D&D 5E (2024) World of Warcraft: Boss Monsters

dave2008

Legend
I just picked up the WOW book from my FLGS (I don't have it in DnD Beyond yet so no screen shots from me), and I want to talk about on of the things I was most interested in and I haven't heard much discussion about: Boss Monsters.

You may or may not know that WoW brings back "mythic" monsters (first introduced in Mythic Odysseys of Theros) to 5e24 for the first time. Interesting none of these mythic monsters are in the actual Bestiary. The only provided in the dungeons section of the book. To me, this seems to hint that though legendary monsters help with some issues of solo fights, you really need mythic monsters to be boss monsters.

This is something I agree with. A legendary monster has little to no difference than a standard monster of the same CR. All of its defenses and damage are part of the CR calculation. Take those away and you simple allocate attributes differently to get the same CR. However, a mythic monster acts like many monsters of the same CR and typical triggers new abilities (mythic actions) when its mythic trait is active. Also, these mythic actions often hit harder than standard legendary actions (which they can replace). That really isn't anything new since the mythic concept was introduced.

However, what is new with WoW is how they have extended the mythic range up and down.

More Mythic:
Several of the mythic monsters in WoW can use their mythic trait 2/day, effectively giving it 3x the defenses. For example, the CR 13 Alzzin has 205 HP and 3 uses of legendary resistance (LR). When it is reduced to 0 hit points it regains 200 HP and all spent used of LR. It can do this 2x, effectively giving it 605 HP and 9 uses of LR - at CR 13.

Multiple uses of the Mythic trait is something I explored years ago (Godzilla 5e) but this is the first use in an official WotC product. Though still not used to its fullest with these monsters IMO, it opens up a lot of design space for 3PP that they perhaps feared to tread previously.

Less Mythic:
What surprised more was how they introduced a simplified version of a mythic monster. The CR 10 Arcanist Doan doesn't have mythic actions and only recharges its mythic trait once (like OG mythic monsters). However, instead of having mythic actions, Doan gains access to a new action and bonus action when its mythic trait is active.

I am not normally one to downsize my monsters, but I think this new approach is an effective way to get a lot of the bang of a mythic monster without have to spend all of the crunchy design bucks.

Missed Opportunity:
When I heard boss monsters were going to be connected to specific dungeons in WoW I got excited and thought we might see the comeback of lair actions. Alas, that is not the case. I know WotC said people didn't use lair actions with monsters in the MM, but it seemed me that if you are making a bespoke monster for a dungeon, this would be the perfect time to reintroduce the concept. Lair actions provided so much wonderful design potential that I was sad to see they did not make a comeback.

So here is my take on a boss monster using the new rules in the WoW book:

1794428535201.png


PS
Once I get access to the book in beyond I will attach some images.
 
Last edited:

log in or register to remove this ad

A few do get Mythic Action like stuff.

Illidan after getting Bloodied for example heals then gets acess to new moves.

I need to check out the Icecrown Adventure to see if Arthas get's new stuff as the final boss.
 

This sounds like fighting a mythic beast is just going to make fights drag on for even longer if they do. How many people actually want that?
 

This sounds like fighting a mythic beast is just going to make fights drag on for even longer if they do. How many people actually want that?
Well the issue with a solo monster in 5e is that they may only last 1 to 1.5 rounds (see Mike Mearls recent vlog on this: High Level 5e Monsters). So, giving it the mythic trait lets it last 3-4.5 rounds. That doesn't sound like a drag to me, but a necessity. Now, the need for extended monster survivability varies form group to group and depends on the groups size, synergy, tactical, and strategic acumen. The nice thing about mythic monsters is that you can stop the fight at any stage and it you ger XP rewards based on the stage completed. So a CR 8 mythic monster gives 3,900 XP if you defeat 1 stage, 7,800 XP if you defeat 2 stages, and 11,700 XP if you defeat all 3. This allows the DM to easily modify the battle on the fly. So if it appears to drag (highly unlikely) you can just stop it after the 2nd stage.
 

A few do get Mythic Action like stuff.

Illidan after getting Bloodied for example heals then gets acess to new moves.

I need to check out the Icecrown Adventure to see if Arthas get's new stuff as the final boss.
Good point, Illidan is nice in-between Legendary and Mythic monster. but I think Illidan is the only one that gets those options. Also, I haven't run the numbers, but my guess is the 100 HP he regains from his Demon Form bonus action is likely calculated as part of his CR. That is fundamentally different than a mythic trait full HP & LR recharge which is not. The mythic trait gives you a whole lot more design space.
 

This sounds like fighting a mythic beast is just going to make fights drag on for even longer if they do. How many people actually want that?
My players for a start. I mentioned before that my players were surprised that Vecna (EoR) did not have a “phase two”. They clearly felt it was anticlimactic. This comes from video games were boss fights typically have multiple phases, often getting tougher, and also because D&D rules tend to make single bosses something of a pushover.
 

Good point, Illidan is nice in-between Legendary and Mythic monster. but I think Illidan is the only one that gets those options. Also, I haven't run the numbers, but my guess is the 100 HP he regains from his Demon Form bonus action is likely calculated as part of his CR. That is fundamentally different than a mythic trait full HP & LR recharge which is not. The mythic trait gives you a whole lot more design space.
Ragnaros is also sort of like that though he does not get new moves. It's more just that he starts healing while his minions attack the party.
 

IMHO extra hit points make a boss fight longer. They don't make it better, and 605 effective HP at CR 13 sounds like a long evening of the same three attacks to me.

What I'd want from the mythic trigger is a change in what the players are trying to do. Alzzin drops to zero and the room starts coming down, or it goes for whatever it was guarding, and now the party has a new problem on top of the hit points.

As a GM I don't use lots of fights (I am more of an investigative GM) but what I like is when one event in fight alters the reality the player characters know... Fighting becomes part of the session, not the only thing in the session
 

My group has bounced off of WotC content to a large degree, not only because there just isn't much released but other publishers are doing more experimental things, and boss mechanics are one of these things in particular. I think it might be Loot Tavern (my buddy buys all of the 3p content) who made a book with kaiju fights where there are different parts of the boss monster to target in different ways. Doing different things activate different modes or phases of the fight. IDK how the new WOW handles mythic mechanics now, but I've seen in handled in pretty interesting way outside of WotC books.
 

IMHO extra hit points make a boss fight longer. They don't make it better, and 605 effective HP at CR 13 sounds like a long evening of the same three attacks to me.

What I'd want from the mythic trigger is a change in what the players are trying to do. Alzzin drops to zero and the room starts coming down, or it goes for whatever it was guarding, and now the party has a new problem on top of the hit points.

As a GM I don't use lots of fights (I am more of an investigative GM) but what I like is when one event in fight alters the reality the player characters know... Fighting becomes part of the session, not the only thing in the session
Perhaps it wasn't clear in my right up, but the mythic trait also unlocks new actions and abilities. So as the fight progresses through the stages, the combat changes as the monsters abilities change. That covers some of your desire. As I mentioned in the OP, I wish they had brought back lair actions as that covers the rest of your desire. I still include them with my monsters.

Regarding hit points, most monsters above CR 11 or so have two few hit points and deal to little damage. A solo boss monster will drop in 1-1.5 rounds. IMO, that is not long enough to get what I want out of a boss monster. So more hit points are absolutely needed. Simply by staying in the fight longer the monster is better as everyone gets to experience some of the options the monster has. Also, with multiple stages and XP rewards you can stop at any point. You can end the fight at stage 1, stage 2, or all the way to stage 3. It just gives you options to continue the fight if needed.

Is 605 to much at CR 13? I am not sure, but in Mike Mearls recent podcast he noted he was throwing a 450 HP dragon at his level 11 group and was concerned it needed more hit points. So it seems to me like it might be in the right ballpark for some people.
 

Remove ads

Top