6E Theory What criticism will 6e react to?

Musings about what 6E would be like, hypothetically.
I get why you and others suggest this, but I want to point out the logic behind your suggestion. First, I need to undertake extensive effort for others. I then need to hope that that extensive effort--at some indeterminate point--will inspire at least one of them to take up that effort themselves. I then further need to hope that that person specifically elects to run the same system I used, invite me to their table, and offer a campaign that I want to join. I then have to hope that that person is a good GM for the system, and the group lasts long enough to get a solid campaign in.

So...you're asking me to put months to years of work into a project that might produce fruit, which might be the kind of fruit I'm looking for, and which I might be allowed to eat, and which might taste good, and might continue to be edible for a while after.

Do you see how this is not a particularly tempting suggestion? The amount of "possibly" in this is extensive, and at least one of the steps is of quite low probability (inspiring another person to GM). So, I have to invest probably years of my life into maybe possibly someday not having to be a Forever GM, even though being a Forever GM is notoriously common, on the relatively low chance that the stars will align and then, only then, get to play.

I'm really not seeing the upside on this. I have said as much to others, albeit in shorter terms, because I've heard this suggestion dozens if not hundreds of times. My response remains unchanged: That's a ludicrous thing to ask of me.
Only you you can determine the cost / benefit analysis for you. Most of your issue seems to be the situation for any DM, so as a forever DM it seems like a pretty normal / typical investment with little to no downside. You see it differently - and that is OK. I wasn't telling you to do it, just asking if you considered it. It seems you a have and it is no for - no worries!
I don't mean to be flippant, but this feels like an attempt to say, congenially, "Cool story bro, didn't ask." Given you furnished me with this information by starting with "Then you must be a fan of 5e24!", it would seem you do care what I think. What would be the point of telling me otherwise?
I was being a bit sarcastic as I know you don't like 5e. However, I thought you might want to know your information (on this topic) was outdated.

I will admit I am drawn to your post like a moth to a flame. Your experiences with D&D are so different from my own I can't help but watch, and then sometimes respond! It probably doesn't hurt the your tone is typically so authoritarian that I often have a reflexive reaction to your posts. I do truly feel sorry for the experiences you have had playing D&D, I honestly can't imagine myself staying with the hobby if my experience was like yours.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

I will admit I am drawn to your post like a moth to a flame. Your experiences with D&D are so different from my own I can't help but watch, and then sometimes respond! It probably doesn't hurt the your tone is typically so authoritarian that I often have a reflexive reaction to your posts. I do truly feel sorry for the experiences you have had playing D&D, I honestly can't imagine myself staying with the hobby if my experience was like yours.
If you do truly sympathize with his plight, then why not help him by playing some 4E with him? I once hosted a 4E game for them and i can do it again if we get some more players!!
 


Only you you can determine the cost / benefit analysis for you. Most of your issue seems to be the situation for any DM, so as a forever DM it seems like a pretty normal / typical investment with little to no downside. You see it differently - and that is OK. I wasn't telling you to do it, just asking if you considered it. It seems you a have and it is no for - no worries!
It is worth noting that I do GM two games now, they just aren't using 4e. I had had much more play-experience with a different system (Dungeon World), and it's a lighter system. I thought it smart to go with something I was deep in the weeds with, especially since half my players had never touched a TTRPG before.

I was being a bit sarcastic as I know you don't like 5e. However, I thought you might want to know your information (on this topic) was outdated.
And I appreciate the correction.

I will admit I am drawn to your post like a moth to a flame. Your experiences with D&D are so different from my own I can't help but watch, and then sometimes respond! It probably doesn't hurt the your tone is typically so authoritarian that I often have a reflexive reaction to your posts. I do truly feel sorry for the experiences you have had playing D&D, I honestly can't imagine myself staying with the hobby if my experience was like yours.
I'm...not sure what makes my posts "authoritarian". I personally have a strong antipathy for anything authoritarian whatsoever. That's part of why I have such a distaste for this glorious era of "GM empowerment"; that is what strikes me as authoritarian. A GM explicitly empowered to do whatever they want, whenever they want, for as long as they want--isn't that what an authoritarian leader is?

As for staying with the hobby, I'm sort of stubborn like that. Having a bad experience doesn't preclude the possibility of having a good one in the future; instead, it puts the onus on me to increase the odds of having a good one. It also helps that I have had good experiences with other things, so...it's a lot easier to point the finger at one specific issue, namely the edition du jour, rather than blaming the activity entire.
 


As for staying with the hobby, I'm sort of stubborn like that. Having a bad experience doesn't preclude the possibility of having a good one in the future; instead, it puts the onus on me to increase the odds of having a good one. It also helps that I have had good experiences with other things, so...it's a lot easier to point the finger at one specific issue, namely the edition du jour, rather than blaming the activity entire.
FYI, @MichaelSomething suggest they might be willing to run a 4e game for you. If it happens I am willing to join in the fun!
 
Last edited:

I'm...not sure what makes my posts "authoritarian". I personally have a strong antipathy for anything authoritarian whatsoever. That's part of why I have such a distaste for this glorious era of "GM empowerment"; that is what strikes me as authoritarian. A GM explicitly empowered to do whatever they want, whenever they want, for as long as they want--isn't that what an authoritarian leader is?
I am happy to explain in more detail, but I would prefer to do it as a DM. Just let me know if your are interested.
 

I'm very much of the philosophy a DM should create a campaign and then recruit players for it. That doesn't mean the DM can't get feedback from previous campaigns and just scuttlebut at the local game store but ultimately he has to be passionate about the setting. If not it can't be saved.

My theory to.

Heres the campaign/pitch. Recruit to fit.

Or one shot starter sets give them a few options for stuff you like. If theyre not into it 0 players.
 

I think trying to proscribe how a DM should put together a campaign gets a bit silly. There's nothing wrong with someone making a campaign world then recruiting players, or pitching a campaign idea to an existing group, or recruiting some new players into an existing campaign world, or playing a few one shots then deciding to turn it into a campaign, or finding a bunch of people who's schedules line up then decide about campaign, or pretty much any other order of making the decisions. The idea that everyone should follow the same strict pattern for order of operations on organizing a game is pretty foreign to me.
 

I think trying to proscribe how a DM should put together a campaign gets a bit silly. There's nothing wrong with someone making a campaign world then recruiting players, or pitching a campaign idea to an existing group, or recruiting some new players into an existing campaign world, or playing a few one shots then deciding to turn it into a campaign, or finding a bunch of people who's schedules line up then decide about campaign, or pretty much any other order of making the decisions. The idea that everyone should follow the same strict pattern for order of operations on organizing a game is pretty foreign to me.

I think most here are describing THEIR way. No one cares what everyone else is doing. We are just saying "I like this way and think it is best for me."

I don't think the game could proscribe this if they wanted to.
 

Remove ads

Top