The Everlasting is a fricking astounding novel. The setting might be kinda conventional--at least at first--but I figure the ... nature of the narrative (avoiding spoilers, here) and the novel's themes (which include the accidental nature of history, as you say) are not entirely mainline for fantasy; but, I don't read a lot of fantasy, so my sense of the genre might be wrong.Read The Everlasting by Alix E Harrow, the only one of this year's Hugo novel nominations I hadn't read, and it's a doozy. I think I may have to change my preference from Death of the Author to this one. Which is a slight pity, because The Everlasting is a much more traditional fantasy novel in a way, cleanly and beautifully written, but it's also very impressive.
Owen Mallory is a historian who desperately seeks to belong in Dominion, a country not unlike Britain just after WW1. He has devoted much of his life to the study of Sir Una Everlasting, a heroine who is central to the creation myth of Dominion. And so when he's sent back in time a couple of thousand years to meet Una and guide her to her death, he's overjoyed and conflicted. And it only gets more complicated from there.
Much of the story is about how history is a pile of accidents, and it doesn't tell a story until you make it do so. And who is free, who loves another?
Also, Harrow's other novels are also all well within range of this one, quality-wise, if you haven't read them.








