TSR TSR Era D&D, Shared Experiences

Maybe so. We know some folks (like Lee Gold's crew in LA) started messing around with more character-centric play as early as '75, an it's a pretty logical thing to do if you're coming into the hobby from SF&F fandom culture rather than gamer culture. Whether people bothered with character backgrounds or histories for new characters really seems like it was a question of the local culture of play.

For context, remember I was responding to the claim that "1/2E D&D had the generic idea that the PC were new and fresh out of school/training and did not know everything about the world. A far cry from the 5E 'everyone is an expert on everything'."

I don't think things have actually changed that much, in that department. A first level Fighter in AD&D, like in OD&D, is a "Veteran"; tougher, more skillful and experienced than a regular soldier. Not a newb apprentice. A 1st level M-U may be merely a "Prestidigitator", but starts out with a minimum age of 26 and an average age of 33 in 1st Ed. Almost none of them are kids, even though a human fighter starts age 16-19 (every other class starts at least 18, and Illusionists over 30).

Both 1E and 5E assume that adventurers are broadly competent. Part of the reason 1E doesn't have a skill system is that it's assuming that adventurers generally know how to do practical stuff like traveling and orienteering and exploring.
This is true, especially when comparing a level 1 PC to the 1e commoner stat ;)
 

log in or register to remove this ad


The Companions start at 5th level as well. I mean, Raistlin is pretty famous for having passed his test of wizardy. These really, really weren't new characters.
Though Dragonlance is already a low magic world.....plus the pre War of the Lance time frame is even lower magic: few wizards, no dragons, no clerics.

And poor Raistlin finds fireball so 'powerful' of a spell and is thrilled when Fizban teaches it to him (and then he goes from 5th level to epic 20th level in the last couple pages of the trilogy)
 


I bought and read Thunder Rift about two years ago. It is quite odd, in trying to be an introductory everything setting in a smallish contained valley.

When I realized the hydrology was nonsensical or at least highly unlikely - rivers splitting rather than flowing together as a tributary entering a large river, and one river that split off as a distributary of an east flowing river to flow north to join a different east flowing river - I decided “and for that reason, I’m out”.
I didn't have a problem with the split, but the rest of the hydrology was bonkers. I think I may have changed it, but then again, I was 18 and just wanted to run a campaign there. So, we may have handwaved the whole situation.

I remember having more of a problem with how the waterfall could be heard through the "entire" valley! That was definitely removed.
 


Though Dragonlance is already a low magic world.....plus the pre War of the Lance time frame is even lower magic: few wizards, no dragons, no clerics.

And poor Raistlin finds fireball so 'powerful' of a spell and is thrilled when Fizban teaches it to him (and then he goes from 5th level to epic 20th level in the last couple pages of the trilogy)
Only because they cut so much out to make it fit into 3 books. A whole lot more stuff went on, which is detailed in the modules and in The Lost Chronicles books (which are read in between the original chronicles for best continuity--Dragons of the Hourglass Mage specifically). Fistandantilus was responsible for much of that power after his Test, explaining his rapid increase in power.
 

I think it's apples and oranges to compare the RULES D&D, and the LITERATURE D&D. Yes, they started with backstories and between level 3-5 (in DL1), but that was to fit the story. It's also true that in the rules of the game, it was more of the norm to start at level 1 without much of a backstory. I know this is anecdotal, but it wasn't until the novels took off (both Dragonlance and FR with Drizz't) that players started emulating that in the games, creating PCs with cool backstories that would fit into one of those novels.
Sorry, but isn't that backwards? The game came first and then they wrote the stories. The novels were novelizations of the modules, not the other way around.
 

I think experience and how you played the game depends when you got into it. Most of people i know, got into 2ed ad&d after playing crpg versions of the game and reading novels. So naturally, they tended to run it more like that. Also, modules and their availability wasn't the same across the globe. They were more USA thing, while people in continental Europe were from the start pretty much homebrew/diy oriented.
 

Ten foot poles.
Literally everybody took ten foot poles into dungeons. They were useful, but not THAT useful.
It's funny to think about people trying to navigate in the world carrying a 10' pole. I have a 6' bo staff IRL and it's a pain in the neck to take anywhere, it gets caught on stuff, it's hard to get into my car...adding four feet and going underground just sounds exasperating.
 

Remove ads

Top