D&D General What is "mechanical complexity" doing?

And as it turns out, some (a lot) of players find one infinity of possibilities to be enough, and don't wan't to add another layer of complexity on top of that (eg, rules mastery).

That goes both ways, honestly - there's a goodly number of rules mastery folks who don't want GM's to have much of a hand in otherwise.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Mechanical complexity is like building a game out of Lego.

It's work to put it together. You have to go step by step. Sometimes you follow the instructions to build exactly what you see on the box, and sometimes you take all the pieces from decades of different themed sets to build something the world has never seen before. Some people love the process of building as much as the like playing with the toys. Some people love the process of building more than they like playing with the toy (and that's okay, too).

When everyone builds with Lego and then brings their builds together, everyone has toys that you know are interactive, interchangeable, and fungible. And in the end, it's just really friggin' satisfying to have a giant Lego [thing] that you can admire, play with, or constantly rebuild.

Conversely, the Rule of Cool is building a game out of drawings. Anyone can sketch whatever they want on their own sheet of paper. But that also means there's nothing inherent that makes the drawings fit together. People may have completely different styles, skills, scales, systems, color, or techniques of drawing. And that's okay. But it's not the same as having a common base like using Lego.

Lego gives the game form, function, and (optionally) theme. It's a form of communication. It gives the game an inherent level of structure and discipline.

And Lego is fun. Personally, I like Lego, and I like drawing. But I like playing with Lego more.
 

That goes both ways, honestly - there's a goodly number of rules mastery folks who don't want GM's to have much of a hand in otherwise.
This is probably a 3e/PF vs OSR divide. We don't need a rule for everything in OSR. The DM/GM can just make a decision and offer a DC to be beat. Such an approach leads to far simpler rules.
 


Not only that, but you get us to a start of a point - Mearls is... wrong.

There is not a simple divide: complex vs simple. Specifically - the player cares very much about what is complex, and in no way do we all agree about where we want to see complexity.

And this is where we see in 4e how Mearls is wrong - 4e isn't simple! It puts its core complexities in places that Mearls (and presumably many others) don't care about, or personally find easy to manage.
Expanding outside of D&D, there are games like Champions/Hero System which are known for complexity -- but only in highly compartmented sections (most notably character creation) with much of the day-to-day play of the system being to-hits and comparing damage or effect to resistance (or skill checks with chart-based modifiers) regardless of the ability or activity. Compare that to something like Aftermath which thrives on moment to moment complexity, and suddenly the question of which game is complex (to say nothing of whether people find a given complexity manageable) a, well, rather complex question.
This is probably a 3e/PF vs OSR divide. We don't need a rule for everything in OSR. The DM/GM can just make a decision and offer a DC to be beat. Such an approach leads to far simpler rules.
Good highlight of multiple forms of complexity.

Spinning off from that, one can argue back and forth which of AD&D and 3e/PF are more complex -- is a convoluted character creation model with more systematic rules more complex; or a game with few character creation decisions but a whole bunch of non-similar exception-based situational rules.
 
Last edited:

Rule of Cool can easily apply to lego builds as it is by nature rules agnostic.

I can see you've never had to help a 5 year old navigate the evils of being gifted a knock-off brand Lego of an IP they love, and the emotional damage of coming to terms with the horrors hidden in those low quality bricks. Unfortunately, there's nothing about the Rule of Cool that can help those scars. Its just empty platitudes, my friend.

 

Good highlight of multiple forms of complexity. Likewise, though, one can argue back and forth which of AD&D and 3e/PF are more complex.
I think OSR has come to mean simpler gaming because a lot of it goes back to BECMI or B/X. I agree 1e was fairly complex because everything was a table. The actual choices you made though as you advanced your character even in 1e were fairly simple. So most players could dump the rest of the responsibility on the DM.
 

Mearls draws a divide between players looking for complexity in the mechanical interactions, and players who don't want to engage with game mechanics at all, preferring to stay largely or entirely in a conversational mode with the GM, and goes on to claim 4e was designed for the latter, to the dismay of the former, and the modern problem is trying to add this mechanical complexity for players who want it, without stepping on the player who wants to just say "I swing my sword" in his words.
Huh. I wouldn't call 4e a game in "conversational mode." ::activates encounter power to slide two squares to the next quote::

My ultimate point; this isn't actually reconcilable. The best you can do is a short equilibrium, until the "complex" players hit the limits of your current decision space and leave, or you can break it the other way and hope your "simple" players don't notice they aren't strategically relevant or become "complex" players through exposure.
Reconcilable? No. Compromisable? Yes. Judging by the density of 5.5e character sheets and the Free Rules, WotC gave up on the conversationalists.
 

I think OSR has come to mean simpler gaming because a lot of it goes back to BECMI or B/X. I agree 1e was fairly complex because everything was a table. The actual choices you made though as you advanced your character even in 1e were fairly simple. So most players could dump the rest of the responsibility on the DM.
Right, sorry, I was attempting to delineate 1E as a tangential category distinct from OSR. I will see if I can edit that into my response.
 

This is probably a 3e/PF vs OSR divide.

Yes, but no.

Meaning, you can probably see what I am talking about manifesting across that divide, yes. But that's because the design philosophies of each happen to serve differing needs that already existed.

We don't need a rule for everything in OSR.

Several other game sub-cultures don't need a rule for everything - indeed, most of narrative gaming doesn't need a rule for everything, either. The OSR doesn't own this and didn't invent it.

Players are complicated. We each have our own idiosyncratic set of needs, some of which are orthogonal to each other, others which are in tension/competition.

The OSR manages to serve a not-uncommon set of needs/desires, but it serves many needs, and is not the only way gaming has found to serve any one of them.

The needs/desires are the important, pre-existing thing. Our current common design styles and gaming culture tribalisms are not great proxies for the needs.
 

Remove ads

Top