When is Rules Lite Too Lite?

A working rules light game in one rule:

When two participants have different views on what should happen next, flip a coin to see which one takes place.
M.A.R. Barker wrote up a one-page game with that as its mechanic, with dice rolls rather than coin flips, and I believe used it from time to time. I’ve never tried it myself, but would love to see a write up of someone using it.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

M.A.R. Barker wrote up a one-page game with that as its mechanic, with dice rolls rather than coin flips, and I believe used it from time to time. I’ve never tried it myself, but would love to see a write up of someone using it.
D&D's actual skill system is only about two steps removed from my Coin Flip (TM) system:

1. Define character abilities from a list rather than through informal agreement

2. Add weighting to the 50:50 odds to account for skill level and difficulty
 



There is no "too lite" in general, there are even fully narrative RPGs and they right for their purpose.

Generally I like the tactical aspect of D&D but I also played Risus which is a two-pages rules game and it was totally fine!

For longer, more involved campaigns? I need a system with at least a bit of crunch to it.

It still depends... heavy rules make a long game longer, someone might want a campaign to be long due to a very deep and complex narrative.
 

M.A.R. Barker wrote up a one-page game with that as its mechanic, with dice rolls rather than coin flips, and I believe used it from time to time. I’ve never tried it myself, but would love to see a write up of someone using it.
John Harper did a similar game called 50/50 with slightly more rules than that. It's about two-pages long. I can't seem to find a link.

I don't know if it's authentic, but I believe M.A.R. Barker's game was called Perfected. I first came across it as this image.

Perfected.jpg
 

D&D's actual skill system is only about two steps removed from my Coin Flip (TM) system:

1. Define character abilities from a list rather than through informal agreement

2. Add weighting to the 50:50 odds to account for skill level and difficulty

This is like saying that all RPGs are only about two step's removed from Celebrim's World's Simplest RPG.

See discussion:


Ect.
 

I'd say the rules are too light when someone playing the game is not enjoying it.

This sounds like the (highly flawed) idea that if your relationship with your spouse is not working, adding another person (like having a kid, or an affair) is going to help.

Game broken, add more rules?

You can change "light" to any other descriptive word, too.

"The rules are too <foo> when someone playing it is not enjoying it," is non-diagnostic, though. And it also fails to admit to problems arising from anything other than rules.
 

This sounds like the (highly flawed) idea that if your relationship with your spouse is not working, adding another person (like having a kid, or an affair) is going to help.

Game broken, add more rules?

Why does anyone ever treat argument by analogy as either sound or clarifying?

Do you imagine a one to one and onto relationship exists between game rules and personal relationships? Does imagining rules as people in any way clarify what makes a good rule or a good ruleset, or do it require now a massive more amount of explanation than before, since you now must agree on what constitutes good human relationships, how relationships map to rules, as well as resolve the original point of contention?
 

Why does anyone ever treat argument by analogy as either sound or clarifying?

Because it often is - but it does require the recipient to not be too hung up on the details, and instead look at the general form.

Do you imagine a one to one and onto relationship exists between game rules and personal relationships?

A one-to-one relationship is hardly required in this case.

Does imagining rules as people in any way clarify what makes a good rule or a good ruleset

It wasn't intended to.

or do it require now a massive more amount of explanation than before, since you now must agree on what constitutes good human relationships, how relationships map to rules, as well as resolve the original point of contention?

I think most readers did, or will, get my point.

My apologies if it is opaque to you, but it wasn't written for you, personally.
 

Remove ads

Top