare variety of badger which grows to twice the
size of the normal sort: Hit dice: 3; 1-3/1-3/1-6; Size: M. They are otherwise
identical.

So the halfling fighter would then turn into a 1 HD badger able to advance up to a 3 HD giant badger and then to a max hp one. Still not 6th level.
I e heard but don't have access to verify that the 1e DMG also had a section about players having no humanoid PCs like dragons or whatever that pretty much a mounted to making a class with similar power as the normal starting classes. It's entirely possible that it's the same section that you are referring to. I had 2e games where one of us was playing a modified class beast and we enjoyed it though so it wasn't a 1e exclusive solution.

For some reason I want to say that I heard it in an old puffinforest let's read the 1e DMG video talking about that section
 

Reasonable behavior, in-character decision? Well, I suppose that's up to interpretation, isn't it?

Kind of weird, though, to imagine having been killed (almost certainly traumatically), then be recreated into a completely different body (including that of a black bear back in the AD&D example prior), and then either just be killed again off hand or commit suicide because the body wasn't to preference, and thinking of that as all "reasonable behavior".

Honestly, the only way this becomes reasonable behavior is because it's the player making that decision based on the metagame knowledge that other, specifically more preferable, results were available on the reincarnation table. And if that's the game you're playing, that's fine. But don't chide people who have a view that it's behavior they really don't want to see in their D&D games.
Yes, it's absolutely reasonable behavior when you have reliable magic to come back from the dead. "Dying" when you're going to be alive again an hour later is more like going under general anesthesia, since it's not permanent.

Real world people go under general anesthesia to get bigger butts and boobs (and other cosmetic surgery), and back when silicone implants were invented general anesthesia had a mortality rate of around 1 in 1000 (now it's more like 1 in 100,000). People inject weird non-medical grade stuff for similar enhancements, with a huge risk of complications, illness, and death for similar boost. (AFAIK there haven't been controlled studies of illegal injections). People will go through a year-long, extremely painful, complication-prone process of breaking and stretching bone to get a few inches of height.

And that's just for cosmetic purposes, that's not someone who is routinely going on life threatening adventures and has already died and come back at least once seeking to get better at surviving the extreme dangers they put themselves in by using a procedure they have experienced and know is safe.

So I absolutely don't object to PCs doing something that increases their chances of surviving their adventuring career that is less dangerous and less traumatic than things real-world people do for purely cosmetic purposes.
 

Remove ads

Top