In addition to what @Umbran posted just upthread, I would add two things:I think its more that we shouldn't presume that relatively low income, or a low degree of popularity / retention or whatever partially interchangeable synonym we use, is the goal of any given system unless we know that it is.
First, I don't imagine that the typical RPG has the goal of low income or a small audience. But if its designer is realistic, that is what they will expect. They might hope that their game will miraculously break out; but again, if they're realistic, they'll know that this hope is not likely to be realised.
Second, to me it seems that most successful RPG designers - outside of the handful of big corporate games - recognise that their audience plays a variety of games, and deliberately designs for that audience. They're not designing games like WOW or even D&D where part of what the player is paying for is access to, and participation, in a big network of people playing the same game and having similar play experiences. They're designing games that will provide the variety their audience is looking for.






