The changes in math have been extremely frustrating, and I see the results as a professor at an R1 University in a quantitative field.
One of the problems is that back when I was in school (70s-80s) that there were a bunch of kids who did great at math and knew there multiplication tables great (although that little professor calculator at home and having to practice them
a lot when I failed a test helped), but there were a bunch of kids that the old system didn't work for.
I think like many reform movements, the things we've had in the past decade+ swung too far, and while they might have helped the bottom end, they seem have decimated the top end. Finding a balance was a topic at a recent school board meeting here.
It feels like individual teachers would have had more individual classroom curricular control to avoid the swings going too far when the pedagogical winds changed. The centralized top down curricular controls that the majority of voters seem to want for general public schools (but not charters and private schools) doesn't seem to be helpful.
I was happy to hear at our own board meeting that the students are indeed supposed to be practicing the tables (what worked for the high end back in my day) along with things that are supposed to make sure everyone is pulled along.
In our area (a mixed suburban/rural spread district with very mixed demographic/income including a high poverty level, some very non-impoverished areas, and lot of English language learners in a southern state), "Public charter" seems to equal "only the easy to teach kids". Here anyway...
- Charters aren't required to provide transportation - therefore the schools trend massively wealthier (in terms of the poverty rate being much, much lower). And since money is strongly correlated with good nutrition, receiving medical care (mental and physical), knowing more how to navigate the IEP/504 system and getting help doing so, more access to tutoring (which costs $) when needed, having been read to more as a child, having parents who went to college or finished high school and are better able to help, being less likely to have PTSD, etc...
- Parents need to know to apply and apply to Charters, which requires some knowledge of the system and the social capital to better interact with it. This is builds on the things the transportation requirement does (see previous bullet) and have almost no new immigrants and very few English language learners (insert obvious reasons those groups need extra support).
- For whatever reason, in addition to lacking English language learners, looking at the statistics, non-specialized Charters seem to not have as many children who would need specialized special ed services beyond the most common IEP/504 things (like those seen on college campuses, as opposed to those needing a shadow for emotional issues or the like).
- They are freed from many regulations and requirements that the parents seem fine with not having for their kids... But many of the pro-charter/pro-voucher legislators, for example, want to free those two groups from regulations they think are vitally important for the general public schools.
- I'm not sure how the discipline works differently here, but I am guessing the local regular public school has to take the disciplinarily difficult students back after they serve their expulsion while the charter might have ways of dodging that (especially if it is a mid-year return and the lottery isn't open).
I don't blame parents when they find that their home public school didn't serve their kid and that some other one did (flexible registration at another general public school, magnet, charter, private, home) - whether it is a particular thing their child experienced, or something endemic at their local public school!!! But here, if one models the educational outcome statistics based on student poverty, the two very popular charter schools are in the average performance range just like most of the local public schools. And so for any particular child, there isn't evidence the charter gives an academic advantage beyond what individual student demographics would predict. (Before charters were a thing, the state report cards used to break out the average student performance for those qualifying for reduced student lunches and those not. At many well-regarded, and less-well regarded local publics the performance in both groups was about the same, but the the well-regarded has much fewer of the former).