D&D 5.5E (2024) What would be most fun to play "Single Class, 4 Characters" Party?

The A-men are coming! I don't know if the Trickery Domain is really that good at what it is supposed to do, it's always been kinda unsatisfying for me, but maybe if you try a short bow build? Cleric is definitely the One Class party with the most power backing it.

Everybody gets a signature instrument. Just for the thematic fun I think Bard is the best pick. It might not be the most powerful team but it'll be a lot of hamming it up and fun moments.

I don't think it would be that bad, between the Eldritch Knight, the Battlemaster, the Samurai, and some choice feats there would be plenty of good skills.

And I'm sure you can just grab Guidance through a feat too.

I agree, I think finding the way to overcome obstacle is the fun bit.

Reminds me of that time in organized play, during the Stradh campaign, our party ended up being like... a Ranger, a Monk, my Fighter and I think... a Rogue? and the module makers thought it was a good idea to send a low level party with unknown composition against a werewolf. We had a single Silvered dagger between us to use so we had to devise this whole dance where we would pass the silver dagger to each other each turn just to inflict damage and my Fighter would use his Protecton Fighting style to defend from the Werewolf's attack. At somepoint the DM just gave up and gave us the win because it was taking forever. In another session we had a Paladin added to the party, but we ended up against damn animated trees that just resisted our attacks and the Paladin was out of slots for Smites. The DM let us set the trees on fire using my lantern oil because the module was clearly not designed for our party composition.

The season sucked for that honestly, really bad design for an organized play... but we did manage to find ways to pull it off.

Clerics best single class party imho. Hard part lvl 1-4 but theyre ahead of most non martials there. Probably best class overall lvl 1-12.

Frontline sits there with spirit guardians. Ones behind them maybe summon stuff

Mass command spam. And some domains have good control spells. All can heal.

They can also come close to martial damage basic builds maybe not optimized ones.

Probably lower on fun though. Youre built around 3-5 spells doing same thing over and over domain depending. Very effective though.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Clerics best single class party imho. Hard part lvl 1-4 but theyre ahead of most non martials there. Probably best class overall lvl 1-12.

Frontline sits there with spirit guardians. Ones behind them maybe summon stuff

Mass command spam. And some domains have good control spells. All can heal.

They can also come close to martial damage basic builds maybe not optimized ones.

Probably lower on fun though. Youre built around 3-5 spells doing same thing over and over domain depending. Very effective though.
That's my impesson as well. Really powerful, but probably pretty repetitive and feels more like a classic party so the 'shenanigans' aspect isn't very strong.
 

That's my impesson as well. Really powerful, but probably pretty repetitive and feels more like a classic party so the 'shenanigans' aspect isn't very strong.

Yeah its really boring tbh.

When we did it BG3 we ended up with 1 typical cleric rest were doing odd stuff.

Death domain was the best beatstick and we had 2 war domain clerics more for control.

Them and fighters were the easiest iirc. Tabletop would replicate most of it bit less crazy BG3 magic items for example.
 

Druids or Wizards

For Druids, Stars, Moon, Forged, Symbiote. All human.

For Wizards:

Evocation, Conjurer, Reborn Bladesinger, Abjurer, Diviner All gnomes.

  1. 4 PCs
  2. All 5.5 material is allowed for character creation or builds
  3. Everyone pick the same class
  4. Everyone picks a different subclass
  5. No multiclassing
 

No, in my case, it came from running and playing in all-thief games in the 1970s under AD&D.

It's a great composition for shenanigans/robbing non-combat NPCs. Also very good in urban settings.

It's a lot harder -- even with 5E subclasses -- to do the stuff that a standard party can do. I wouldn't take a group of all rogues into a dungeon. I wouldn't take them to kill a hostile dragon. I wouldn't use them to take on an undead witch-priest.

I'm not sure why you wouldnt put rogues in a dungeon - their infiltation, trap defusion and scouting seem perfect for dungeoneering.

I'd have the undead witch-priest as a stealth assassination mission, where the party gets in unseen and the Assassin triggers assassinate on the witch-priest using a dagger for nick and rapier for vex, then bonus action to disengage.
The Mastermind hangs back with a crossbow and uses Tactics to boost the Swashbuckler dashing in for a Cunning strike to Trip the Witch-priest prone. With the enemy prone everyone now gets advantage to attack them.
The Arcane Trickster is dealing with any minions - hopefully zombies who are too slow for the high dexterity rogues.

Mastery, cunning strike and uncanny dodge help during the dragon encounter too, though a dragon breath is admittedly a difficult fight for them (or anyone really).

but sure Rogue parties arent optimised for combat, they are all about Skill Expertise, Stealth and Coordination (not to mention chaining advantage)
 

Single class parties are a lot of fun because they can't do it all, and players have to be creative in how they tackle challenges -- and also knowing when some challenges are not realistic and go find something they're more suited to doing.
I think this is the key part. This is the main appeal of a single class party.

Even if you're playing a class who can "do it all" via subclasses, like cleric, as a group you're still going to respond to narrative challenges and opportunities like clerics* (*this statement has not been vetted by the gods of trickery and war), which shapes how you reach and prepare for traditional encounters.
 



Can we be a bit more specific?

Would be curious to see what people do with this thought experiment (a variation on the OP):

Here are 13 classes:
  1. Artificer
  2. Barbarian
  3. Bard
  4. Cleric
  5. Druid
  6. Fighter
  7. Monk
  8. Paladin
  9. Ranger
  10. Rogue
  11. Sorcerer
  12. Warlock
  13. Wizard

Now here are 14 of the D&D 5e Adventure paths. Which adventures would go best with which party of All [class]? (note, I left off Hoard and Rise, because they are combined (and better imho) in Tyranny of Dragons). In my head I'm like each adventure gets ONE class each; and each class gets only ONE adventure each (with one adventure left over). But hey, do what you like.

I don't have an opinion actually on this, but I might noodle on it more anyway.
  1. Princes of the Apocalypse
  2. Out of the Abyss
  3. Curse of Strahd
  4. Storm King's Thunder
  5. Tomb of Annihilation
  6. Waterdeep: Dragon Heist
  7. Waterdeep: Dungeon of the Mad Mage
  8. Baldur's Gate: Descent Into Avernus
  9. Icewind Dale: Rime of the Frostmaiden
  10. The Wild Beyond the Witchlight
  11. Critical Role: Call of the Netherdeep
  12. Tyranny of Dragons
  13. Phandelver and Below: The Shattered Obelisk
  14. Vecna: Eve of Ruin
 

Can we be a bit more specific?

Would be curious to see what people do with this thought experiment (a variation on the OP):

Here are 13 classes:
  1. Artificer
  2. Barbarian
  3. Bard
  4. Cleric
  5. Druid
  6. Fighter
  7. Monk
  8. Paladin
  9. Ranger
  10. Rogue
  11. Sorcerer
  12. Warlock
  13. Wizard

Now here are 14 of the D&D 5e Adventure paths. Which adventures would go best with which party of All [class]? (note, I left off Hoard and Rise, because they are combined (and better imho) in Tyranny of Dragons). In my head I'm like each adventure gets ONE class each; and each class gets only ONE adventure each (with one adventure left over). But hey, do what you like.

I don't have an opinion actually on this, but I might noodle on it more anyway.
  1. Princes of the Apocalypse
  2. Out of the Abyss
  3. Curse of Strahd
  4. Storm King's Thunder
  5. Tomb of Annihilation
  6. Waterdeep: Dragon Heist
  7. Waterdeep: Dungeon of the Mad Mage
  8. Baldur's Gate: Descent Into Avernus
  9. Icewind Dale: Rime of the Frostmaiden
  10. The Wild Beyond the Witchlight
  11. Critical Role: Call of the Netherdeep
  12. Tyranny of Dragons
  13. Phandelver and Below: The Shattered Obelisk
  14. Vecna: Eve of Ruin
I would definitely give SKT to Rangers, although a DM who finished it may have a different opinion. IMO that sandbox is their hole and it was made for them.

edit: complete answers below spoiler text
  1. PotA -- Clerics, sort of a religious detective story
  2. OotA -- Warlocks, but a Gloom Stalker would love it there
  3. Curse of Strahd -- the Survivor class from Van Richten's.
  4. SKT -- Rangers, but Barbarians, Fighters, and Druids would also like the vibe.
  5. ToA -- I confused this with Tomb of Horrors. I'd put Druids here.
  6. Dragon Heist -- why not Rogues? It's Rogues. There might be an argument for Bards?
  7. DotMM -- can you Delicious in Dungeon this adventure? Free Space.
  8. You're doing Paladins a disservice if you don't send them to Avernus
  9. Rime -- Wizards. For reasons, but I can only put spoiler text once I assume
  10. Witchlight -- I saved this one for the Bard players. I wasn't wrong.
  11. Netherdeep -- I think Exandria is a good world for Artificers. Druids could make sense here too.
  12. Tyranny -- I feel like this is a good adventure to be knights, but I'll say Sorcerers because there's a Dragon Queen
  13. Shadow of the Dragon Queen -- I added this one in for the Fighters. This is the war campaign.
  14. Phandelver -- All I know is this has something to do with Goblin politics, so I'm dumping it on the Barbarians. I apologize. I know they wanted SKT. Maybe they can trade with the Ranger if they want.
  15. Vecna -- thematically, Druids vs Undead is pretty classic, but I want more of Dandadan vibes, so I'm sending the Psion. RIP Psion.
Apologies to the Monk. None of these adventures scream, "Monk." Though Exandria does have the Cobalt Soul.
 
Last edited:

Remove ads

Top