When Someone Wonders "What Happen??" - Were the Wrong Lessons Learned from Apocalypse World?

I’m assuming that the Spiders response is addressing premise because it either changes or doesn’t. I’m assuming that the MC has already set what Spiders views are. When the PC says ‘‘give up slavery, you’re taking away their freedom for a future that isn’t guaranteed.’ That’s the stuff I’m reincorporating to help me decide IF he does change his mind.


In fact whenever I’ve talked about disclaiming it’s in precisely the situation where you think it could (or are inspired to), change the characters mind.

<snip>

I’m expecting people to add dramatic context to the example. In actual play it would probably look more like:

This is happening at the end of session three where these characters have developed a relationship, maybe talked around or come to blows over the issue before. So there’s lots more back story and fictional goings on that play has produced. The characters are both far more deep. We the players know this is a key moment. Hopefully they’re not just storming in and saying the actual line I used in the example. There’s back and forth and emotions and stuff.


To the extent the issue actually carries artistic weight then the Spider player needs stuff to work with and inspire them.
Your reference to inspiration (twice in what I've quoted) points me back to my remarks upthread, quoted from the earlier thread, about aesthetic intuition.
 

log in or register to remove this ad


Your reference to inspiration (twice in what I've quoted) points me back to my remarks upthread, quoted from the earlier thread, about aesthetic intuition.
I don't know why I don't reference it more but your thread:


Is brilliant
 

As far as I can tell, base AW (maybe 2e too?) lacks a "convince somebody of a thing" Move. You can Go Aggro to try and get them to do something, or Seduce/Manipulate; but there's no "talk somebody 'round through honest debate" (you can argue Seduction I guess?). My assumption is that this is deliberate for the play that Baker wanted to get out of AW, but doesnt really work well for games where "convincing somebody to see it your way or at least a mutually beneficial outcome" is possibly more common?

One reason I detest the "well just RP it out" thing is that people are irrational. I really like when a system gives me as a GM the tools to go "yeah based on what I have in my prep that might work to convince em, but lets see if this fictional person that's not actually me has something up their sleeve" via a roll.

I really like the explicitness of Stonetop's Persuade vs NPC:

When you press or entice an NPC, say what you want them to do (or not do). If they have reason to resist, roll +CHA:

Right here, if we're having a conversation between PC(s) and a NPC and I can tell we're driving towards "I want you to do something" I need to ask myself "would this NPC resist?" Ive found this consideration so helpful, because I need to articulate a reason which then sets stakes and potential outcomes. Then I need to make that clear, so I give the players that information, right? Because we haven't taken up dice yet, and I need to ensure the fictional situation is clear.

Then we get the results list:

on a 10+, they either do as you want or reveal the easiest way to convince them; on a 7-9, they reveal something you can do to convince them, though it’ll likely be costly, tricky, or distasteful.

So a 10+ is actionable. Either your pressing/enticing works, or if there's no way words alone would change the situation it becomes clear what will. Incorruptible guard? She'll tell you how to get proper authorization and so forth. Want me to stop doing slavery? Sure, give me so much money I don't have to worry about it any more.

7-9 still gives you a path, but you probably didn't want it.
 

As far as I can tell, base AW (maybe 2e too?) lacks a "convince somebody of a thing" Move. You can Go Aggro to try and get them to do something, or Seduce/Manipulate; but there's no "talk somebody 'round through honest debate" (you can argue Seduction I guess?). My assumption is that this is deliberate for the play that Baker wanted to get out of AW
I believe this is correct!
 


Generally speaking, I like it when you can use skills to make someone do something involuntarily (lying to someone, appealing to their baser instincts, intimidation) but not voluntarily (make them be your friend, convince them to surrender when they clearly shouldn't, perform a specific favor).
 

I'm okay with the latter, but only when it makes sense. And that's why the principle of "following the fiction" is so important. A king isn't going to just abdicate and make you his heir because you rolled an 11 on 2d6. But you may convince a merchant to give you a better deal by smooth-talking him, or get a former employer to write you a letter of recommendation because you reminded him of the time you saved his caravan.
 

I think if you roll and make someone remember something, it detracts from the illusion of the character. I prefer for freedom to exist to extend to NPCs nearly as much as free will does to PCs.
 

Having come into PBtA via reading Dungeon World and reading about PBtA games in general, I did not like how often it seemed you in general as a GM would have to figure out complications and how often you would fail in general as a player.

Occasional "come up with a complication" can be fantastic in my experiences in other games, using that as a constant part of stuff seemed overwhelming to me to contemplate as a DM and annoying to deal with as a player.

I generally like a more pulpy competent protagonist view of things in RPGs so that the players are incentivized to be active rather than super cautious even if things go really poorly.

I have gotten a bunch of PBtA stuff, but mostly for inspiration from the specifics, not for use straight using the PBtA system.
In my view, failure represents challenge, because the GM never gets to do anything unless you roll badly. In D&D, you don't get bad results for a failure (unless it's a nat-1), the DM is your bad results- "the monster attacks." Any roll under 10 brings the GM into the game, where the mystery is found.
 

Remove ads

Top