Spoilers Strange New Worlds s4


log in or register to remove this ad


I also wonder whether something happens with Pelia and Scotty that could explain how Scotty is properly older in TOS.
I know she was only available for a limited amount of filming, and a lot of that separate to the rest of the cast (thus episodes which she spends alone in her quarters) but it definitely seems like Scotty is the Chief Engineer right now, not Pelia.
 

Hopefully the resolution of the series does not involve killing off all of the characters we know and love but I am sure it will involve killing off some of them. La'an, in particular, I fear she is not long for these worlds. It basically comes down to whether it makes more sense that she is not mentioned in Star Trek II if she is alive or dead. And I lean towards dead.

I also wonder whether something happens with Pelia and Scotty that could explain how Scotty is properly older in TOS.

Given La'ans speculated recruitment to Division 31, maybe she, Pelia and Scotty get caught up in some timetravel shenanigans. Scotty ages up before coming back, La'an's records are wiped and Pelia is off building sandcast;es.

Number One features on a recruitment poster in Lower Decks so it seems that she gets promoted and goes on to great things

Which could mean Ortega's head is on the chopping block, though she does go out as a war hero so we'll have to wait and see.
 

This episode had a by-the-numbers but enjoyable B plot (Uhura saves the day; sometimes you can do everything right and still not get the ending you wanted) and an...odd...A plot. I really didn't understand why the writers felt it necessary to have Kirk drug the admiral to achieve his objective. Watching it, that revelation was a surprise; I thought the episode had already done a fine job of establishing that this guy was unstable (head injury, previous vendetta against Kirk's father, cover-up, emotional response to the murder of his family), so when he lost it, it already made sense.

Kirk drugging him really is not a good look for that character, especially as the underlying dilemma was about him putting moral rules above consequences. So...he's a deontologist when it comes to definitely killing thousands to potentially save millions, but a utilitarian when it comes to drugging people and lying. Confusing, but also just not on brand (to be fair, I've never loved the way this version of Kirk was cast or written).

It also made the rest of the crew onboard, who apparently were willing to follow orders from an increasingly obviously unstable commander and kill thousands of potential innocents, look not great. Like, if Kirk hadn't drugged the admiral, they would have wiped out the planet. Any other episode would have had them all in open rebellion to find a better way. So I thought they were out of character.

For me, this was the opposite of the previous episode, which I thought was mostly bad but had a great ending that emphasized character in a good way. This episode was mostly good but the ending left me confuzzled.
 
Last edited:

Wish people would stop pretending tropes and gimmicks are the same thing.

I've enjoyed all the episodes this season (so far). It does feel like there's been more reliance on gimmicks to attract attention to the episodes.


Definitely have a gimmick:

Episode 4 - "A Case of Chiaroscuro"
Trope - Detective noir story
Gimmick - shown black and black and white

Episode 5 - "Level-Five Transporter Accident"
Trope - ?
Gimmick - PUPPETS

Episode 7 - "Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass"
Trope - almighty being messes with the crew
Gimmick - shown in soft focus and extreme zooms, just like real soap operas


A case could that episodes 3 and 6 do to

Episode 3 - "Human Best Friend"
Trope - Drunken shenanigans
Gimmick - Blackout drunk, need to piece together what happened, like the Hangover movie.

Episode 6 - "Off-Hour"
Trope - Out of Control Ship
Gimmick - Real time counter


With my rant out of the way, I kind of wish, like Morrus, they used Una instead of Kirk (or even something with Ortegas). We only have like 12 episodes with this crew. Kirk has an entire series and 7 movies already. Not a fan of the drugging solution.
 

Kirk drugging him really is not a good look for that character,
Yeah, I just wish they'd come up with a better solution than that. It makes me feel like Kirk doesn't deserve to be the captain. It's kinda tarnished him in my eyes. I mean, I'll get over it and likely forget all about it. But right now that particular detail gives me the ick. Sure, you can stun people or whatever, or even Vulcan nerve pinch them, but drugging them secretly against their will is a type of assault which feels different. Probably because of its association with sexual assault in real life. It was a poor choice.
 



I'm guessing that many posters aren't going to be happy with today's episode, either.
Todays episode was brilliant. An entire tribute to The Princess Bride that even has Pelia going off with a Miracleworker named Max!!

and the Enterprise fights a dragon! This was metafictional 'gimmick' done right, a simple plot and freedom for the characters to have fun. Anson Mount was spectacular in that regard.

Those dress uniforms at the beginning were kinda snazzy too, I want one

The Kirk Laan relationship does beg the question - what happens to her after next season
 

Remove ads

Top