D&D General Stealth is Weird in 5e

Steampunkette

Game Designer and 3rd Party Publisher!
EN WORLD+
Don't get me wrong, 5.5e helps. But "You gain the invisible condition" is kinda... weird. The invisible condition, by its nature, gives you concealment. So once you've hidden behind a tree, you are invisible so long as you remain quiet.

There's no guidance for how to find a hidden creature, nothing about leaving cover/concealment, etc. It's all just really open to interpretation...

So here's my suggestion for how to complicate it just enough to cover some bases! I am specifically soliciting feedback, here.

Step 1) Determine Range and Conditions.
If you are closer to the creature you're hiding from than their Wisdom Modifier in 5ft squares, you require 3/4 cover or heavy concealment to hide. If you are outside that range, half cover or light concealment allows you to hide. If the creature has the blind condition, you have heavy concealment at any range. If the creature has Blindsense you cannot benefit from concealment, but may still hide behind cover.

You cannot hide from a creature that is actively aware of you unless you can gain total cover or heavy concealment against that creature, such as by rounding a corner or moving into a Darkness spell's area.

This allows characters to do things like hiding in bushes or tall grasses, which would typically only provide light concealment. But if someone's within 5-25ft, close enough to see the grass bent down around you or through the bush more easily, you cannot. Notably, since it is based on the Wisdom Modifier of the creature you are hiding from, you cannot know, in advance, if Light or Heavy Concealment, or Half or 3/4 Cover, is required. Thus it is always better to hide in the best possible cover or concealment, but even less optimal options may be enough... But you won't know until it is too late!

The ability to -partially- negate Blindsense is also notable. Echolocation is often foiled in horror movies by behind an object before the next audio pulse is emitted, for example. Similarly, thermal vision can be foiled by something as thin as a sheet of paper. And even the Graboids, the source of the concept of tremorsense, could be left unaware of your location if you just stand still.

Step 2) Active versus Passive
If you are taking the Hide action or otherwise specifically choosing to enter into hiding, you roll a Stealth check against the Passive Perception of creatures in the area. Once you are hidden, creatures that are actively looking for you take the Search Action in order to find you. If a creature enters into the area where you are hidden, you must roll a Stealth check against that creature's Passive Perception to remain hidden.

When a creature takes the Search Action they roll an Investigation check against the Passive Stealth of a creature hiding within a number of squares equal to the investigator's Wisdom modifier. If the hidden creature has total cover, the investigator cannot reveal the target with this action unless they are within 5ft of the hidden creature.

Passive Perception is 10+Perception Modifier. Passive Stealth is 12+Stealth Modifier. This 2 point increase represents the success you have already had in hiding from creatures that are now actively seeking you.

Here, we reward the hiding creature for their success by making it harder to find them. We also determine who does or does not make the check on a given turn, rather than forcing the player to keep making stealth checks every X turns if creatures remain in the area or some other nonsense. Similarly, if a creature spends an action investigating they are not also spending that action attacking, casting spells, or otherwise working against the creature whose location they do not know.

We also create an 'area of effect' for the searching party. This both reduces the number of actions wasted on investigation, since searching 'the area' now has a defined perimeter, and places results in the triggering of the default rule for retrying skill checks being something a creature isn't allowed to do unless some change in circumstances occurs, such as the cover or concealment being reduced by a Fireball, or the gaining of Guidance. They can still search for the hiding creature, of course... but not within an area they've already searched.

Step 3) Movement
So long as you remain hidden, creatures do not know where you are, though they may know where you -were- before you became hidden, and seek you out based on the last place they saw you. While hidden from a creature, you can move up to half your speed by taking the Hide Action on your turn to roll a Stealth Check against the Passive Perception of creatures that might reasonably see or hear you. You must end this movement with appropriate cover or concealment in order to remain hidden. You may, instead, move up to your full speed while remaining hidden with the Hide Action on your turn, but you have disadvantage on your Stealth Check to hide at the end of your movement.

If you successfully hide in a new location, even a creature that previously knew your location becomes completely unaware of where you are.

Here we have an excellent way to maintain the active versus passive structure. If you are moving you must hide as an action to maintain the hidden condition. You also have to move slowly if you want to -stay- hidden, to avoid making too much noise. This also brings Invisibility to the forefront. Invisibility grants you Heavy Concealment, but you still have to hide to move stealthily. And referring back to Step 3: If you're invisible and someone hasn't seen you before you went invisible or otherwise snuck invisibly into the area, you roll your Stealth check to see if they've hear you on approach.

Step 4) Benefits
While Hidden, you gain the following benefits:
  • If you initiate combat while hidden, your targets are surprised and you may choose to have any initiative between 1 and 20+Initiative Modifier, going first in case of a tie.
  • When you make an attack roll on a creature while you are hidden from that creature you gain advantage on the attack roll.
  • You cannot be targeted by spells or effects which require line of sight or awareness of your location or presence.

Oh, look, a distinct and potent, but ultimately not devastating, reason to set up ambushes.

Step 5) Coming out of Hiding
The following situations end the hiding condition:

  • You make an attack roll.
  • You cast a spell or use an ability or item that mimics a spell which has visual or auditory elements.
  • You speak above a whisper or otherwise make noise.
  • You fail a Stealth Check when taking the Hide action.
  • A creature succeeds on an Investigation check when taking the Search Action.
  • Your Cover or Concealment is removed or negated such as a creature moving to the same side of your cover as you.
  • You move out of Cover or Concealment and do not end your turn with Cover or Concealment sufficient for a Hide Action.
  • You choose to stop hiding.

And that's... it. Covers all the major bases, gives some solid reasons to spend your turns hiding, etc... but then we come to the edge cases!

Rogue: Cunning Action's bonus action hide supercedes the hide action taking an action.
Ranger: Hide in Plain Sight (2014 and associated systems) can now just be described as having full cover and/or heavy concealment for the purpose of hiding in natural environments.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Don't get me wrong, 5.5e helps. But "You gain the invisible condition" is kinda... weird. The invisible condition, by its nature, gives you concealment. So once you've hidden behind a tree, you are invisible so long as you remain quiet.

For whatever reason they decided that conditions replace most verbiage describing results of any action; whether that makes sense for hidden is open for debate. I just remind people that it's a condition - they aren't actually invisible as in the spell. I think they should have used a different word to describe it.

Having said that, all invisible means is that you have advantage on initiative and attacks and attacks against you have disadvantage unless you can be seen. If you actually read the book (I know, it's rare) I think it's clear.

There's no guidance for how to find a hidden creature, nothing about leaving cover/concealment, etc. It's all just really open to interpretation...

So here's my suggestion for how to complicate it just enough to cover some bases! I am specifically soliciting feedback, here.



This allows characters to do things like hiding in bushes or tall grasses, which would typically only provide light concealment. But if someone's within 5-25ft, close enough to see the grass bent down around you or through the bush more easily, you cannot. Notably, since it is based on the Wisdom Modifier of the creature you are hiding from, you cannot know, in advance, if Light or Heavy Concealment, or Half or 3/4 Cover, is required. Thus it is always better to hide in the best possible cover or concealment, but even less optimal options may be enough... But you won't know until it is too late!

The ability to -partially- negate Blindsense is also notable. Echolocation is often foiled in horror movies by behind an object before the next audio pulse is emitted, for example. Similarly, thermal vision can be foiled by something as thin as a sheet of paper. And even the Graboids, the source of the concept of tremorsense, could be left unaware of your location if you just stand still.



Here, we reward the hiding creature for their success by making it harder to find them. We also determine who does or does not make the check on a given turn, rather than forcing the player to keep making stealth checks every X turns if creatures remain in the area or some other nonsense. Similarly, if a creature spends an action investigating they are not also spending that action attacking, casting spells, or otherwise working against the creature whose location they do not know.

We also create an 'area of effect' for the searching party. This both reduces the number of actions wasted on investigation, since searching 'the area' now has a defined perimeter, and places results in the triggering of the default rule for retrying skill checks being something a creature isn't allowed to do unless some change in circumstances occurs, such as the cover or concealment being reduced by a Fireball, or the gaining of Guidance. They can still search for the hiding creature, of course... but not within an area they've already searched.



Here we have an excellent way to maintain the active versus passive structure. If you are moving you must hide as an action to maintain the hidden condition. You also have to move slowly if you want to -stay- hidden, to avoid making too much noise. This also brings Invisibility to the forefront. Invisibility grants you Heavy Concealment, but you still have to hide to move stealthily. And referring back to Step 3: If you're invisible and someone hasn't seen you before you went invisible or otherwise snuck invisibly into the area, you roll your Stealth check to see if they've hear you on approach.



Oh, look, a distinct and potent, but ultimately not devastating, reason to set up ambushes.



And that's... it. Covers all the major bases, gives some solid reasons to spend your turns hiding, etc... but then we come to the edge cases!

Rogue: Cunning Action's bonus action hide supercedes the hide action taking an action.
Ranger: Hide in Plain Sight (2014 and associated systems) can now just be described as having full cover and/or heavy concealment for the purpose of hiding in natural environments.

I think what you're proposing is fine, I'm just not sure it's necessary. There are going to be times for example when you should be able to hide while only lightly obscured because whoever you're hiding from is significantly distracted. It's difficult, if not impossible, to come up with rules that cover every situation.

The only change I make is that the DC for hiding from any individual in my game is based on either an opposed roll or the enemy's passive perception. Other than that I handle whether or not you can hide or stay hidden on a case by case basis.
 




One of things they tried to fix was the use case where you emerge from a hidden location, run up to a creature and attack. They want you to get advantage on that attack. But if you lose the condition as soon as you emerge from cover, then it doesn't work. But in trying to fix that they introduced a different problem of potentially not being seen when you obviously should.

But there's also the problem of potential LoS vs actual LoS. You should be able to stealthily follow someone walking down a hallway even if there's no cover/concealment to hide behind simply because they aren't looking in your direction. But of course if for whatever reason they do look back, then you should be spotted no matter what you rolled for stealth.

There's just so many potential use cases that make hard-coding these rules difficult. Even the stuff like make a noise louder then a whisper, doesn't that depend on the ambient noise? What if you are stealthing near a large waterfall that would drown out most noise and people need to shout to each other to be heard. Clearly making noise slightly louder then a whisper shouldn't reveal you.
 

One of things they tried to fix was the use case where you emerge from a hidden location, run up to a creature and attack. They want you to get advantage on that attack. But if you lose the condition as soon as you emerge from cover, then it doesn't work. But in trying to fix that they introduced a different problem of potentially not being seen when you obviously should.

I don't think they were necessarily trying to fix emerging from hidden and attacking with advantage. You don't need advantage to sneak attack and steady aim grants advantage. Rogues in the games I play almost always get sneak attack and regularly have advantage.


But there's also the problem of potential LoS vs actual LoS. You should be able to stealthily follow someone walking down a hallway even if there's no cover/concealment to hide behind simply because they aren't looking in your direction. But of course if for whatever reason they do look back, then you should be spotted no matter what you rolled for stealth.


There's just so many potential use cases that make hard-coding these rules difficult. Even the stuff like make a noise louder then a whisper, doesn't that depend on the ambient noise? What if you are stealthing near a large waterfall that would drown out most noise and people need to shout to each other to be heard. Clearly making noise slightly louder then a whisper shouldn't reveal you.

There are situations where I will let a rogue sneak up on someone that could see them but they don't, that's were DM discretion and what kind of style the group wants. Personally I don't want someone popping up from behind a crate like a Jack-in-the-box and getting advantage if the target was looking in the direction of the box already. For that matter, my players don't want that either because I apply rulings like that to the enemy as well as the PCs.
 

I don't think they were necessarily trying to fix emerging from hidden and attacking with advantage. You don't need advantage to sneak attack and steady aim grants advantage. Rogues in the games I play almost always get sneak attack and regularly have advantage.
By RAW you would lose the condition before being able to attack with advantage, I think there was even a sage advice, or maybe a tweet that had to clarify it. The same wording was there in the UA, but got removed, so it seems likely that they did it to clarify that situation.

But yes in actual games most people would ignore that strict RAW reading.
There are situations where I will let a rogue sneak up on someone that could see them but they don't, that's were DM discretion and what kind of style the group wants. Personally I don't want someone popping up from behind a crate like a Jack-in-the-box and getting advantage if the target was looking in the direction of the box already. For that matter, my players don't want that either because I apply rulings like that to the enemy as well as the PCs.
I don't mind the Jack-in-the-box gain to gain advantage. Like sure if someone is focused directly at you they shouldn't be "suprised" but generally speaking they can't just focus on the guy popping up behind a crate, combat is going on and they are probably paying attention to lots of different things, so you can still catch them slow to react when you do pop up because they don't know when it will be. And mechanically it's not particularly different from just standing there using Steady Aim so it's a whatever to me.

But regardless, we agree there needs to be a lot of DM discretion in running stealth. And personally I don't think trying to clarify it with more rules is going to change that much. The best approach is probably keep the word count relatively low on the actual rules, make it clear that DMs are going to have to use their discretion, and then provide a few very short examples of them using that discretion.
 


To the OP: good write-up but I think you need to account for invisibility in part 1 Determining Conditions etc. To cover this, I'd add the bolded here "If the creature has the blind condition and-or if you are invisible, you have heavy concealment at any range."

For step 5 I'd break it down to those things that automatically blow your cover and those things that only have a chance of blowing your cover assuming you want to remain hidden. Making a ranged attack from cover, failing a stealth check, or casting a spell should IMO only give observers a new chance to find you rather than automatically blowing your cover, so as to allow for: "The shot came from somewhere in those crates but I can't tell where" or "What was that? I'm sure I just heard a twig snap!" or "I can hear a voice mumbling up in the trees but I've no idea where it's coming from"
 

Remove ads

Top