6E Theory What criticism will 6e react to?

Musings about what 6E would be like, hypothetically.
The cheapest things to do to make D&D more like Daggerheart are 1) Separate character sheets for each class, 2) Print subclass abilities, invocations, and feats (etc) on individual cards (they already have spell cards), and 3) Put those in a box set with the PHB as the default way of purchasing it.

Perhaps they could make this more feasible if they only put like levels 1-12 in the PHB, and had a separate book of options for later levels (or even put many of these "paragon paths" in the setting books they're appropriate for).
Have you seen the most recent beginner's box:
1793815086080.png
 

log in or register to remove this ad

I don't think the "core" books work that way conceptually. At least to me. I see the core as universal. So I'd present a very simple set of options in the core and then have splat books. By default most DMs say splat books are not allowed unless approved. Now I'm taking a knife to the game every time I play it. I'm never allowing 25 playable races in my campaign setting.
IMO, "core" is a terrible concept. To me the essence of D&D is homebrew. No rule is "core," everything is up for negotiation and modification. Otherwise - play a computer game!
 


It seems to me that every possible species should be included in the books. Then the DM and group decided which species to include in their particular campaign. I don't see why having it the book should be a problem.
Because there's only so much page count and design effort to put in at one time. According to a quick google search, there are 58 species allowed in Adventurer's League Forgotten Realms campaigns (which is more than I thought, I would have guessed 40), and 183 species total across all books. That's way too much to include in the core book, especially when a lot of those are extremely obscure or are very setting specific (like the Eberron version of elves).

I'm a big fan of variety, but trying to cram 183 species either requires too much of the 384 pages in the PHB or ends up making them mechanically indistinct. It's also going to be absolutely overwhelming for a new player to get a handle on, that's way more options than needed to hit analysis paralysis.
 

Because there's only so much page count and design effort to put in at one time. According to a quick google search, there are 58 species allowed in Adventurer's League Forgotten Realms campaigns (which is more than I thought, I would have guessed 40), and 183 species total across all books. That's way too much to include in the core book, especially when a lot of those are extremely obscure or are very setting specific (like the Eberron version of elves).

I'm a big fan of variety, but trying to cram 183 species either requires too much of the 384 pages in the PHB or ends up making them mechanically indistinct. It's also going to be absolutely overwhelming for a new player to get a handle on, that's way more options than needed to hit analysis paralysis.
My word "possible" was doing a lot of work in my statement! I obviously don't think it is realistic to put all species in the PHB. But I have toyed with the idea that the PHB on has humans and points to the "Book of Species" for all others.
 

I don't think the "core" books work that way conceptually. At least to me. I see the core as universal. So I'd present a very simple set of options in the core and then have splat books. By default most DMs say splat books are not allowed unless approved. Now I'm taking a knife to the game every time I play it. I'm never allowing 25 playable races in my campaign setting.


I would never make that offer. And I'd never have continued as that groups DM if they came with those characters. We want different things and we aren't going to be compatible. In my groups, they all played dwarves and elves even when new stuff came out. Now when it comes to classes, I did battle that stuff some. To the degree I feel like I failed to hold the line there, I really feel the game was lessened. Not ruined but lessened.

25 playable races is good. But opt in pick the ones you like.

I normally spotlight races whatever makes sense for campaign theme. Very little is banned more flyers and specific campaign stuff where its inappropriate eg aquatic race Darksun.
 


I think that it's time for WotC to consider having several lines of D&D to support both.

Maybe DnD and Pathfinder should switch which one goes storytelling and which one goes crunchy tactical every edition and let the fans decide :p

I don't know. Have you ever heard of this little game called Magic: The Gathering? WotC supports different product lines and game modes under that brand, catering to different audiences and playstyles. I'm not suggesting the business models are identical, but the idea that a brand has to be tied to one uniform gaming experience doesn't exactly reflect WotC's own history.

And D&D itself used to support Basic and Advanced D&D as separate, concurrent product lines. This isn't even an entirely new idea for the franchise. And before anyone brings up TSR's eventual financial collapse, I don't think maintaining separate Basic and Advanced D&D lines was what broke the bank. TSR had plenty of other problems, and I don't think the mere existence of multiple D&D rulesets is a particularly convincing explanation for its downfall.
It's still the same game, it's just different deck building rules.
 



Remove ads

Top