Wizards of the Coast retains Fisher Phillips, a union avoidance firm; vote will take place on November 10th

Fisher Phillips is a well known anti-union law firm.
IMG_8736.jpeg

A recent filing confirms that Wizards of the Coast has retained the services of Fisher Phillips, described as a union avoidance firm by United Wizards of the Coast, to represent them during the ongoing unionization efforts at the company. Recent filings posted to the National Labor Relations Board confirms that Wizards is continuing to use Fisher Phillips, a well-known law firm considered to be one of the best in advising clients on how to avoid unionization, in regards to the efforts by several groups of Wizards of the Coast employees to unionize. Wizards previously hired Fisher Phillips to assist them when a group of Magic: The Gathering Arena employees unionized earlier this year. That move came with widespread condemnation from the wider Magic: The Gathering fanbase due to the law firm’s anti-union sentiments. Wizards has declined to voluntarily recognize the unionizing employees, forcing a vote among employees. That vote, according to NRLB filings, will take place on November 10th. Ballots are typically counted a few weeks after the vote takes place, although that may be delayed due to the Thanksgiving holiday.

Wizards unfortunately has a history of hiring anti-union companies. In addition to Fisher Phillips, Wizards previously worked with the Pinkertons, a detective agency with violent anti-union history during the late 19th century. The Pinkertons were called upon to retrieve Magic: The Gathering product that was released ahead of schedule.

Wizards has previously stated that they are against the new unions forming, but will respect the results of a vote. The company has said that collective bargaining is not necessary to deal with ongoing concerns at the workplace, which include protections from job layoffs, mandatory AI usage, and ownership of creative works done outside of work hours.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Christian Hoffer

Christian Hoffer

In my sarcastic voice: "wait, Freelance??? Working for your employer's direct competition? Doesn't that put them in a 3-way opposition of each of their employers? Isn't that an unethical conflict of interest?"

Unsarcastically, now: This is how it just should be with creative work. You're hired to do work for your employer that they direct. They own the thing they paid for, not everything you do on time they didn't pay you for.

there's no ethical need for an agreement not to compete. Sure, a company might WANT that. Doesn't mean it's unethical to negotiate against it.
Of course people who aren’t employees aren’t expected to work for a single company. Otherwise your plumber would never make a living.

There is a big difference between an artist commissioned to produce a piece of art and the art director commissioning the work, who you absolutely wouldn’t expect to be working for both Paizo and WotC.

Of course, you can try and negotiate for anything you want. Good luck, because a non-compete is a perfectly reasonable and common contractual term. Hells, it’s even common to have terms stopping you working for a competitor even after you’ve stopped working for them until a period has passed.
 

log in or register to remove this ad



Certainly, but employed.

Does picking up a shift a week put you in the obligation not to take work with competition? How about part-time? Full time? Where does it appear?
No, if you work freelance you’re not an employee that’s the point.

It depends are you competing with your employers. It would depend on the expectations of the company and the nature of the work.
 



I thought I was relatively clear, but if not:

Not where does "freelance" start and end. Where does this moral obligation to avoid competition with and employer begin? What strengthens it or weakens it's moral force? What social good is produced by it, rendering it virtuous? Why should anyone agree with you that it exists beyond the letter of a contract?
 


Of course people who aren’t employees aren’t expected to work for a single company. Otherwise your plumber would never make a living.

There is a big difference between an artist commissioned to produce a piece of art and the art director commissioning the work, who you absolutely wouldn’t expect to be working for both Paizo and WotC.
That's a full-time staff position, so yes, unlikely to be hired for two full-time jobs at once. (Edited to add: unless you're a CEO, I guess.)
However, there's no reason an art director at one company couldn't, say, paint a commissioned art piece for another.

Artists also do gallery shows all the time, doing art they personally create and sell. No big deal. Normal work for an artist.


Of course, you can try and negotiate for anything you want. Good luck, because a non-compete is a perfectly reasonable and common contractual term.
Common perhaps. Not reasonable.

Your job isn't your spouse - you don't owe them exclusivity. They'll look you in the eye during layoff day and say "it's nothing personal. It's just business."

Competition is just business. It's baked into the whole idea of capitalism. Your employer isn't your spouse, your workplace isn't 'a family'.

My employer and I settle up every payday. Every payday, we're even. Neither of us "owes" the other anything. I show up and do my work. They pay me. I have no romantic illusions about loyalty.


Hells, it’s even common to have terms stopping you working for a competitor even after you’ve stopped working for them until a period has passed.
Newly passed laws make all such agreements null and void in the state of Washington, with very few narrowly-tailored exceptions. For good reason, they're anticompetitive and place an undue burden on workers. I live in California, where also these sorts of agreements are unlawful.

I understand WHY a business may want such a thing.
I do not fathom why any individual worker SHOULD advocate for this, as if it's perfectly reasonable.

I find this position against the very principle of free enterprise. Why shouldn't we be able to advance our station by working harder, and working for ourselves, finding opportunities beyond the scope of the workweek?

Confidentiality agreements, I can understand. Non-competes? Those are for the birds.
 

You're not paying attention; they're just called Hasbro layoffs now, and the company has been downsizing since 2023, affecting Wizards staff each year.
I think WotC's employment this year is higher than 23. It's just that consistent hiring for 9 months doesn't make news.
A large round of layoffs does make news.
We KNOW that the D&D design team is larger than any point in the WotC era.
 

Remove ads

Remove ads

Top