The Parable of the Toaster | When "It's a Player Issue" is no excuse

I think its more that we shouldn't presume that relatively low income, or a low degree of popularity / retention or whatever partially interchangeable synonym we use, is the goal of any given system unless we know that it is.
In addition to what @Umbran posted just upthread, I would add two things:

First, I don't imagine that the typical RPG has the goal of low income or a small audience. But if its designer is realistic, that is what they will expect. They might hope that their game will miraculously break out; but again, if they're realistic, they'll know that this hope is not likely to be realised.

Second, to me it seems that most successful RPG designers - outside of the handful of big corporate games - recognise that their audience plays a variety of games, and deliberately designs for that audience. They're not designing games like WOW or even D&D where part of what the player is paying for is access to, and participation, in a big network of people playing the same game and having similar play experiences. They're designing games that will provide the variety their audience is looking for.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

There's only room for a handful of big broad-appeal games, because they are in competition with each other.

But there's room for plenty of smaller niche games, and in that context you are not trying to compete for mass appeal, you are trying to compete for distinctiveness. Dishes meant to be consumed only occasionally need to have a stronger flavour.
 

Sure, but games still need to appeal to the width of the audience that they are, hypothetically, going for.

If the deciding factor to whether a given player is in that group is the extent to which the game already works or doesn't work for them in all its details, then it becomes tautologically impossible for a game to improve. At best, the system of value at work can only echo chamber the game's design further by further purity testing the audience out.

The game should be for the people it appeals to, but that's going to include people who like the thrust of the design, but are looking for improvements in particular areas.

Back to Masks, if a player

  • Like the idea of Teen Superhero Drama.
  • Likes the playbooks being designed around producing particular arcs.
  • Is excited by specific playbook mechanics (like the Beacon's checklist of things they want to make happen)
  • Likes the Conditions being emotional states, and resolving them by acting out.
  • Likes the Aesthetics and setting of Halcyon City or at least one or two of the Unbound Variants.
  • Likes the idea of fighting villains as advertised in the ad discourse up thread.
  • Likes the idea of playing to find out what happens as the game describes it.
  • Likes the art in the book.

I would personally feel myopic trying to assert that the much smaller detail of whether its possible for a good plan to provide a small bonus to the effectiveness of a combat roll, or even the broader feedback that they might consider something to add some more structure to that activity (again, like something Legends tried) would somehow exclude them from the goal audience.

Because that is, the conversation we were having about it.
 

Sure, but games still need to appeal to the width of the audience that they are, hypothetically, going for.

If the deciding factor to whether a given player is in that group is the extent to which the game already works or doesn't work for them in all its details, then it becomes tautologically impossible for a game to improve. At best, the system of value at work can only echo chamber the game's design further by further purity testing the audience out.

The game should be for the people it appeals to, but that's going to include people who like the thrust of the design, but are looking for improvements in particular areas.

Back to Masks, if a player

  • Like the idea of Teen Superhero Drama.
  • Likes the playbooks being designed around producing particular arcs.
  • Is excited by specific playbook mechanics (like the Beacon's checklist of things they want to make happen)
  • Likes the Conditions being emotional states, and resolving them by acting out.
  • Likes the Aesthetics and setting of Halcyon City or at least one or two of the Unbound Variants.
  • Likes the idea of fighting villains as advertised in the ad discourse up thread.
  • Likes the idea of playing to find out what happens as the game describes it.
  • Likes the art in the book.

I would personally feel myopic trying to assert that the much smaller detail of whether its possible for a good plan to provide a small bonus to the effectiveness of a combat roll, or even the broader feedback that they might consider something to add some more structure to that activity (again, like something Legends tried) would somehow exclude them from the goal audience.

Because that is, the conversation we were having about it.

Well with Masks specifically I’m not convinced this is a small detail. It’s adding in a process of evaluation that the other person (the GM) might not like.

Narrativist games as a whole (and maybe rpgs as a whole) have to wrestle with the issue of how much fictional position, the way we evaluate the fiction of a characters approach, actually has an impact.

If you take it as a given that some people want to wrangle better positioning, you could actually say this is a hobby wide design problem because it tends to reflect vastly different attitudes to play and what the fun of play is.

Purposefully shutting down the effects of positioning is a known design switch to solve the problem.

.

The reason a lot of design theory deals with types of fun, is to try and answer the questions you posed without it being a tautology. There are of course different design theories but to give an example:

A game tests specific skills

One of the skills Chess tests is memorisation.

If you hate that skill then you can go to the drawing board and come up with a different game. Let’s say Chess 360. Chess 360 wouldn’t be improved by changing it to add memorisation back in because some people like memorisation.
 

There is a lot of game design theory that concerns this, and its why we're talking about it, I've linked some designers and video essayists talking through the issue up thread. They establish useful language and concepts for thinking through the problem borrowed from an adjacent medium.

I think we're still sort of in the infancy of the medium, which we've "properly" had since what, the 70s, as a whole, and the specific subniche of "narrative" gaming is even younger and more fragmentary right now.

We don't have much settled practice, we have, at best, cultural factions centered around particular figures or games, and all of these games are highly experimental, in principle if not in intent.

Personally, I still find utility min/maxing useful as a guiding principle in purity/broad appeal, so a solution that minimally satisfies the "desire path" while performing as little harm as possible to the appeal of the game from a purist perspective, is a big win in my eyes because this seens like a common sticking point in Masks reception in online discussion about the game.

Of course, that conception of purity is taking some things for granted about the design intent of the game that might not be true in the first place.
 

Most important is to know your audience, and have a niche: do something different. I don't think there is any competition, there is one game that is 80%, 10 that are 15%, and the rest are 5%. Do what you are going to do. It takes a lot of leg work, marketing, going to cons, etc. to make it even in a break even sense; building a following is also important. So it goes.
 

If the deciding factor to whether a given player is in that group is the extent to which the game already works or doesn't work for them in all its details, then it becomes tautologically impossible for a game to improve.

So?

Why can't a game just be what it is? You can like it for what it is, or not, and get on with your day.

Plus, "improvement" is undefined here. I suspect you have an unspoken intent there that may not be (indeed, almost certainly is not) universal.
 

So?

Why can't a game just be what it is? You can like it for what it is, or not, and get on with your day.

Plus, "improvement" is undefined here. I suspect you have an unspoken intent there that may not be (indeed, almost certainly is not) universal.
I'm not sure much is being said here, are we embarking on a kind of multiplayer existential crisis on the nature of art, value, and how it intersects with subjectivity? Do things becone good or bad only because we choose to regard them so? Is the quality of the writing only a property of the reader?

What would universal intent even look like? A version of Masks suited to the average FIFA fan?
 

I'm not sure much is being said here, are we embarking on a kind of multiplayer existential crisis on the nature of art, value, and how it intersects with subjectivity? Do things becone good or bad only because we choose to regard them so? Is the quality of the writing only a property of the reader?

What would universal intent even look like? A version of Masks suited to the average FIFA fan?
I think the only one invoking that crisis is you. Everyone else replying to you seems pretty satisfied that a thing can be good because it accomplishes what it seeks to well, without including "well I wanted something different [which you presumptuously call improvement]" baggage.
 

I think the only one invoking that crisis is you. Everyone else replying to you seems pretty satisfied that a thing can be good because it accomplishes what it seeks to well, without including "well I wanted something different [which you presumptuously call improvement]" baggage.
But it sort of seems like the issue is one of control, its being presented that some people in this thread don't like that someone feels differently about the game than they do, and the people who feel that way keep reaching for this strategy of using the concept of subjectivity to undermine dissenting views as if I owe them a compatible viewpoint, or am supposed to have some kind of "come to jesus moment" where the inevitability is supposed to set in.

It isn't a fruitful line of argumentation, because it isn't really about the game at this point, its about what discourse is permissible concerning the game, and how we might be fantasizing the subjectivity of others can be undermined to manufacture consensus. I don't need any other particular, miniscule, subset of the audience for the game (which isn't the case, some of the people arguing with me have claimed to never touched it) to agree with me. We don't need to agree to move forward, but that's a problem this community has had before.

The OP of this thread is about times when the incentive structures of the system cause friction for the players, and designing to help that not happen. It kind of seems like ya'll are well off-topic, or at least taking a largely belligerent "we shouldn't design around avoiding that because it compromises the artistic integrity of the game in question" stance on it that's blotting out other views.

But I feel like, if Conway et all get that feedback, and want to alter it in some future permutation of the design of the game, they're allowed to do that? they certainly don't have to, but the consideration that they might, and discussion of how they might go about it and what design elements or values cause that "sticking the knife in the toaster" moment could be valuable and should exist?
 

Remove ads

Top