So I just purchased a copy of Alternate Realities Publications'
Big Bang: The Mostly Illustrated RPG Guide to Firearms Vol 1 (affiliate link), and I'll admit that I'm pretty impressed.
To quickly recap, this is a gun book, written not only for the Cyberthriller RPG (the publisher's house system, which I believe was never actually released), but also for d20 Modern, Fudge, and the Action! System. However, this is far,
far more than a simple list of weapon stats for your games. It's clear that whoever wrote this book is a serious gun enthusiast, as each entry not only has a table with system-agnostic real-world information (for things like the gun's country of origin, year of release, caliber, accuracy, rate of fire, range, magazine size, and more), but also has an overview of each weapon that's several paragraphs in length. And, as the title says, most of them have a picture.
Needless to say, anyone who enjoys guns recreationally will get a huge kick out of this, even if you don't care for the game statistics. For instance, I'd never heard of the
2mm Kolibri before (which shot the smallest centerfire cartridge of any gun ever made). A word of warning, however, is that the "Vol. 1" in the title is not for show; there's apparently something like ten books in this series, along with several supplements for things like military vehicles and other areas of weaponry. It's a pretty intense series.
From a rules perspective, I can only speak to d20 Modern, but I can't help but comment on a new rule introduced here, called "blowthrough." Apparently the author couldn't stand how the cover rules worked in standard d20 Modern, and so invented this rule to make cover more realistic. The way it works is that you add three Blowthrough (Bf) values together: the first is based on the caliber of the bullet fired (from the table on page 17), the second is the type of bullet (e.g. full metal jacket, armor piercing,
tracers, etc.), and the third is the type of material that you're shooting through (page 18). When you add these together, you have the final value, and if you roll
under that on a d20 then you shoot through the material, essentially negating the cover.
So if your character is firing a gun using 5.56mm NATO rounds (Bf 8) which are full metal jacket (also BF 8) at someone taking cover behind a solid wood door (Bf -4), then you need to roll under a 12 to ignore cover, denying them any bonus for being behind the door.
Now, I like this level of verisimilitude and the level of tactical engagement that it offers, but I can't ignore that there are a few issues here. One, this d20 roll is apparently made separate from your attack roll (or any other roll, for that matter), which is going to slow things down some. Second, rolling below a target number is counterintuitive in any iteration of the d20 System, where you always want to roll higher numbers. Third, there's a small discrepancy in the rules here; it says you want to roll under the final Blowthrough value, meaning that rolling the same number would be a failure, yet a few paragraphs after it says "roll under" it mentions that "if the final Blowthrough factor is 20 or greater, it will automatically blow through the cover material," which is a bit confusing since it makes it sound like a Blowthrough of 20 represents an unbeatable value...yet if you only have to roll under to succeed, you could still fail if you get a natural 20 against a Blowthrough value of 20.
In other words, the rules contradict themselves as to whether a d20 roll whose result is exactly the same as the Bf value is a success or a failure. GMs take note if you decide to use this system.
That said, these aren't very big marks against the supplement itself, which seems to be aware that greater complexity is the price of greater representation of real-world salient factors in the game, and seems fine with it. Personally, I'm glad to have the option, and think that this is a pretty cool book overall. A member of my group is a vet, and I'm planning on printing out a
personal copy of this for him for a holiday gift. I'm sure he'll love it.