Which of these D&D classes would you take if you had to choose one?
  • Which of these D&D classes would you take if you had to choose one?


    From the upcoming A Touch More Class. For me, it’s the Savant all the way. Sherlock Holmes style!


    Comments 39 Comments
    1. Inchoroi's Avatar
      Inchoroi -
      The Lodestar is the one that I think sounds the most interesting; I actually read the Savant, but didn't like it. Just didn't wow me like I'd hoped it would. The Mahout was interesting as well, but not my cup of tea in general.
    1. Dausuul's Avatar
      Dausuul -
      Mahout, no question. A dedicated "pet master" class is one thing D&D lacks right now. There are pet master subclasses (beastmaster ranger, necromancer wizard, etc.), but each has a full-powered base class chassis, which means the pet is pretty limited in how strong it can be.

      The others all look to me like they should be subclasses; specialized variants on concepts that already exist.
    1. Hussar's Avatar
      Hussar -
      The gemini sounds like it has all sorts of interesting.
    1. Deiscent's Avatar
      Deiscent -
      I like the idea of the Mahout. D&D has too many flavorful and interesting monsters not to try something like this.
    1. J.M's Avatar
      J.M -
      Gemini could be fun. We’ve got a similar concept in my current campaign: a two-headed ogre. At the start of each session he rolls randomly (50/50) to determine which head is in control of the character. One of them is a brutish warrior, the other a mage. During the session the player can reroll once, and the GM can reroll once. It’s been a lot of fun at the table.
    1. Lucius Drake's Avatar
      Lucius Drake -
      I quite like the look of the Mahout as well. A good pet class could add a tonne to the game!
    1. Mistwell's Avatar
      Mistwell -
      Fate Bender
    1. 77IM's Avatar
      77IM -
      Tinkerer! When you reach level 20, you become a Tinkererer.
    1. Zardnaar's Avatar
      Zardnaar -
      Gemini was alright at lower levels mine was great. It started to fall off hard mid levels though.
    1. LuisCarlos17f's Avatar
      LuisCarlos17f -
      Gunfighter, manhout and tinkerer. The manhout is an interesting idea because some players like the idea of a monster pet like a old cartoon from childhood.

      ---

      The keys to create and design a new class:

      - Right balance of power, of course.

      - Fun gameplay, nothing of boring class features/game mechanics soon are forgotten by players soon.

      - Interesting background. A good class is like a cool cosplay, Halloween costume or clothings by urban tribes to show their own style or mark of personality.

      If you had to choose some "no-core" classes to be the main characters of a story (comic, cartoon serie, novel or movie), without nothing of game mechanic, only storytelling, which would you choose?
    1. doctorbadwolf's Avatar
      doctorbadwolf -
      Gunfighter and Tinkerer speak to me, but only if they don’t have to contend with rolling for chance of explosion-in-face or whatever.
    1. SilentWolf's Avatar
      SilentWolf -
      The Savant. D&D 5e lacks a pure mundane intelligent based Class. I would design it by drawing inspiration from the Expert described in the Sidekicks UA, but without excessive skills in combat (I would leave those for some Subclasses, like the Tactician).
    1. Connorsrpg's Avatar
      Connorsrpg -
      I tool like that Savant is an Intelligence based class, but the Mahout and Fate Bender are more my style.

      Not sure why but many of the 'names' of these classes to not speak to me at all. Just hearing the name does not tell me what they do. Without reading about them I would have no idea what sort of character half of these would be.
    1. Draegn's Avatar
      Draegn -
      I would consider these to be backgrounds.
    1. chaoshead87's Avatar
      chaoshead87 -
      I like the sounds of the Lodestar.
    1. Tom Miskey's Avatar
      Tom Miskey -
      Several interesting choices, but if I had to choose one, I think it'd be the Geomancer. Magical abilities and a need to use your environment in interesting and unique ways...
    1. Stacie GmrGrl's Avatar
      Stacie GmrGrl -
      Savant for me.
    1. Cergorach's Avatar
      Cergorach -
      Can we multiclass? Bloodweaver/Fatebender/Gemini for me please...
    1. collin's Avatar
      collin -
      The Savant or the Tinkerer for me.
    1. Eltab's Avatar
      Eltab -
      Fatebender sounds interesting - mess with the dice rolls.

      Since last session my d20 rolled '7' five rounds in a row. An extra boost would have been nice. Even a +1more would have been a hit !
    Comments Leave Comment