TSR TSR Era D&D, Shared Experiences

Later Basic line modules variously were introduced sometimes in support of the later new intro sets and some were set in the mini setting of Thunder Rift which was mostly not explicitly connected to Mystara at all, and sometimes continuing the BECMI/Mystara lines (the DDA and DA lines of modules for instance).
Thunder Rift is an odd duck. It's a mini setting designed for the All New Dungeons and Dragons game and explicitly only went to 5th level. It was deliberately vague on certain elements (like religion) so it could be placed anywhere. A single module called Escape from Thunder Rift let you leave the Rift and end up in Karameikos as a graduation from AND&D to the Rules Cyclopedia. That has made some people unofficially place it in Mystara, but in an isolated area either in the KW or elsewhere on the planet, possible as the titular escape is done via portal. I personally would place in outside the KW but on Mystara, but I guess that's DM choice.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Yup. ENCHANTED creatures. Undead, especially incorporeal undead are certainly enchanted. Created by magic and all that. After all, Xorn aren't summoned either.
This is an interesting rules question.

From the 1e PH under protection form evil it says:

The protection encircles the recipient at a one foot
distance, thus preventing bodily contact by creatures of an enchanted or conjured
nature such as aerial servants, demons, devils, djinn, efreet, elementals, imps,
invisible stalkers, night hags, quasits, salamanders, water weirds, wind walkers,
and xorn. Summoned animals or monsters are similarly hedged from the
protected creature.

The listed creatures, including the xorn, are all extraplanar and normally enter the prime by being conjured. Some could enter on their own by a portal, but normally extraplanar stuff is on other planes.

The 1e DMG special hidden rules on spells does not clarify the enchanted creature definition.

The 1e MM has an interesting note in the ghouls section

"The magic circle of protection from evil actually keeps these monsters completely at bay."

Which indicates this is a change from what you would expect from the spell.

Then again in the ghast section it says:

"The circle of protection from evil does not keep them at bay unless it is used in conjunction with cold iron (such as a circle of powdered iron, an iron ring, etc.)."

Which seems to indicate that they are similar to ghouls but more powerful, so for the PFE exception to apply it needs a little extra oomph from cold iron.

Shadows are similarly called out as specifically blocked by PFE: "a protection from evil will keep them at a distance."

No other undead (groaning spirit, ghost, lich, mummy, skeleton, spectre, vampire, wight, wraith, zombie) mention protection from evil affecting them.

Enchanted creatures originally in the Basic line in Moldvay were defined as "The spell will also keep out hand-to-hand attacks from enchanted (summoned or created) monsters (such as living statues)," for me at the time I was running 1e I was very familiar with B/X Basic as well, this might have fed into my interpretation of it when I was Dming.

I interpreted enchanted as being something like a golem, homunculus, a skeleton, or a zombie, a magically created creature or something currently enchanted (such as the permanent duration animate dead). Undead also do not seem similar to the 1e listed extraplanar creatures. I did not think it worked against generally magical creatures like dragons or nymphs or pixies. So I never interpreted undead as enchanted creatures for protection from evil spells except for things like skeletons or zombies animated by an animate dead spell or as specifically called out in their individual MM entry.

AD&D 2e changed the wording of protection from evil to narrow what was covered.

"Third, the spell prevents bodily contact by creatures of an extraplanar or conjured nature (such as aerial servants, elementals, imps, invisible stalkers, salamanders, water weirds, xorn, and others)."

In 2e it is clear it does not prevent contact with magical creatures unless they are extraplanar or conjured or specifically called out as such in their monstrous compendium entries (ghoul and ghasts keep that call out in their MC1 entries, shadows lose that call out).

However in the BECMI Basic set the Basic rules definition of enchanted creatures in protection from evil changed to in many ways widen it:

"In addition, "enchanted" creatures cannot even touch the cleric! If a magic weapon is needed to hit a creature, that creature is called "enchanted." However, a creature that can be hit by a silver weapon — a lycanthrope (were-creature), for example — is not an "enchanted" creature. Any creature which is magically summoned or controlled (such as a Charmed character) is also considered to be an "enchanted" creature."

So all wraiths and higher undead will be blocked but not wights or ghouls, zombies or skeletons unless they are magically controlled such as the control an animate dead spell grants the caster over animated zombies and skeletons.

late in the B/X line you get the Rules Cyclopedia which lists in their monster entries whether a creature is enchanted or not and things like vampires and spectres are listed as enchanted creatures so subject to protection from evil. The protection from evil spell keeps the BECMI redefinition: "An enchanted creature is one that normal weapons will not affect, one which only magical weapons can hit. A creature that can only be hit by a silver weapon—a werewolf, for example—is not an enchanted creature. Any creature that is magically summoned or controlled, such as a charmed character, is also considered to be an enchanted creature." Interestingly wights which can be hit by silver weapons are listed as being enchanted. Ghouls are not listed as being enchanted creatures. Skeletons and zombies are. Shadows are enchanted creatures, but throughout the Basic line they are specifically not undead while in AD&D they are undead.
 
Last edited:

I started in the late 80s, and my group rarely used modules. So I have none of the nostalgia for those old modules.
I started in the mid 80s, and was pretty young. I was terrible at running modules. As a result, most of the modules I have nostalgia for don't occur until after 2e came out and I got better at running them. I wouldn't develop a love of the classics until I was an adult. I know I ran Temple of Elemental Evil back in the day, but my love of Village of Hommlet wouldn't develop until the 2010s.
 

Thunder Rift is an odd duck. It's a mini setting designed for the All New Dungeons and Dragons game and explicitly only went to 5th level. It was deliberately vague on certain elements (like religion) so it could be placed anywhere. A single module called Escape from Thunder Rift let you leave the Rift and end up in Karameikos as a graduation from AND&D to the Rules Cyclopedia. That has made some people unofficially place it in Mystara, but in an isolated area either in the KW or elsewhere on the planet, possible as the titular escape is done via portal. I personally would place in outside the KW but on Mystara, but I guess that's DM choice.
I bought and read Thunder Rift about two years ago. It is quite odd, in trying to be an introductory everything setting in a smallish contained valley.

When I realized the hydrology was nonsensical or at least highly unlikely - rivers splitting rather than flowing together as a tributary entering a large river, and one river that split off as a distributary of an east flowing river to flow north to join a different east flowing river - I decided “and for that reason, I’m out”.
 

I really rather like Thunder Rift, I'm unconcerned about the rivers and if it ever became a problem I'd just make alterations. It's otherwise a fun little intro setting with some nice simple adventures, I actually ran a little 5e campaign in it during covid which was largely just a string of adventures with a chance to buy some gear in between, it was fun.
 

So all wraiths and higher undead will be blocked but not wights or ghouls, zombies or skeletons unless they are magically controlled such as the control an animate dead spell grants the caster over animated zombies and skeletons.
Heh, this is probably where our interpretation came from. :p
 

The Companions of the Lance are a famous example of adult PCs having years of backstory and prior adventures. As the first book starts they're (mostly) joining back up after a five year separation of going on individual quests.


Oh yeah. :) I had Mentzer sheets and graph paper photographed at public coin-op copy machines or at dad's office, and then once we got a PC with printer at home, I started making my own sheets using the word processor.
The Companions start at 5th level as well. I mean, Raistlin is pretty famous for having passed his test of wizardy. These really, really weren't new characters.
 

The Companions start at 5th level as well. I mean, Raistlin is pretty famous for having passed his test of wizardy. These really, really weren't new characters.
Well, yes and no. They were literally brand new characters. The creators just started them off as grown-up, established adventurers. They also had histories/backgrounds with interpersonal relationship drama and trauma in addition to their prior adventuring.
 

The Companions start at 5th level as well. I mean, Raistlin is pretty famous for having passed his test of wizardy. These really, really weren't new characters.

Well, yes and no. They were literally brand new characters. The creators just started them off as grown-up, established adventurers. They also had histories/backgrounds with interpersonal relationship drama and trauma in addition to their prior adventuring.
I think it's apples and oranges to compare the RULES D&D, and the LITERATURE D&D. Yes, they started with backstories and between level 3-5 (in DL1), but that was to fit the story. It's also true that in the rules of the game, it was more of the norm to start at level 1 without much of a backstory. I know this is anecdotal, but it wasn't until the novels took off (both Dragonlance and FR with Drizz't) that players started emulating that in the games, creating PCs with cool backstories that would fit into one of those novels.
 

I think it's apples and oranges to compare the RULES D&D, and the LITERATURE D&D. Yes, they started with backstories and between level 3-5 (in DL1), but that was to fit the story. It's also true that in the rules of the game, it was more of the norm to start at level 1 without much of a backstory. I know this is anecdotal, but it wasn't until the novels took off (both Dragonlance and FR with Drizz't) that players started emulating that in the games, creating PCs with cool backstories that would fit into one of those novels.
Maybe so. We know some folks (like Lee Gold's crew in LA) started messing around with more character-centric play as early as '75, an it's a pretty logical thing to do if you're coming into the hobby from SF&F fandom culture rather than gamer culture. Whether people bothered with character backgrounds or histories for new characters really seems like it was a question of the local culture of play.

For context, remember I was responding to the claim that "1/2E D&D had the generic idea that the PC were new and fresh out of school/training and did not know everything about the world. A far cry from the 5E 'everyone is an expert on everything'."

I don't think things have actually changed that much, in that department. A first level Fighter in AD&D, like in OD&D, is a "Veteran"; tougher, more skillful and experienced than a regular soldier. Not a newb apprentice. A 1st level M-U may be merely a "Prestidigitator", but starts out with a minimum age of 26 and an average age of 33 in 1st Ed. Almost none of them are kids, even though a human fighter starts age 16-19 (every other class starts at least 18, and Illusionists over 30).

Both 1E and 5E assume that adventurers are broadly competent. Part of the reason 1E doesn't have a skill system is that it's assuming that adventurers generally know how to do practical stuff like traveling and orienteering and exploring.
 

Remove ads

Top