Wizards of the Coast responds to D&D unionization effort, says they will respect results of union vote

A vote will take place, likely next month.
Status
Not open for further replies.
1792079195155.jpeg


Wizards of the Coast declined to voluntarily recognize a union of game developers for Dungeons & Dragons and Magic: The Gathering, but they have told employees they will respect the final vote when employees decide whether or not to move forward with unionization. Yesterday, Wizards of the Coast United reported that Wizards had declined to voluntarily recognize a union made up of game designers and developers consisting of the D&D, Magic: The Gathering, and Duel Masters teams. In an email obtained by Wargamer, Wizards executives said they are “not neutral” in regard to unionization but would respect the voting process.

The language used in the email largely mimics language used when responding to a previous unionization attempt by the developers of Magic: Arena, which was eventually successful. The email states that management believes that crafting a strong workplace comes from working directly with employees, not through unions. It also touted a list of employee benefits that came via the result of “direct collaboration” as opposed to union negotiations. Those benefits include a 20% increase in base salaries since 2023, annual bonuses, five weeks of paid time off, and free product.

Wizards told employees that “it is the right of every eligible employee to decide whether union representation is right for them” and that “in the end, [Wizards] will respect the results of the election, no matter what [their] employees choose.” They also said they expected respectful conversations moving forward and that no one would be treated differently based on their opinions.

The next step will be for the National Labor Relations Board to review a petition from the union and to set a date for the election. The NLRB aims to hold elections within 42 days of receiving the petition.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Christian Hoffer

Christian Hoffer

I’m not sure that WotC execs have any agency in this, no matter what their opinions are. In my opinion, it’s likely that Hasbro calls the shots on these kinds of decisions, and WotC leadership can at best massage the comms slightly to inject their own leaning (e.g., whether they want to adopt a more aggressive or more collaborative posture). But outright accepting the union was never in the cards even if WotC’s leaders had wanted that outcome. They are likely following the chain of command and unfortunately in big multi-layer corps like this it means a "president" or "general manager" or even sometimes "CEO" of a wholly owned subsidiary is in fact just a glorified middle manager. Hasbro is a publicly traded company so of course they must at least put up a semblance of not bowing down to unions, for the sake of optics with their shareholders.

I’m not saying it’s good or bad… but it is I think simply reality.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Heck, just show me a union responsible for poisoning groundwater like Pacific Gas & Electric. Or running fraud like Enron or a ponzi scheme like Bernie Madoff. Or a union that somehow managed to create a global mortgage crisis.

I mean, I'd also like to see that, but I think the on-topic question is more like "How likely is a union (or agents therein) to mess up your money? As a direct counterweight, how likely are they to slow or stop regular corporate abuses that mess up your money?"

Like, ideally we could do math like: If you pay $700/year in union dues, but get a $1000/year raise, you're ahead $300. If union rules get you paid for what would otherwise be an average of $500/year in wage theft, but cost you an average of $5 on union corruption (losses to retirement funds, etc), you're on average ahead another $450, totaling $750 in the black (not counting all other factors). If the average pay on what'd otherwise be wage theft is $50, and union corruption costs you an average of $500, you're behind $450 there, a total of $150 in the red (not counting all other factors).

I would bet that the numbers come out putting you on average in the black, but maybe I'm an optimist; I always bet on black.
 

Which is specifically what I claimed. So my examples show what I claimed!
No. What you claimed is that union officials are frequently charged with racketeering. As proof you showed us a few cases. Well, there are at least a few cases against bad apples in pretty much every field of work that there is.

There are 38 thousandish unions in the United States. Taken with a huge amount of salt, the AI overview says that there are around 100 thousand union officers. If your claim were true, we'd be hearing about new cases every day.

I very much doubt your claim of union officials being frequently charged with racketeering.
 

No. What you claimed is that union officials are frequently charged with racketeering. As proof you showed us a few cases. Well, there are at least a few cases against bad apples in pretty much every field of work that there is.

There are 38 thousandish unions in the United States. Taken with a huge amount of salt, the AI overview says that there are around 100 thousand union officers. If your claim were true, we'd be hearing about new cases every day.

I very much doubt your claim of union officials being frequently charged with racketeering.

That was more years ago with the Mafia.
 

I've been doing this for 16 years. If we want to add in parents, my mom did 30 years, and my grandmother did 30 and 4 as an in-class para/support after she retired. I'm glad that you have some experience, but I'm going to tell you that our experience levels aren't the same.



Sounds great. I have no problems with those.



I'll be honest, I've never heard of anyone grading like this, but also I don't know districts which use grading as a progress meter. In Michigan, we use M-STEP and (typically) NWEA as our signposts for yearly progression and we do get judged on that. And we've had to play around with that to make sure we don't get weird outlier stuff, either (We had a moment where kids were purposefully bombing the initial test because we were trying to reward them on their mid-year progress. Kids are clever, but we had to nip that in the bud). But never, never grading.



I... look, we went over to what I believe are called "Evidence-Based Standards Grading" elsewhere, but my district knows them by a different name and I'm not giving that up because you could probably track me down with it. At any rate, even with our new standards and such I've never even heard of anything close to that sort of thing. Admittedly I'm not an Elementary teacher (I'm Middle & High School), but I've helped out as a co-teacher in various rooms and worked pretty extensively with our MTSS intervention team and I've generally not heard of teachers tell parents not to teach kids new methods, though I know certain sections of math often have questions which ask you to solve things in certain ways to show you know those methods specifically.



I have experience with those, but at the same time I think a lot of people misrepresent or simply don't want to change their view on how things were taught. Like, I am reminded of the meme post that made its way across the internet of the engineer parent getting angry about how a kid got a question wrong because they solved a question when it asked the kid to estimate, or sometimes it's just a badly-worded question when the concept is valid. On the latter, I'm reminded of "Explain why this student got this wrong", which I think can be confusing to some parents but we are better at executing them now in math and I think they are interesting (largely because I tutor after school and end up trying to figure it out with the students myself). Also lead to one of the funniest exchanges I've ever had with a student.

"So do you think he's got right or wrong?"

"Wrong."

"Why's that?"

"<Deadpan> He hasn't gotten lucky on one all year."




Not just pay, but benefits and a lot of other things. You're here, having done this, telling me that teachers have done this like this in years past. But we are still stuck very much in the throes of high-stakes testing, we're still losing benefits and honestly being demonized by a lot of groups, we have a lot of parents who actively barge their way into curriculum for... reasons (I'm a Social Studies teacher and God, I still feel lucky that I'm not yet a science teacher), and we're expected to continue to do more for less. You got out in two years: imagine dealing with it for another 14. Heck, we're only now getting through the aftershocks of the COVID generation...

(Edited to give correct name of new grading concept)
My daughter could not add and subtract at the end of second grade without writing down sentences of numbers.

She could not quickly answer 8+8. She had highest math grade in her class. Parents were told not to teach math because the kids needed to learn the concepts first.

I could do basic multiplication by the end of second. We learned addition in Kindergarten in the 80s.

Now my daughter loves school and learning so we played school all summer and she entered 3rd grade knowing her math, including multiplication, and can answer basic facts quickly.

As a parent, I, generally, do not blame teachers. I am angry at the school system and the education system for failing.

As I said, the public charter is run by teachers and is night and day different. You can also tell that the teachers are happy and excited to teach without the county and crappy admin. They also do not take crap from parents. They have a waitlist and remind parents that bad behavior on their part an result in removal.

A kid who was violent, twice, was removed from the school. In public school, they’d get a referral and be back in class tossing chairs the next day. Elementary schools here do not have ISS.

I am happy if the system is better where you teach. The parents I know all have similar issues and are spread out across the country.
 

I'm still wondering what the D&D bargaining unit's leverage/power is in negotiations with WotC/Hasbro, assuming they vote in the union and WotC recognizes it?

I'm a Californian, but I've also lived and worked in Europe. So I've seen transport union strikes timed to peak travel times cause enormous disruption immediately, giving the union a lot of power. In America, when my daughter was school age, we went through a teachers' union strike. Because children's education is so important to every parent, and because many parents also have to use the school as 'free daycare,' this gave the teachers' union enormous power/leverage. Over the years, the UAW has taken repeated strike action against various automakers. Because these automakers have enormous fixed costs that keep accruing even when employees are down tools, this gave the UAW very significant leverage/power.

Because Magic is the most profitable part of Hasbro, if the Studio X bargaining unit went on strike, I think they'd have Hasbro by the throat.

But if the 160 person D&D bargaining unit went on strike, I am very skeptical that would move the needle at Hasbro's new HQ in Boston. And because so many Americans live paycheck-to-paycheck, I wonder how long the D&D employees could hold out?

Are there labor laws or regulations that their union could use effectively to sue Hasbro? (The limit of my knowledge on this particular topic is a legal obligation for WotC to bargain with the union in good faith. But what does that really mean without enforcement power?)
 

My daughter could not add and subtract at the end of second grade without writing down sentences of numbers.

She could not quickly answer 8+8. She had highest math grade in her class. Parents were told not to teach math because the kids needed to learn the concepts first.

I could do basic multiplication by the end of second. We learned addition in Kindergarten in the 80s.

Now my daughter loves school and learning so we played school all summer and she entered 3rd grade knowing her math, including multiplication, and can answer basic facts quickly.

As a parent, I, generally, do not blame teachers. I am angry at the school system and the education system for failing.

As a professor at an R1 University in a quantitative field, the outcomes of these changes in math education have been extremely frustrating.

One of the problems is that back when I was in school (70s-80s) that there were a bunch of kids who did fine at math and knew their multiplication tables fluently, but there were a bunch of kids that the old system didn't work for too.

I think the things we've had in math in the past decade+ swung too far in how they were implemented in some places (a smoosh to the middle instead of raising the bottom end). Finding a balance was a topic at a recent school board meeting here.

It feels like individual teachers would have had more individual classroom curricular control to avoid the swings going too far when the pedagogical winds changed. The centralized top down curricular controls that the majority of voters seem to want for general public schools (but not charters and private schools) doesn't seem to be helpful.

I was happy to hear at our own board meeting that the students are indeed supposed to be practicing the tables (what worked for the high end back in my day) along with getting beyond just wrote memorization (since that by itself didn't work for everyone in the past).

As I said, the public charter is run by teachers and is night and day different. You can also tell that the teachers are happy and excited to teach without the county and crappy admin. They also do not take crap from parents. They have a waitlist and remind parents that bad behavior on their part an result in removal.

A kid who was violent, twice, was removed from the school. In public school, they’d get a referral and be back in class tossing chairs the next day. Elementary schools here do not have ISS.

In our area (a mixed suburban/rural spread district with very mixed demographic/income including a high poverty level, some very non-impoverished areas, and lot of English language learners in a southern state), "Public charter" seems to equal "only the easy to teach kids". Here anyway...
  • Charters aren't required to provide transportation - therefore the schools trend massively wealthier (in terms of the poverty rate being much, much lower). And since money is strongly correlated with good nutrition, receiving medical care (mental and physical), knowing more how to navigate the IEP/504 system and getting help doing so, more access to tutoring (which costs $) when needed, having been read to more as a child, having parents who went to college or finished high school and are better able to help, being less likely to have PTSD, etc...
  • Parents need to know to apply and apply to Charters, which requires some knowledge of the system and the social capital to better interact with it. This is builds on the things the transportation requirement does (see previous bullet) and have almost no new immigrants and very few English language learners (insert obvious reasons those groups need extra support).
  • For whatever reason, in addition to lacking English language learners, looking at the statistics, non-specialized Charters seem to not have as many children who would need specialized special ed services beyond the most common IEP/504 things (like those seen on college campuses, as opposed to those needing a shadow for emotional issues or the like).
  • They are freed from many regulations and requirements that the parents seem fine with not having for their kids... But many of the pro-charter/pro-voucher legislators, for example, want to free those two groups from regulations they think are vitally important for the general public schools.
  • I'm not sure how the discipline works differently here, but I am guessing the local regular public school has to take the disciplinarily difficult students back after they serve their expulsion while the charter might have ways of dodging that (especially if it is a mid-year return and the lottery isn't open). If charters can just push the students with disciplinary problems to the general public schools, and the voters leave those public schools no choice, of course the obvious happens. <insert entire other discussion on this that is well beyond the scope of this board and for which no widespread solution has been found>
I don't blame parents when they find that their home public school didn't serve their kid and that some other one did (flexible registration at another general public school, magnet, charter, private, home) - whether it is a particular thing their child experienced, or something endemic at their local public school!!! But here, if one models the educational outcome statistics based on student poverty, the two very popular charter schools are in the average performance range just like most of the local public schools. And so for any particular child, there isn't evidence the charter gives an academic advantage beyond what individual student demographics would predict. (Before charters were a thing, the state report cards used to break out the average student performance for those qualifying for reduced student lunches and those not. At many well-regarded, and less-well regarded local publics the performance in both groups was about the same, but the the well-regarded has much fewer of the former).
 
Last edited:

The changes in math have been extremely frustrating, and I see the results as a professor at an R1 University in a quantitative field.

One of the problems is that back when I was in school (70s-80s) that there were a bunch of kids who did great at math and knew there multiplication tables great (although that little professor calculator at home and having to practice them a lot when I failed a test helped), but there were a bunch of kids that the old system didn't work for.

I think like many reform movements, the things we've had in the past decade+ swung too far, and while they might have helped the bottom end, they seem have decimated the top end. Finding a balance was a topic at a recent school board meeting here.

It feels like individual teachers would have had more individual classroom curricular control to avoid the swings going too far when the pedagogical winds changed. The centralized top down curricular controls that the majority of voters seem to want for general public schools (but not charters and private schools) doesn't seem to be helpful.

I was happy to hear at our own board meeting that the students are indeed supposed to be practicing the tables (what worked for the high end back in my day) along with things that are supposed to make sure everyone is pulled along.




In our area (a mixed suburban/rural spread district with very mixed demographic/income including a high poverty level, some very non-impoverished areas, and lot of English language learners in a southern state), "Public charter" seems to equal "only the easy to teach kids". Here anyway...
  • Charters aren't required to provide transportation - therefore the schools trend massively wealthier (in terms of the poverty rate being much, much lower). And since money is strongly correlated with good nutrition, receiving medical care (mental and physical), knowing more how to navigate the IEP/504 system and getting help doing so, more access to tutoring (which costs $) when needed, having been read to more as a child, having parents who went to college or finished high school and are better able to help, being less likely to have PTSD, etc...
  • Parents need to know to apply and apply to Charters, which requires some knowledge of the system and the social capital to better interact with it. This is builds on the things the transportation requirement does (see previous bullet) and have almost no new immigrants and very few English language learners (insert obvious reasons those groups need extra support).
  • For whatever reason, in addition to lacking English language learners, looking at the statistics, non-specialized Charters seem to not have as many children who would need specialized special ed services beyond the most common IEP/504 things (like those seen on college campuses, as opposed to those needing a shadow for emotional issues or the like).
  • They are freed from many regulations and requirements that the parents seem fine with not having for their kids... But many of the pro-charter/pro-voucher legislators, for example, want to free those two groups from regulations they think are vitally important for the general public schools.
  • I'm not sure how the discipline works differently here, but I am guessing the local regular public school has to take the disciplinarily difficult students back after they serve their expulsion while the charter might have ways of dodging that (especially if it is a mid-year return and the lottery isn't open).
I don't blame parents when they find that their home public school didn't serve their kid and that some other one did (flexible registration at another general public school, magnet, charter, private, home) - whether it is a particular thing their child experienced, or something endemic at their local public school!!! But here, if one models the educational outcome statistics based on student poverty, the two very popular charter schools are in the average performance range just like most of the local public schools. And so for any particular child, there isn't evidence the charter gives an academic advantage beyond what individual student demographics would predict. (Before charters were a thing, the state report cards used to break out the average student performance for those qualifying for reduced student lunches and those not. At many well-regarded, and less-well regarded local publics the performance in both groups was about the same, but the the well-regarded has much fewer of the former).
You’re right about the issues with charters. I agree with you that they are moving more to the people capable of providing transport although this charter provides transport for needy students.

The public schools hate them though. The school councilor tried to scare us into staying in the county system even when they said our complaints about our experience were valid.

I would prefer schools return to tracks that allowed teachers time to focus on students in ways that met needs.

Our experience was that kids who performed well received no attention.

The last straw for us was the letter from the second grade teacher to all parents saying not to teach concepts that were not scheduled until 4th.

When we asked some other teachers, they said that was when it appeared on state tests and teaching them early was just wrong.

I’m sorry, my kids will not magically forget to do basic addition because it was taught in 2nd rather than 4th. Education is cumulative.

I am not trying to make people upset. I am just very angry with the situation. My job is to make sure my kids have the skills to make it when they are out in the world and the county system failed us.
 

You’re right about the issues with charters. I agree with you that they are moving more to the people capable of providing transport although this charter provides transport for needy students.

The public schools hate them though. The school councilor tried to scare us into staying in the county system even when they said our complaints about our experience were valid.

I would prefer schools return to tracks that allowed teachers time to focus on students in ways that met needs.

Our experience was that kids who performed well received no attention.

The last straw for us was the letter from the second grade teacher to all parents saying not to teach concepts that were not scheduled until 4th.

When we asked some other teachers, they said that was when it appeared on state tests and teaching them early was just wrong.

I’m sorry, my kids will not magically forget to do basic addition because it was taught in 2nd rather than 4th. Education is cumulative.

I am not trying to make people upset. I am just very angry with the situation. My job is to make sure my kids have the skills to make it when they are out in the world and the county system failed us.

I am very glad your charter provides transportation and that it is working very well for your child!!

And I hope your local general public (and the forces above it making it have to do things that don't work) get addressed. I wish I was optimistic (about this and many other things across the country) because a lot of them are <well beyond the board rules to discuss>.
 
Last edited:

My daughter could not add and subtract at the end of second grade without writing down sentences of numbers.

She could not quickly answer 8+8. She had highest math grade in her class. Parents were told not to teach math because the kids needed to learn the concepts first.

I... cannot speak to that problem because I largely see the opposite at my level. I would love it if kids would write down problems, but that feels like a big issue and certain is after COVID really hammered the mid-level Elementary fundamentals of kids due to lockdowns.

I could do basic multiplication by the end of second. We learned addition in Kindergarten in the 80s.

So could I, and even I still got called out for doing things too quickly in 2nd Grade. But I also recognize the rose-colored glasses I wear looking back; I would also say that you probably view your early education differently than your parents, as my mom informed me in recent years of a bunch of problems with my teachers that I didn't remember or never clocked. And I know that there were a bunch of kids that the "One-size fits all" system did not work for and left kids behind. That's the struggle: people want to move back to a system that they only barely remember and did not see from the other side. Part of the reason we've seen different approaches to this stuff is to try and include all different kinds of learners instead of trying to fit kids into a single mold. That mold might work for you and I, but there are bunches (like my father) who it didn't work for.

This isn't to say the new approach doesn't have problems; I keep in communication with our math department and I've picked their brain on it multiple times. I think there is a desire to blend both styles. Like, I would say the earlier rote learning of our era is closer to learning routes to a place; you are good until a route is blocked, at which point you have problems because you never learned the map. Meanwhile the new teaching focuses on learning the map, trying to teach a bunch of different ways to approach a problem and understanding it... but lacks focus, so the kids don't internalize where they are going as well. We need more focus and attention on the destination, but probably not in the same advocates for the old ways really want.

Now my daughter loves school and learning so we played school all summer and she entered 3rd grade knowing her math, including multiplication, and can answer basic facts quickly.

As a parent, I, generally, do not blame teachers. I am angry at the school system and the education system for failing.

I'm not even sure it's the education system as much as people failing the educational system. We continue to get less funding, less independence, and if you are unlucky enough your school board gets filled with cranks that get offended by people having rainbows in their rooms (Sorry, Romeo, but you can't be surprised after you gave us Kid Rock).

As I said, the public charter is run by teachers and is night and day different. You can also tell that the teachers are happy and excited to teach without the county and crappy admin. They also do not take crap from parents. They have a waitlist and remind parents that bad behavior on their part an result in removal.

A kid who was violent, twice, was removed from the school. In public school, they’d get a referral and be back in class tossing chairs the next day. Elementary schools here do not have ISS.

I'm happy for your charter, but they get to run on different rules and toss the tough kids to us. I'm glad they can toss kids that are difficult, but that's not something you can do at a public school because you can't just kick a 7th grader out of the educational system.

Like, in all honesty, I'm not sure if they are actually teaching under a different system or if they simply have a different baseline of student which allows them to proceed at a rate that is more befitting your daughter. And good for her, but public schools take in all kinds and you have to deal with that in class. Differentiated education is difficult and while it's the ideal, it can be hard to pull off when kids can be at drastically different levels.

I am happy if the system is better where you teach. The parents I know all have similar issues and are spread out across the country.

I feel like parents should focus on politicians giving us funding and let us deal with our administrations.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.
Remove ads

Remove ads

Top