[PF2] Legendary or Magical

mellored said:

I have to say, I'm a bit surprised by the poll result. I expected something closer to an even split.

And while the sample size is still fairly small, it bodes well for the skill feats.

Click to expand...

Charlaquin said:

It's not that surprising, since both the pro-Legendary Feats and anti-Legendary Feats camp want rogues to not be magical. That's why I say I think the poll misses the crux of the disagreement.

Click to expand...

mellored said:

If you can do better, then do better.

Click to expand...

Charlaquin said:

I’d ask something along the lines of “the rogue jumped out of the tower and landed safely on the ground. Is this possible without an act of magic?”
• Yes
• No

Click to expand...

mellored said:

Meh..
That doesn't really tell what people prefer for their justification.

If I was doing another poll, I would have...

A rogue jumped out of a tall tower and
* lands safely due to his legendary skill (catfall).
* lands safely due to his magical spell (feather fall).
* lands safely due to his magical item (ring of feather fall).
* lands safely due to his supernatural/ki/psionic ability (slow fall).
* dies because of physics (realistic fall).
* other.

Click to expand...

zztong said:

> Something else (comment below).

Seriously though, if I'm playing the rogue, I don't want to jump from the tower using ability or magic unless its something like a 10 foot fall or maybe higher if I'm going to land in a hay wagon or water. Part of the fun playing a rogue, to me, is to succeed in normal and plausible ways. A super-heroic or magical rogue, to me, makes the rogue less interesting.

Click to expand...