When is Rules Lite Too Lite?

I don't think rules are necessarily too lite, but they can be too lite for what you want them to do.

I generally think most lite games that don't have any form of character progress are too lite for long term campaigns, but are often fantastic for one or two session scenarios.

Don't try and force them to do something they aren't designed for and it will be fine.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

I mean, the official Prince Valiant RPG uses flipping coins as its primary resolution mechanic.

Yeah but you have multiple coins depending on skill so it isn't 50-50 which I think was implied.

TWERPS had one stat which served as both hit points and your skill to do any task. I'm sure there is a literal coin flip RPG out there.
 


I absolutely think there are a number of rules light systems out there that are so light they stop being a "game" and are effectively just "role playing" systems.

I am also mildly (but only mildly) surprised by how many people consider it an insult or personal affront to face that fact. People take pride in using theater-of-the-mind instead of a battle map. No one gets offended when you point out that spending hundreds of hours painting minis isn't the same as spending hundreds of hours at the game table. But the insinuation that someone's role playing experience is closer to improv theatre than a traditional game can be highly polarizing.

I consider it just another form of playing. I appreciate it for what it is.

Personally, a prefer more structure in my regular game. Most of the good experiences I've had with light stuff have been one offs and con games. I've also done collaborative writing and improv, with varying results.
Some of us are there for the game with resultant story, not so much the RP. I've had sessions where no one spoke in character voice, yet fun was had and we all felt like characters were played to defined type.

For me, too light is when it ceases to feel like mechanics are shaping the story, too. If the mechanics aren't impactful on the story, there's no point in them being there.
 

Of course that's more of an issue with zero-to-hero games than it is with games where the PCs start out as experienced, maybe outright heroic figures and could be expected to only advance (if at all) in modest ways.

While my example is classic zero to hero, with visible vertical growth, it also includes competent heroes that don't necesarily get better verticaly, but over the course of game develop new skills and abilities aka horizontal growth. To put it plainly, if your character sheet is same on 1st and 5th session, it's no big deal. If it's same at 1st and 30th, it becomes boring. There are no new buttons to push, no new stuff to use, you have same toolkit you had from the start. Not to mention, when you have very basic and light char creation, there is very little mechanical variance in characters you can create. Mechanics are things that give fun options in game part of RPG, at least for me. New abilities give more options in game play loop.
 

For me, rules light games are unsatisfying for long a la the OP's story. They're not too light in a failed-as-a-game sense, but they are like fun-sized candy --- not a meal. Not supposed to be a meal either, in their defense. I think a light game is too light when they don't provide a presence at the table, because it creates that "we're just playing make believe" feeling.

Mind you, I like a simple resolution system --- simple roll under/over, say --- if it comes with sufficient opinion on when and how it is used. For example I love the utter simplicity of Cypher System --- any task can be ranked in difficulty on a 1-10 (1-15 for supers) scale, roll over --- but it would not be considered rules light.
 

Over the years, i tried few rules light system. Window, Fate Accelerated, Cairn, Knave, Mork Borg. Had fun with all. But universal complain from the group was lack of mechanical character growth, or in some cases very small growth. For one shots and short campaigns, not a problem. For longer games, it kinda is. Session 1 and session 50, your character has pretty much same (and mostly very limited) toolkit for problem solving. Also, there is disconect between character growth in fiction and in game terms.

So, too light, for me, is when game doesn't have solid rules for mechanical growth of characters, be it vertical, be it horizontal.
Back in the 80s I cut my teeth on D&D but the RPG I played the next most of was Champions, a very crunchy superhero game. And unlike zero-to-hero games like D&D, you started as a hero and at tiny, slow mechanical growth. Not only were XP granted miniscule against the points used to create your character, but the GM set power cap limits that you built up to in character creation and were still there in play so your main powers weren't advancing.

So long ago I realized it was just a conceit of D&D that characters went from nobodies to heroes to legendary figures in a few months in-game time, and that's not the measuring stick I use for fiction or other RPGs.
 

While my example is classic zero to hero, with visible vertical growth, it also includes competent heroes that don't necesarily get better verticaly, but over the course of game develop new skills and abilities aka horizontal growth. To put it plainly, if your character sheet is same on 1st and 5th session, it's no big deal. If it's same at 1st and 30th, it becomes boring. There are no new buttons to push, no new stuff to use, you have same toolkit you had from the start. Not to mention, when you have very basic and light char creation, there is very little mechanical variance in characters you can create. Mechanics are things that give fun options in game part of RPG, at least for me. New abilities give more options in game play loop.

All fair. It just depends on whether the lightweight nature of the game is involved in vertical compression (i.e.the numbers being used are small, so the range of values in skills and the like is small), horizontal (strong lumping of skills and attrbutes together and/or very limited exterior special abilities) or both.
 

For me, rules light games are unsatisfying for long a la the OP's story. They're not too light in a failed-as-a-game sense, but they are like fun-sized candy --- not a meal. Not supposed to be a meal either, in their defense. I think a light game is too light when they don't provide a presence at the table, because it creates that "we're just playing make believe" feeling.

I don't think in some cases they aren't supposed to be a meal. Its just their proponents consider most of the important elements of a game exterior to the system elements. They consider those minimal needs to resolve success and failure in a way that relates to the characters (in whatever fashion and to whatever degree is imprortant) and otherwise to be minimized as they aren't what they think the game is about.
 

Back in the 80s I cut my teeth on D&D but the RPG I played the next most of was Champions, a very crunchy superhero game. And unlike zero-to-hero games like D&D, you started as a hero and at tiny, slow mechanical growth. Not only were XP granted miniscule against the points used to create your character, but the GM set power cap limits that you built up to in character creation and were still there in play so your main powers weren't advancing.

So long ago I realized it was just a conceit of D&D that characters went from nobodies to heroes to legendary figures in a few months in-game time, and that's not the measuring stick I use for fiction or other RPGs.

Hero does have an enormous amount of potential horizontal growth, however, even with combat and skill caps: new skills, adding powers on via multipower slots, working on attributes that aren't directly involved in your caps and so on. That's a consequence of it being a mechanically full-featured game. Some rules light games don't, because supporting that would require the game to be busier than they find worthwhile.
 

Remove ads

Top