Last week I read two short primary sources on the conquest of the Inca Empire and Inca religion. The former was
An Inca Account of the Conquest of Peru by Titu Cusi Yupanqui, one of the final Inca Emperors. The latter was
An Account of the Ancient Customs of the Natives of Peru by Blas Valera, an early mestizo Jesuit priest that was imprisoned and tortured by his own order for wanting to translate Catholic religious terms into indigenous languages. Primary sources are a mix of fun and extremely frustrating, because about half the book is invaluable firsthand knowledge of historical events, while the other half is politically motivated lies. And it can be difficult to tell the two apart. Titu Cusi Yupanqui "quoted" word for word long speeches that were given before or shortly after his birth. And Blas Valera made a lot of comparisons between Inca religion and Catholic and ancient Roman practices. Sometimes it was simply discussing similarities, like calling the
acllas "vestal virgins" or "nuns." Other times, it was insisting the Inca worshipped Mercury as a god of travel and trade and Mars as a god of war.
I would not recommend them unless you're as interested in Inca history as I am.
And today I finished reading
Fifth Sun: A New History of the Aztecs by Camilla Townsend. On the whole it was an excellent narrative of Aztec history and politics. The basic way Mesoamerican politics worked was through a complex web of intermarrying royal families from different city states, where each king had dozens of wives, but only the sons of his primary wife could inherit land. The Aztecs managed to manipulate the system so they were able to take power from the Tepanecs and form the largest empire Mesoamerica had ever seen. But, in the process, they also created disgruntled, landless princes that took the sides of the Spaniards when they arrived.
I highly recommend. Anyone that wants to understand the Aztecs from an indigenous perspective should read it. And it was a lot more interesting that I thought it would be. And I'm already someone that finds Mesoamerican history interesting.
If this book were used as a reference for an HBO show about Aztec history, the show would rival Game of Thrones or Rome.
However, after you've read a few scholarly books, you develop the ability to tell when the author is speaking of a topic they're deeply familiar with, and when they're out of their depth and engaging in some wild speculation about a topic they don't know much about. The vast majority of this book is material that Townsend clearly knows a lot about. But there are some sections where she engages in Jared Diamond-style arguments about "why Native Americans were technologically inferior," which to me weren't convincing, and didn't really seem necessary to the point of the book. Yeah, of course one side having cavalry and metal armor and the other only being infantry with stone weapons would give the conquistadors an upper hand. I don't think "wheat was domesticated earlier than corn" is a good explanation for why the Aztecs didn't use iron, gunpowder, or cavalry.
And she uses sketchy phrases like "we can assume" or "perhaps they thought" quite a bit. Assuming we know what historical figures that didn't write their stories down were thinking can make for good stories. It doesn't make for good history. I don't think we can assume what La Malinche thought. We simply don't know.
But, even if that leaves a bad taste in my mouth, the book is still excellent.
For my last point, here's a quote Bernal Diaz del Castillo, a conquistador that was with Cortes, about how much the sight of Tenochtitlan shocked him.
"When I beheld the scenes around me, I thought within myself, this was the garden of the world. All of the wonders I beheld that day, nothing now remains. All is overthrown and lost."
I understand the conquistadors were conquerors. Their job was to kill, loot, enslave, and do whatever else was necessary to get gold and glory. They were hardly unique in that regard. But, still, the fact that the conquistadors saw a beautiful, clean city that they themselves said was the coolest place on Earth. They described it as being like something from a fantasy novel. They couldn't believe their eyes. And their first inclination was to destroy it. Montezuma even offered them a regular payment of tribute if they would simply leave Tenochtitlan. But instead Cortes chose to murder the emperor, destroy most of the city during a long, brutal siege (during which the majority of the population died), and began the long, gradual process of eroding their culture.
Conquistadors often played up how cool the lands they conquered were as a way of bragging to the Spanish Crown about how impressive and important their accomplishments were. Or they'd exaggerate the destruction done by other conquistadors as a political move. But it's still incomprehensible for me to imagine showing up in a new, exotic land and seeing the greatest wonders of the New World, and almost immediately deciding to destroy it.
"Not forever on earth, only a little while here." - Nezahualcoyotl, Tlatoani of Texcoco