D&D 5E (2024) What would be most fun to play "Single Class, 4 Characters" Party?


log in or register to remove this ad

I have a hard time picturing an all-rogue party (a classic going back to the 1970s) covering all roles.
Actually we did this in AD&D.
The only changes I remember is that one. Could brew poisons and potions, one recipe a level, and another was able to read 1st level scrolls without issue. One was thug focused on back stabbing and the other was a catburgler.

Maybe 2ed.
 


Actually we did this in AD&D.
The only changes I remember is that one. Could brew poisons and potions, one recipe a level, and another was able to read 1st level scrolls without issue. One was thug focused on back stabbing and the other was a catburgler.

Maybe 2ed.
Adding healing and making spellcasting easier are pretty huge changes for AD&D thieves, so I think we're agreeing here that it's hard to do RAW in AD&D.
 

Adding healing and making spellcasting easier are pretty huge changes for AD&D thieves, so I think we're agreeing here that it's hard to do RAW in AD&D.
The 2e Handbooks I think all had some advice on how to handle these kind of all the same parties. There was the assumption of not just running generic adventures but instead making the adventures thematic for that type of party. So an all Thief party would be stuff like pulling off the great heist.

No doubt some of this was partly a way to balance things, but also let's be real if we are making an all Rogue party, having the adventure not be themed in some manner would be a let down.
 

No doubt some of this was partly a way to balance things, but also let's be real if we are making an all Rogue party, having the adventure not be themed in some manner would be a let down.
100%. If your players all make a single class (or a single ancestry or a single background), they are sending a very strong signal about what they want to happen in the game.
 

The 2e Handbooks I think all had some advice on how to handle these kind of all the same parties. There was the assumption of not just running generic adventures but instead making the adventures thematic for that type of party. So an all Thief party would be stuff like pulling off the great heist.

No doubt some of this was partly a way to balance things, but also let's be real if we are making an all Rogue party, having the adventure not be themed in some manner would be a let down.

The books had that. Essentially it was each thief specializes in a different skill.
 




Remove ads

Top