The Parable of the Toaster | When "It's a Player Issue" is no excuse

It's possible to make games that can't be ruined just by trying to make good decisions instead of bad ones. We know this since such games have been made. So there's no excuse.
 

log in or register to remove this ad



It's possible to make games that can't be ruined just by trying to make good decisions instead of bad ones. We know this since such games have been made. So there's no excuse.

I suspect that turns on whether people A) agree withour second sentence and B) think such games don't just have other problems. That's usually been the counters I've seen in the past.
 

I think that a certain degree of generalized coverage is helpful for games trying to avert the toaster situation that the OP outlined.

Easily adapted resolution mechanics, or basic subsystems for different areas, depending on the outlook of the game/engine, can be helpful-- I see a kind of right-to-repair ethos as being something relevant here, where its good to have games that can be popped open, or use modular/standardized parts, to reduce the likelihood someone feels the need to stick a proverbial knife in their figurative toaster.
I disagree with this claim pretty strongly.

The four RPGs that I've played most recently are S/Lay W/Me, Showdown, Agon 2e, and Torchbearer 2e:

S/Lay W/Me doesn't have anything like an "easily adapted resolution mechanic - it has a rule for turn-taking, rules for the limits of permitted narration, rules for when narration triggers either participant to roll dice, and a rule for when to compare the two participants' dice rolls and how that comparison then shapes the subsequent permitted/required narrations. I think it's a pretty good RPG; the session where I played the hero (as opposed to the monster and lover) was vibrant, and intense, and I "lost" without even noticing until I reflected afterwards: Playing S/Lay W/Me

*Showdown is another two-player game with a very strict structure. It has no "easily adapted resolution mechanics"; but it does have rules for how dice rolls settle narration rights over the present and the past of the two PCs, and rules for the parameters of what is narrated, and produces pretty compelling character development in a context of intense conflict: Playing "storygames": Mobile Frame Zero - Firebrands; and Showdown

*Agon 2e is more conventional as an RPG than either S/Lay W/Me or Showdown, but it is very obviously designed to support Homeric roleplaying - in the way PCs are conceived and built, the way scenarios (islands) are set up, and the way the campaign develops and is resolved (with the big questions being (i) whether the heroes return home, and (ii) if they do, what their legacy will be). It's not a game that will make you wonder what the reach of Achilles's spear was; but its likely to remind you of Achilles's love for Patroclus, or Priam's love for Paris: Agon 2e: family-themed actual play

*Torchbearer 2e is the most "generic" of the four RPGs that I've mentioned. But it is still designed to support a particular sort of RPGing - in terms of fiction, something pretty similar to classic D&D; and in terms of mechanical feel, something that feels post-D&D and a lot more systematised. But if you want to play Tomb of Horrors as Gygax intended it, TB2e isn't the system you want. There's already a system that will do that, namely, classic D&D!​

I feel that a fundamental part of game design is maximizing utility, there's fundamentally very little intrinsic value in making your game less useful to any given participant, to making them have a worse time. One might even consider the maximization of utility to be the essential skill of game design.

Specialty enters the picture, but it comes from how creating utility produces an opportunity cost in other sources of utility in your game, preferences is how we navigate parity in those opportunity costs both for ourselves and in the context of choosing between groups to satisfy
I've got doubts that game design has utility maximisation as a fundamental element. But even if it does, that doesn't entail that games should incline towards the "generic". Eg my utility is enhanced by having games available like the ones I mentioned just above; and it seems plausible to me that the overall utility of the population of game-players is increased by having a wide range of games available to play.

When it comes to Masks, and tactical advantages, that actually seems to me to be a fairly trivial house rule for those who want it (Baker discusses a version of it in the "Advanced ****ery" chapter of Apocalypse World). But I don't see how any game designer was under any sort of obligation to include it. Assuming that they're any good (as a designer), they've written a game that facilitates the play that they wanted to facilitate.
 

More complex or abstract, narrative-focused games have always been fascinating to me, I'll admit.

However, the older I get, the more I simply want a simple task-based resolution system.

A player wants their character to do X, but there's some ambiguity as to whether they can pull it off in the immediate conflict / context, so I call for a specific, task-based roll to determine the overall outcome.

And the task is based on clear, more literal stats on their character sheet (for example, a trait for "getting things done in an immediate, physical or athletic sense" rather than a trait to "measure how much does this impact the character's destiny and generational emotional trauma state of their descendants".

The latter is fascinating, but I don't have the mental capacity for those kinds of "plot or theme character traits" anymore.
 

More complex or abstract, narrative-focused games have always been fascinating to me, I'll admit.

However, the older I get, the more I simply want a simple task-based resolution system.

A player wants their character to do X, but there's some ambiguity as to whether they can pull it off in the immediate conflict / context, so I call for a specific, task-based roll to determine the overall outcome.

And the task is based on clear, more literal stats on their character sheet (for example, a trait for "getting things done in an immediate, physical or athletic sense" rather than a trait to "measure how much does this impact the character's destiny and generational emotional trauma state of their descendants".

The latter is fascinating, but I don't have the mental capacity for those kinds of "plot or theme character traits" anymore.
Interesting. I have been cutting more and more from the combat pillar to facilitate "plot of theme character traits" in my RPGs. I do understand the exercise though and how it can be a bit taxing.
 

Interesting. I have been cutting more and more from the combat pillar to facilitate "plot of theme character traits" in my RPGs. I do understand the exercise though and how it can be a bit taxing.
The weird thing is, I'd like to abstract combat more. Like, every participant in a fight tests their preferred "physical conflict" stat and the degrees of success / failure summarizes the overall outcome instead of a turn by turn grindfest.

edit: except for important duels, where things get more involved. I like the various duelling rules from Outgunned.
 
Last edited:

When I was growing up, I was taught some very specific things that helped me to be the person that I am today.
  1. You don't tug on Superman's cape,
  2. You don't spit into the wind,
  3. You don't pull the mask off the ol' Lone Ranger, and
  4. You don't get Blackrazor or Whelm without going through White Plume Mountain. (But you can have Wave. Nobody swims or uses tridents, anyway.)
In other words, knives are just the third-party/homebrew solutions everyone knows to bring for your toaster-world setting.
You also don't cast firestorm in a small dungeon room before reading just how many squares it affects. I may or may not of done this.
 

Are you sure you mean Second Wind? Second Wind is a base fighter ability that all of the fighters have.
That was my point. Since it was a base fighter ability instead of something specific to a particular subclass, I had to rewrite their rules to make it work. Most of us old school people just need a Fighter, Wizard, Cleric, and Rogue. Wreck everything else and we won't care that much we will just ban it in our games.
 

Remove ads

Top